Opinion Blog

Finding Common Ground

With Peter DeWitt & Michael Nelson

A former K-5 public school principal turned author, presenter, and leadership coach, Peter DeWitt provides insights and advice for education leaders. Former superintendent Michael Nelson is a frequent contributor. Read more from this blog.

School & District Management Opinion

3 Mistakes New Leaders Should Avoid

Don’t make promises you can’t keep
By Michael Nelson & Peter DeWitt — January 19, 2025 4 min read
Screen Shot 2025 01 16 at 5.28.27 PM
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

A new year. 2025. The beginning of each calendar year usually signals the start of the hiring process for vacancies in school and district leadership positions. Excitement abounds as applicants seek new leadership opportunities and districts anticipate the possibilities that new leaders bring.

Prospective leaders are filled with what they hope will be innovative ideas that catch the attention of an interested district. Districts envision “what could be” for students, staff, parents, and the community the successful applicant will serve.

Many hiring processes for school and district leadership positions are quite rigorous with multiple steps over the course of many days. Once the decision has been made and a new leader has been chosen, what top three actions should those new leaders take to be successful in meeting the needs for themselves and the district that hired them?

First, Seek to Understand

Many staff members and constituents will want to meet with a new leader after they are hired. Conversations will focus on the priorities of the district, their sacred cows, or their overall input on how the newly hired person should lead. These conversations are important and should be had, but a new leader also develops systems for garnering information from as many different staff members and constituents as possible. Listen and try not to make promises you cannot keep.

Seeking to understand also means gathering research. Researcher Victoria Berhardt has identified four types of data: Demographic, Perceptions, Student Learning, and School/District Process. In the early days after being hired, it is important for the leader to discover those data. Much of data in these three areas can be easily gathered for the new leader without much time or effort.

However, it’s Bernhardt’s fourth area of data where new leaders should focus their initial time and effort. They should establish key areas and questions to ask in each setting. This can be done in a variety of ways:

  • Individual interviews (with people inside and outside the school or school district)
  • Staff and community meetings
  • Surveys and questionnaires (can be differentiated for different employee groups, parents, and community members)
  • Presentations and perceptions sharing for civic and government organizations
  • Informal and unscheduled conversations

General themes from the perceptions data can be generated. The perceptions data can be cross-referenced into Bernhardt’s other categories, too. For example: Is it the perception that the district is doing well in the area of literacy but the student learning data say otherwise? This gives a new leader an opportunity to discover areas of disconnect in order to build a system of coherence.

Second, Communicate Consistently

Consistent communication is key for a new leader. Unlike an established leader whose staff, parents, and community will expect him/her to share content like direct progress toward goals or a response to a certain school or district policy, a new leader’s communication should be about connection. Leadership is about building relationships and establishing trust.

In Begin With Trust, Harvard professor Frances X. Frei says there are three drivers of trust, which are authenticity, empathy, and logic. People need to know that they are dealing with the authentic you, that you care about them, and they understand your logic.

A new leader needs to share all they are doing to show they are:

  • Excited about the position
  • Thrilled to be working with staff, parents, and the community
  • Transparent in how they are learning about the school/district
  • Committed to this new role by sharing their learning adventures in classrooms, schools, parent meetings, and community meetings

Communication for new leaders needs to be consistent and constant. Communication forms can take on a variety of forms:

  • Written communication such as letters, notes, and emails
  • One-minute videos
  • Phone messages
  • Website updates
  • Coffee with the new leader
  • Meet the new leader town halls
  • Speeches at staff meetings, PTA meetings, civic organizations, chamber of commerce, and city council

Third, Be Visible So You Can Listen and Communicate

One of the greatest compliments a new leader can receive is “he/she seems to be everywhere.” The rippling of this compliment will send a message throughout their school or district as well as the community. It shows they are committed to leading the building/district. Being visible is the overarching and foundational strategy of directly listening and communicating. Ask staff, parents, and community members where people gather and go to them.

Beginning a new leadership position is an exciting moment as it is an opportunity to use talents to inspire and lead with meaningful intention. By prioritizing listening, communicating, and visibility, new leaders can begin to develop a collective alignment to support student learning and the long-term success in their position.

The opinions expressed in Finding Common Ground With Peter DeWitt & Michael Nelson are strictly those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School Climate & Safety Webinar
There But Not Present: Rethinking Student Engagement
Learn how to recognize the early signs of disengagement and what the behavioral science reveals about which interventions actually work.
Content provided by Frontline Education
Teacher Preparation Webinar What Teacher Education Should Look Like in the Age of AI
Explore the current trends around the use of AI in teacher preparation and continuing education with data from the EdWeek Research Center.
English Learners Webinar How Can School Districts Better Support English Learners With Disabilities?
Join this webinar to hear recent findings from the EdWeek Research Center and discover practical strategies for improvement.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management From Our Research Center What We Know About School Board Members, In Charts
Many school board members are retired and have never worked in education before, survey shows.
1 min read
LOS ANGELES, CA - APRIL 21, 2026 : A board meeting at the Los Angeles Unified School District headquarters on Tuesday, April 21, 2026 , in Los Angeles, CA. The LAUSD met to discuss a resolution calling for development of a Screen Time Policy setting time limits by grade, including elimination of student digital devices for early education through first-grade, prohibiting device use by elementary and middle school students during passing periods, lunch and recess. The board unanimously voted to approve Board Member Nick Melvoin's Resolution to limit student screen time.
The Los Angeles Unified School District school board meets on April 21, 2026, to discuss whether to develop a policy to limit students' screen time. A new EdWeek Research Center survey shows that many school board members nationwide are retired and have never worked in K-12 education.
Kayla Bartkowski/Los Angeles Times
School & District Management The Best Books About Leadership These Educators Have Ever Read. What's Yours?
Critical lessons learned from books (and one TV show) about leadership.
8 min read
School & District Management Mamdani Says NYC Public Schools ‘Failed’ Nikole Hannah-Jones’ Daughter
In a recent essay, Hannah-Jones recounted her decision to enroll her daughter in a high-need school.
Cayla Bamberger, New York Daily News
•
3 min read
Journalist Nikole Hannah-Jones poses for a portrait at the headquarters of The Associated Press in New York on Dec. 10, 2021.
Journalist Nikole Hannah-Jones, shown at the headquarters of The Associated Press in New York on Dec. 10, 2021, recently wrote an essay in the Atlantic describing her selection of a high-poverty school in New York City for her daughter, and their subsequent disappointment with that experience. Hannah-Jones' piece received widespread attention, and this week Mayor Zohran Mamdani called the piece "devastating" and said it pointed to a need for improvements to the school system.
Robert Bumsted/AP
School & District Management ‘Are They Getting Distracted?’: A New Spotlight on How School Boards Vote
A national dashboard will track school boards’ voting records on contentious issues.
5 min read
A collage-style illustration of a photo of raised hands at a meeting and a grid of three smaller images overlaid on a piece grid paper, showing the patch of an ICE agent's vest, two young students holding a pride flag, and a stack of books. Clippings of ballots with "yes" and "no" boxes filled out are also placed on the grid paper.
Illustration by Emily Wright for Education Week + Getty