The question of the week is:
What are one to three things you would tell your first-year teacher self, and why would it/they be important to tell?
In Part One, Ruth Okoye, Sheila Wilson, Cindy Garcia, and Ixchell Reyes kicked off this multipart series sharing reflections from veteran teachers.
In Part Two, Meghann Seril, Anabel Gonzalez, Kelly Owens, and Joy Russell shared their thoughts.
Today, it’s time for Neema Avashia and Jennifer Orr to make their contributions.
‘Compliance Is Not the Goal’
Neema Avashia is the daughter of Indian immigrants and was born and raised in the hills of southern West Virginia. She has been an educator in the Boston public schools since 2003, primarily as a civics and history teacher, and was a Boston educator of the year in 2013. This fall, she moves out of the classroom and into a coaching role, supporting ethnic-studies teachers across the same district:
This past June, instead of packing up my classroom, I dismantled it. Encouraged colleagues to come and take what they wanted, recycled, donated, and trashed whatever was left. This is the end of my 19th year teaching. For now, at least, it’s also the end of my time as a teacher. I have not returned to the classroom this fall.
If I’m honest, this moment has been coming for a while now. About five years ago, I began to battle with my school system in a way that I’d never had to previously. Sure, I’d pushed back against poor-quality assessments and microaggressive report card comments. I’d advocated hard for a nurse in every school and for changes that would make the transition to high school smoother for rising 9th graders. But I’d never felt the full force of a school system coming down on me the way it started to in the fall of 2017, when the Boston district announced that they were closing my school, scattering the staff and students, only to then renovate the school and give it over to another community to inhabit. In effect, we were being gentrified out of our school building.
The fight to stop that closure (which we won), followed by a subsequent fight to hold onto our students’ only access to green space for play (which we lost), followed by an initial COVID response plan that provided $19 box fans as the only source of ventilation while asking us to simultaneously teach online and in person, ultimately became too much. I felt as though my school district had become a giant fortress of ill logic, with thick brick walls, and my job was just to keep hurling myself into the wall in the hopes that I might break through and get us to solutions that made better sense, that took care of people instead of rendering harm down on them.
But eventually, the wall became too big. Too impenetrable. I wasn’t breaking through; I was breaking. I was less patient. Quicker to frustrate. Less able to bounce back from challenges at work and at home. My body has made it clear that it needs respite. Needs time to recover from repetitive impact. That the only thing I am equipped to do right now is to extend care: first to myself and then to my colleagues in this work.
Looking back on my career, I am struck by how much unlearning I have needed to do to get to this point. How much of what was initially communicated to me about education, about its goals, about how it is best done, was in fact entirely wrong. And how so many of these ideas continue to hold credence nearly two decades later, when in fact we should discard them and build anew.
1. Compliance is not the goal. I began teaching in 2003, right around the time when policies inspired by No Child Left Behind started to come down hard on students in classrooms all over the country. High-stakes testing, broken-windows policing, and “no excuses” strategies applied in classrooms in an effort to compete with charter schools that kicked out any students who “weren’t a good fit” for their learning environment. Use of standardized-testing data to measure teacher effectiveness. To shutter schools deemed “underperforming.” The result of this wave of punitive, fear-mongering policy was an obsessive focus on compliance in schools. If kids weren’t complying, then there was something wrong with them. They needed to be fixed. If they couldn’t be fixed, they needed to leave.
I grew up in rural, majority-white schools and became a teacher in city schools populated almost entirely by students of color. When I started this work, I didn’t possess the systems analysis that I needed to do this work well. Instead of listening hard to the part of me that wanted to center young people’s humanity, I aspired to the definition of “effective teaching” that the system articulated: one that prioritized urgency, prioritized results, prioritized compliance above all else. It took me far too long to unlearn ideas about schooling rooted in institutional racism. To reject the messaging passed down from administrators and leaders and society at large that our focus should be on getting students to comply with the increasingly oppressive rules and narrow curriculum that we were offering.
In truth, those students who were not complying were my best teachers. They were telling me, through their words, and their bodies, and their choices, exactly what didn’t work about school and why it didn’t work. They were pointing us all toward more liberatory models of education—ones that center relationships, agency, and relevance. But it took me too long to listen to them, to lift up what they were seeing, to imagine different ways for moving forward. And in the process, I lost too many of those students. We lose too many of those students. To push out. To overdoses and violence and incarceration. If I could go back, I would have started listening to those young people from the very beginning and building my classroom around what they said they wanted and needed.
2. Standardization is not the way to meaningful engagement. During my first year as a teacher, the director of curriculum and instruction for the city came to observe my classroom for a “curriculum-implementation review.” The goal was to see how effectively my teaching was aligned to the city’s pacing guide. Was I teaching the standards they said I needed to be teaching, during the week when they said to be teaching them, on the day when they believed they needed to be taught? The director wrote pages of praise for me after his observation, about how faithfully I was soldiering through what had been laid out. Looking back, I can only think about how both he, and I, were so wrong about that goal.
Because the most impactful lessons that students have taken away from my classroom have not been the ones that are dictated by a pacing guide. They are the ones that are responsive to context. They’ve happened in the moments when I’ve looked at what I’m “supposed to” be teaching and said, “Wait a minute. This isn’t right.” Or, “This is leaving key information out,” or, “I think kids need to feel this and not just read it,” and then worked to fill in the gaps.
The most powerful moment in learning the history of school desegregation for my students didn’t come from any book or video. It came from listening to Terrence Roberts speak with them about his experiences integrating Central High School. To understand the inhumanity of solitary confinement, my students read first-person testimonials, analyzed statistics, and crafted a response to a document-based question. But the reality of that experience didn’t hit home for students until I built a cube of 6x9 dimensions out of PVC pipe and placed it in my classroom so they would feel the intensity of being held within those walls for a few minutes, never mind 23 hours a day. To reflect on the long history of institutional racism in this country, and its continued impact, I gave students cardboard and glue and spray paint and watched with awe as they built incredible scale-model memorials that could be constructed to force Americans to confront and grapple with our hard history. When learning about hegemony, and how we resist it on the individual level, I brought in BIPOC friends and former students to talk through their experiences with navigating, and working in, dominant spaces.
Those moments were where the learning became most real. Where theoretical ideas and texts suddenly became solid, became lived, because we were living them with other people. I wish I could have created these opportunities earlier for my students. Created them more often. Understood earlier that it is through lived experience and human connection where the deepest learning happens, no matter what a pacing guide is telling you to do.
3. Exceptionalism is not the fix. I grew up as an exception—one of very few students of color in a majority-white context. A queer kid who didn’t have language or models to give name to my queerness. I think in a lot of ways this shaped my outlook on everything. I survived through sheer force of will. And I approached teaching this same way: as something I could excel at through sheer force of will.
I was wrong. Will is not sufficient. And closing your door to the big picture so that you can “just focus on teaching” is also not the solve. The systemic inequities that are coming down on young people, coming down on all of us, really, demand our attention and our energy. But battling them is not something any of us can do alone. It requires us to be in deep and sustained relationships with young people, with their families, and with people in the communities where our schools are situated. When I have succeeded in pushing back on unjust decisions in my school system, it has been because I’ve been working in concert with others, because we’ve listened hard to one another, and identified a shared way forward. And when I’ve failed, it’s because the foundation underneath the fight has been less solid.
The scale at which we are asked to work—the number of students, the number of preps, the lack of meaningful time during the school day for doing any of the important work—makes it incredibly difficult to build relationships in the ways we need to. It requires you to make conscious choices about how you use your time: In the choice between grading another stack of papers or having a conversation with a young person or family or colleague, the conversation, the relationship, needs to be the first choice. I didn’t understand this for too long. But if there’s nothing else you take from this, then take this unlearning: the most important work you can do as an educator is to focus on relationships. To let listening to the needs of the folks most impacted be the thing that drives every decision that you make.
I wish I could go back and tell my first-year teacher self: This work you are embarking on is a marathon without end. There is no “done.” There is no finite marker of success. There is just the choice you make every day to center the humanity of young people, of families, and of yourself in a context where humanity is least often the value driving decisionmaking.
‘You Are the Expert’
Jennifer Orr is in her third decade of teaching elementary school students in the suburbs of Washington. She is a national-board-certified teacher, mom to two teenagers, and an obsessive reader of books of all kinds:
Over the past two decades, I have been known to look back on my first year of teaching with much chagrin. I have been known to say, “If those 4th graders learned anything, it was in spite of me.” I don’t think it was truly terrible, but that year certainly paled in comparison with the years that followed.
Knowing that, knowing how difficult the first year can be for almost all of us, my first piece of advice for my first-year teacher self would be: Keep Work Samples. Take pictures or save documents or whatever to have examples of student work and learning. I did some of this my first year, and it was a gift to be able to look back, both throughout that year and in the years to come, and see tangible proof of all my students had achieved. It was also handy to have student examples of some things, poems, artwork, brochures, math strategies, to share with students in subsequent years. Having student work samples available to me is a lesson I learned early on, and I remain grateful for it.
The next thing I would tell my first-year teacher self would be: You Are the Expert. Even a first-year teacher knows far more than they think they do. It is easy to be intimidated by families and by colleagues and second guess what you are doing. Definitely reflect based on feedback you are getting but don’t question your own knowledge. Over the years, you will refine what you do based on that knowledge (and your ongoing learning), and in that first year, it can be hard to be as clear about why you are doing things as you might like to be. You are not alone in this, but, more importantly, it doesn’t mean you don’t know what you are doing. You do. Keep your students as your focus, work with your colleagues, and believe in your own expertise.
Finally, I wish first-year teacher me had been told that I didn’t have to give homework. That would have been so freeing. Don’t Give Homework. (I say this as an elementary educator.) In my first several years of teaching, I spent a ridiculous amount of time and energy on generating homework, collecting homework, badgering kids about homework, and grading homework. When I realized how often I desperately wanted to dump the whole pile in the recycling bin, I began to question my choices. A little research proved to me that I didn’t have to keep doing this. I knew, anecdotally, that the great majority of my students didn’t want to be doing homework any more than I wanted to be dealing with it. I knew, anecdotally, that many of their families would have been fine, or even ecstatic (those families fighting with their 4th grader over it every night), if I didn’t assign homework. So discovering that homework has no effect or a negligible effect on student achievement allowed me to dump it.
I can’t change that first year now and I’ve come to terms with that. Those of us with years of teaching experience under our belts can let first-year teachers know that they’re doing great. We can also give them permission to stop doing things they feel required to do or to, at a minimum, question things like homework. We can offer them that.
Thanks to Neema and Jennifer for contributing their thoughts!
Consider contributing a question to be answered in a future post. You can send one to me at firstname.lastname@example.org. When you send it in, let me know if I can use your real name if it’s selected or if you’d prefer remaining anonymous and have a pseudonym in mind.
You can also contact me on Twitter at @Larryferlazzo.
Education Week has published a collection of posts from this blog, along with new material, in an e-book form. It’s titled Classroom Management Q&As: Expert Strategies for Teaching.
Just a reminder; you can subscribe and receive updates from this blog via email (The RSS feed for this blog, and for all EdWeek articles, has been changed by the new redesign—new ones are not yet available). And if you missed any of the highlights from the first 11 years of this blog, you can see a categorized list below.
- It Was Another Busy School Year. What Resonated for You?
- How to Best Address Race and Racism in the Classroom
- Schools Just Let Out, But What Are the Best Ways to Begin the Coming Year?
- Classroom Management Starts With Student Engagement
- Teacher Takeaways From the Pandemic: What’s Worked? What Hasn’t?
- The School Year Has Ended. What Are Some Lessons to Close Out Next Year?
- Student Motivation and Social-Emotional Learning Present Challenges. Here’s How to Help
- How to Challenge Normative Gender Culture to Support All Students
- What Students Like (and Don’t Like) About School
- Technology Is the Tool, Not the Teacher
- How to Make Parent Engagement Meaningful
- Teaching Social Studies Isn’t for the Faint of Heart
- Differentiated Instruction Doesn’t Need to Be a Heavy Lift
- How to Help Students Embrace Reading. Educators Weigh In
- 10 Strategies for Reaching English-Learners
- 10 Ways to Include Teachers in Important Policy Decisions
- 10 Teacher-Proofed Strategies for Improving Math Instruction
- Give Students a Role in Their Education
- Are There Better Ways Than Standardized Tests to Assess Students? Educators Think So
- How to Meet the Challenges of Teaching Science
- If I’d Only Known. Veteran Teachers Offer Advice for Beginners
- Writing Well Means Rewriting, Rewriting, Rewriting
- Christopher Emdin, Gholdy Muhammad, and More Education Authors Offer Insights to the Field
- How to Build Inclusive Classrooms
- What Science Can Teach Us About Learning
- The Best Ways for Administrators to Demonstrate Leadership
- Listen Up: Give Teachers a Voice in What Happens in Their Schools
- 10 Ways to Build a Healthier Classroom
- Educators Weigh In on Implementing the Common Core, Even Now
- What’s the Best Professional-Development Advice? Teachers and Students Have Their Say
- Plenty of Instructional Strategies Are Out There. Here’s What Works Best for Your Students
- How to Avoid Making Mistakes in the Classroom
- Looking for Ways to Organize Your Classroom? Try Out These Tips
- Want Insight Into Schooling? Here’s Advice From Some Top Experts
I am also creating a Twitter list including all contributors to this column.
The opinions expressed in Classroom Q&A With Larry Ferlazzo are strictly those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.