School & District Management Opinion

School Closures Are Coming. What Not to Do

How to limit the damage to students from closing schools
By Douglas N. Harris & Valentina Martinez-Pabon — November 28, 2022 3 min read
Conceptual illustration of a falling BEWARE DROP sign
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

As schools work to stem COVID-related learning loss, they are also about to walk over a cliff—really, two cliffs—that could make matters worse. The “financial cliff” created by the drop-off of federal Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief (ESSER) funds is reasonably well known. The “enrollment cliff” is less well-known and underestimated. Falling off both cliffs at once means that school closures are looming—and education leaders need to limit the damage by keeping open high-performing schools.

Let us explain the enrollment cliff first. Many are familiar with the drops in enrollment in traditional public schools induced by COVID. But that’s only the tip of the iceberg. As a nation, we are amid a decadelong, steep decline in birthrates. The figure below shows fertility is now at its lowest rate in many decades—and probably the lowest nonwartime rate in recorded history.

image 20221122 184408

When birthrates decline, we see a drop in kindergarten enrollment five years later that tracks from one school grade to the next. Whether immigration will counteract this remains to be seen. Immigration rates dropped sharply during the 2015 to 2019 span and remained low in 2021, but the future of immigration policy is unclear. Either way, though, school enrollments are likely going to continue declining for at least several more years.

When school enrollments decline, school closures are quick to follow. In a study we published through the National Center for Research on Education Access and Choice, we found that about 1 percent of traditional public schools—some 1,300—close in a typical year (with higher percentages for charter and private schools). A main factor driving closure decisions, we found, is low enrollment. Education leaders avoid school closures at almost any cost, but sometimes their enrollment-driven budgets cannot bear the expense of all low-enrollment schools remaining open. And closing based on low enrollment creates disruption for the fewest people.

We must work hard to keep the most successful schools open.

But what about school quality as a deciding factor? A study from the Education Research Alliance for New Orleans (that involved Harris) showed that when schools are closed or taken over based on low achievement growth, students in the affected schools do at least as well or better in the long run because they end up in better schools. The set of school options available to future students is also improved.

You’ll notice that we said that closure in the New Orleans study was based on lack of achievement growth. Achievement growth is the best measure of how well schools help students learn. State accountability systems, unfortunately, still focus almost entirely on score levels. But school districts can make growth calculations themselves if need be. As a general rule, school leaders should never close a school with average or better growth. Doing so will only reduce future student learning for everyone.

Another advantage of focusing on student growth in the closure process is that the approach makes it less likely that schools serving low-income students or people of color will be disproportionately targeted. We saw this in the REACH research mentioned above. Student test-score levels are tightly correlated with these demographic features, but student-growth measures are not. So, when closures are necessary, doing it based on growth is also more equitable.

See Also

conceptual illustration of erased desks on a chalkboard
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
School & District Management Opinion Public School Enrollment Is Down by More Than a Million. Why?
Thomas S. Dee, November 2, 2022
5 min read

An official of one large school system recently told us that her district would focus on factors like enrollment size and building location—with no plan to consider school quality at all in the closure process. This is a mistake. We understand why factors like building age and low enrollments—fundamentally financial factors—have to be part of the conversation, but when all is said and done, a plan falls short if it saves money but doesn’t serve students in the best way possible given the financial constraints.

We have to remember that schools are organizations that are difficult to create and maintain. If a district has a great team in a failing building, it’s essential to keep that team together. One way to do that when closing schools is to move whole teams from one building to another to keep them—and their success—intact.

To be absolutely clear, we are not arguing to close schools. That should always be a last resort. We are saying this: In the face of the twin cliffs, financial and enrollment, when education leaders believe they have to close schools, they should do so carefully. Smart steps can mitigate the harm.

We have a long way to go to help students catch up post-pandemic and we can’t afford to make the problem worse by following faulty precedents and closing successful schools.

Related Tags:


Student Well-Being K-12 Essentials Forum Boosting Student and Staff Mental Health: What Schools Can Do
Join this free virtual event based on recent reporting on student and staff mental health challenges and how schools have responded.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Curriculum Webinar
Practical Methods for Integrating Computer Science into Core Curriculum
Dive into insights on integrating computer science into core curricula with expert tips and practical strategies to empower students at every grade level.
Content provided by Learning.com
Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management Opinion Why Principals Need to Talk About the Israel-Hamas War With Our Teachers
What can we do when a difficult topic is brought up by students in classrooms? First, don’t leave teachers to handle it in isolation.
S. Kambar Khoshaba
5 min read
Stylized photo illustration of a teacher feeling pressured as she is questioned by her students.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week via Canva
School & District Management Sometimes Principals Need to Make Big Changes. Here’s How to Get Them to Stick
School leaders need their community to take a leap of faith with them. But how do they build trust and conviction?
8 min read
Image of a leader reflecting on past and future.
akindo/DigitalVision Vectors
School & District Management A New Study Details Gender and Racial Disparities in the Superintendent's Office
Women and people of color are less likely than their white male counterparts to be appointed superintendent directly from a principal post.
6 min read
A conceptual image of a female being paid less than a male.
hyejin kang/iStock/Getty
School & District Management Late Arrivals, Steep Costs: Why Some Districts Ditch Third-Party Bus Companies
Districts are facing a host of transportation challenges. Some have addressed them by deciding to bring buses back in house.
6 min read
School buses parked in Helena, Mont., ahead of the beginning of the school year on Aug. 20, 2021.
Some districts are pulling back on decisions to outsource bus services in an effort to save money and improve service.
Iris Samuels/AP