Special Report
Assessment From Our Research Center

It’s Hard to Shift to Competency-Based Learning. These Strategies Can Help

By Mark Lieberman — September 16, 2024 6 min read
A collage of a faceless student sitting and writing in notebook with stacks of books, math equations, letter grades and numbers all around him.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

School districts in every state now have the green light to establish competency-based education programs and models in their classrooms—but they have a lot of work to do on the operational side to make those efforts worth the investment of time and money.

Competency-based education refers to a diverse set of practices by which schools give students opportunities to learn at their own pace to master specific skills, often through projects of their choosing that dovetail with their interests. Several states have offered funding to schools to help them get competency-education programs off the ground, including Iowa, North Carolina, and Oregon.

Educators are interested in the model and supportive of some of its key components, even if largely unfamiliar with the practice.

Forty-one percent of educators in a recent EdWeek Research Center survey said they’d read about competency-based education but never seen it in action or tried it. Another 26 percent said they’d never heard of it before taking the nationally representative survey of 868 educators, which was conducted May 29 to June 19.

In a sign of their interest, 56 percent of survey respondents said they’d like to learn more about it, and another 13 percent said they know something about it and would like to try it. (Nineteen percent said they had no interest at all.)

Also, a majority of survey respondents said that, in five years, they expect their district or school to have at least taken steps toward adoption of competency-based education in some form.

But many are concerned about potential roadblocks to making the most of funding opportunities designed to help districts transition to competency-based education.

Slightly more than half of survey respondents said a major drawback to pursuing competency-based education is that teachers don’t know how to do it. Forty-two percent said eliminating traditional grades would confuse parents and students about how much learning had taken place.

More than a third of respondents said their schools cannot afford the staffing necessary to pull off a transformation of their district’s learning model. And slightly less than a quarter say school buildings would need to be improved in ways that would be too costly. Additional costs might come, for instance, from adding instructional space to allow more students to learn outside the traditional learning model and investing in technology students can use to learn at their own pace.

A note about this model of instruction

Competency-based education, proficiency-based learning, mastery-based learning, personalized learning, student-centered education, and standards-based education are all terms that refer to the same instructional model: one in which students make choices about how they learn and demonstrate their knowledge, learn at a pace that might differ from their classmates’, receive individualized support based on their needs, and progress based on their mastery of course material instead of seat time.
See the Aurora Institute’s definition of competency-based education for more details.

Experts on competency-based education say implementing the model is often tougher in a district where most staff members have no experience with it, or where they even lack familiarity with the concept.

“Schools and districts with a strong prior standards-based culture had an easier time adapting,” said Amy Johnson, an education professor at the University of Southern Maine who has conducted extensive research on schools’ implementation of competency-based learning.

But there are approaches that work. They take time, patience, and often money.

Roughly two-thirds of educators who answered the EdWeek Research Center survey said the emphasis in competency-based education on measuring achievement by skills mastered rather than time spent in school is a benefit. Sixty percent said the same about the opportunity for students to learn at a rate that works for them.

“When competency-based systems are implemented well, they end the paradigm of teachers feeling that they need to go into the classrooms and teach all day by themselves, that they alone are responsible for whether their students fail or thrive,” said Kate Gardoqui, senior associate for the Maine-based nonprofit Great Schools Partnership, which helps schools in several states transform their teaching and learning models. “It sends the exact opposite message to teachers.”

Here are some of the operational moves districts implementing competency-based education should consider making—and the hurdles they might encounter along the way, according to practitioners.

Get everyone on the same page

Teachers, principals, district leaders, students, and parents all need to understand their district’s specific definition of competency-based learning for the new initiative to take hold, said Gardoqui, who helped lead the transition to competency-based learning at a high school in Maine where she was an English teacher in the early 2010s.

Each school needs to have a set of clearly delineated definitions for practices like grading and reporting. No one should have to wonder what it means to be successful in school.

That would represent a marked contrast to the status quo in many schools. “Kids will often be like, everybody knows who the easy graders and the hard graders are,” Gardoqui said. “Parents will say the same thing.”

Eliminating that uncertainty helps students understand what’s expected of them. District officials can also use these changes to pitch the new initiative to parents and community members as an effort to ensure all students have comparable experiences in the classroom.

Develop a portrait of a graduate, and orient students toward it

Instructional staff next have to develop master lists of all the skills students should have before they graduate. The language from those lists can filter down into classrooms and parent-teacher conferences.

But those lists don’t materialize overnight, in large part because staff have other pressing responsibilities that get in the way. Some schools in New York City, for instance, have taken a decade to develop them because teachers and staff there had so many other responsibilities to juggle, Gardoqui said.

See Also

Image of attributes of a graduate.
Parker Shatkin for Education Week with iStock/Getty
States More States Are Creating a 'Portrait of a Graduate.' Here's Why
Libby Stanford, December 11, 2023
8 min read

Schools don’t have to do all this work on their own. Many find success participating in collaboratives like the one Gardoqui helps lead in Washington state. Others seed the ground for a schoolwide competency-based model by allowing it to develop from the ground up in one or two departments that are particularly eager to forge ahead with it.

“Once one department is using those practices, they can become a little easier to spread those out across the school,” Gardoqui said.

Be open to the potential benefits

Investing in new programs can be daunting, especially when a payoff could be years away.

But proponents of competency-based learning see the potential for these initiatives to cut down on the amount of time and money schools spend trying to identify students who need additional support.

“When you have a gradebook that tracks more accurately where students are in their learning, and who needs help, you can get appropriate supports to students more quickly and more effectively,” Gardoqui said.

Competency-based education programs also encourage more direct collaboration with families, said Paulina Murton, the executive director of Great Schools Partnership. That could give schools a leg up when it comes time to ask community members to support additional school funding by raising property taxes or approving bond issues.

Similarly, Murton sees competency-based learning as a potential tool to help improve retention of teaching staff, a steep and ongoing challenge in many parts of the country. If teachers feel more connected and aligned with each other, they’re more likely to want to stick around in their school building.

“When we put students in the driver’s seat of their own learning, we can see a big increase in engagement,” Gardoqui said. “That’s just worth its weight in gold.”

education week logo subbrand logo RC RGB

Data analysis for this article was provided by the EdWeek Research Center. Learn more about the center’s work.

A version of this article appeared in the September 25, 2024 edition of Education Week as It’s Hard to Shift to Competency-Based Learning. These Strategies Can Help

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
(Re)Focus on Dyslexia: Moving Beyond Diagnosis & Toward Transformation
Move beyond dyslexia diagnoses & focus on effective literacy instruction for ALL students. Join us to learn research-based strategies that benefit learners in PreK-8.
Content provided by EPS Learning
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Teaching Webinar
Cohesive Instruction, Connected Schools: Scale Excellence District-Wide with the Right Technology
Ensure all students receive high-quality instruction with a cohesive educational framework. Learn how to empower teachers and leverage technology.
Content provided by Instructure
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School Climate & Safety Webinar
How to Use Data to Combat Bullying and Enhance School Safety
Join our webinar to learn how data can help identify bullying, implement effective interventions, & foster student well-being.
Content provided by Panorama Education

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Assessment A District’s Experiment: What Happens When Schools Do Less Testing?
Los Angeles Unified will excuse some schools from periodic assessments. Supporters hope it will inspire new ways to measure learning.
6 min read
An illustration on a red background of a silhouette of an individual carrying a ladder and walking away from a white arrow shaped sign post, with an arrow facing the opposite direction that has been cut out within the arrow shaped sign with cut pieces of paper on the ground below it.
DigitalVision Vectors
Assessment From Our Research Center What Educators Have to Say About Competency-Based Education
Teachers, principals, and district leaders shared skepticism and optimism for the learning model.
1 min read
Miles Matheny, left, and Lillian Archilla research and create a presentation on Elon Musk and Walt Disney, respectively, during class at California Area Elementary School in Coal Center, Pa., on May 16, 2024.
Miles Matheny, left, and Lillian Archilla research and create presentations about Elon Musk and Walt Disney, respectively, during class at California Area Elementary School in Coal Center, Pa., on May 16, 2024.
Jaclyn Borowski/Education Week
Assessment Explainer What Is Standards-Based Grading, and How Does It Work?
Schools can retool to make instruction more personalized and student-centered. But grading is a common sticking point.
11 min read
A collage of two faceless students sitting on an open book with a notebook and laptop. All around them are numbers, math symbols and pieces of an actual student transcript.
Nadia Radic for Education Week
Assessment Letter to the Editor Are Advanced Placement Exams Becoming Easier?
A letter to the editor reflects on changes to the College Board's Advanced Placement exams over the years.
1 min read
Education Week opinion letters submissions
Gwen Keraval for Education Week