Special Report
Special Education

Charters: An Uneasy Fit

By Caroline Hendrie — January 08, 2004 8 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Tailored for children with autism, the Princeton House Charter School in center-city Orlando is exempt from the A-to-F state system of school grading that strikes fear in so many Florida educators’ hearts. But don’t think Carol Tucker is unaccountable for results.

As the principal of a school of choice, Tucker has someone to answer to: Princeton House would be out of business if the parents of its 190 students decided to pull their children out.

On a more nuts-and-bolts level, though, there’s the raft of performance targets laid out in the schools’ charter from the Orange County school district. A “compliance monitor” from the district’s special education office is assigned to see that the school meets those goals, as well as the complex web of federal, state, and local requirements that flow from the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.

“Some of these kids have 25 pages of IEP goals,” says Tucker, referring to the individualized education plans required for students with disabilities under the IDEA. “We have a lot of rules and regulations we have to follow.”

The idea of breaking free from rules and regulations has been near and dear to the charter school movement since it got rolling in the early 1990s. Yet what many charter schools have discovered, often the hard way, is that the IDEA is one piece of red tape that they simply can’t cut.

“Here’s this highly prescriptive, process-oriented law that kind of hits them in the facet says Elizabeth A. Giovannetti, the vice president for education program design at New American Schools, a nonprofit school improvement organization in Alexandria, Va., and an expert on students with disabilities in charter schools. “They are out there to open new doors to learning. But it’s like, ‘Don’t get too excited; you’ve got to do all these little things, in this order, for this group of kids.’”

Ensuring that charter schools get all those things done has proved to be a challenge not just for the schools themselves, but also for the states and districts where the independent but publicly financed schools have taken root.

“Autonomy versus regulation is the basic tension,” says Eileen M. Ahearn, who has studied how charter schools serve youngsters with disabilities as the project director for the National Association of State Directors of Special Education.

Complicating matters is the marked variety from state to state over such issues as whether charter schools are considered their own local education agencies for special education purposes or are under the wing of school districts. Just who is responsible for what in serving special education students in charter schools is sometimes unclear, and sorting matters out is often made harder by the chilly relations between charter and other public schools in many states and communities.

“Special education has been implemented for over 25 years in regular public schools, and now we have charter schools that have to hit the ground running and deal with things that they probably never thought they would have to deal with,” Ahearn says. “This is the one mandated area that no one can avoid.”

Dearth of Data

Little hard information exists to compile a national scorecard, or even state-level ones in most cases, on how well the nation’s 3,000 charter schools are meeting the needs of children with disabilities.

A federally commissioned study found that in 2000-01, roughly 12 percent of charter school students had IEPs, a figure close to the nearly 13 percent of students enrolled in special education programs nationwide that year. But less is known about the achievement levels of students with disabilities in charter schools, partly because the number of such children in individual charter schools often is too small to be broken out.

“When we look at students with special needs, there’s really not a whole lot of information,” says Dean Kern, the director of the US. Department of Education’s charter schools program.

Still, researchers studying the intersection of charter schools and special education have found some national patterns.

With their smaller-than-average size, for example, charter schools often confront capacity problems not experienced by many district-run schools. And as schools of choice, they present challenges to a national special education system grounded in the principle that parents and education professionals share decisionmaking authority through the IEP teams required by federal law.

Among the many types of charter schools are those that have made serving children with special needs their primary mission. Here in Florida’s Orange County, for instance, Tucker’s school is just one of seven charter schools tailored to children with disabilities. Another two of the county’s 16 charter schools enroll many students with disabilities, with a goal of educating them alongside their peers without disabilities.

Yet most charter schools do not cater to children requiring special education, and by many accounts, those schools have a mixed record in responding to such youngsters’ needs. In some places, charter schools and the agencies that authorize them have devoted close attention to the issue.

For instance, the District of Columbia Public Charter School Cooperative offers training and promotes collaborative approaches to special education in Washington’s flourishing charter sector, in a manner akin to the regional special education agencies that have long served school districts.

At the same time, many charter schools are floundering when it comes to special education. “There are hundreds of charter schools that are saying, ‘We give up,’ and they just aren’t even attempting to provide services,” says Kern, a strong supporter of charter schools.

To him, that suggests a need for charter operators to rethink their approaches toward children with disabilities, and for special educators to consider new ways of holding charter schools accountable for serving them.

“Maybe we’re trying to fit charter schools into a framework that needs to be changed,” Kern says.

Degrees of Separation

From her sixth-story corner office in the 152,000-student Orange County district’s high-rise headquarters here in Orlando, special education chief Harriet P. Brown-Birk tries to keep a close eye on the district’s 16 charter schools.

“The charters have the choice to do a lot of innovative things,” says Brown-Birk, a lawyer who specialized in IDEA cases when in private practice. “But you don’t get a choice if it’s a federal mandate.”

There are hundreds of charter schools saying, ‘We give up,’ and they just aren’t even attempting to provide services.

Despite their watchdog role, Brown-Birk and her staff generally get good marks from local charter operators. “We have a compliance monitor who is very helpful,” says Princeton House’s Tucker.

That kind of collaboration comes more easily in Florida than in some other states, in part because charter schools are considered part of their local districts instead of their own local education agencies. By many accounts, LEA status—largely determined by state law—is a critical factor in how charter schools approach special education.

If a charter school is considered its own local agency, as is the case in many states, it must arrange and pay for the services needed by the children with disabilities that it enrolls, according to a 2001 study by the National Association of State Directors of Special Education.

That obligation can even involve picking up the tab for placing its students in private educational programs, just as a school district might have to do, notes the study, called “Project SEARCH: Special Education as Requirements in Charter Schools.”

For that and other reasons, the study recommended that the status of charter schools as free-standing local education agencies “be reconsidered for purposes of special education.”

In Arizona, where charter schools are considered their own local agencies, the state special education office has been stretched thin as it tries to keep tab on the state’s nearly 500 charter schools.

“Before the charter school movement, we monitored 15 to 20 school districts a year,” says Lynn M. Busenbark, the Arizona education department’s director of program support for exceptional-student services. “We now do 85 to 100 LEAs a year.”

To help manage that caseload, the state now requires new charter operators to receive training on special education, and it pays outside mentors to follow up with each school.

The education department’s special education staff has also worked closely with the Arizona State Board· for Charter Schools to make sure that charter applicants spell out in detail how they will approach special education, a requirement that is becoming increasingly common in other states.

In the Sunshine State, meanwhile, charter schools often turn to the Florida Charter School Resource Center for guidance in managing special education.

Housed at the University of South Florida in Tampa, the state-supported center receives federal IDEA money and is headed by Cathy Wooley-Brown, a former special education director in the Polk County, Fla., school district. The technical-assistance center makes special education a priority in the training and other resources it offers the state’s charter schools. According to state education department data, more than 260 charter schools are open and operating in Florida. In one workshop during the 2002-03 school year, for instance, the center brought together Orange County compliance monitors and staff members from local charter schools.

“I don’t think charter schools are saying we don’t want those regulations,” says Wooley-Brown, who is active nationally on the issue of special education in charter schools. “I think they’re trying to find a way to balance all those requirements against running a little, itty-bitty school.”

However elusive that balance might be, some experts believe that striking it is crucial, if charter schools are going to offer viable options for some of the country’s most vulnerable children.

“What we want is to be able to really take advantage of the independence of charter schools to be creative,” says Giovannetti of New American Schools. “But if we don’t shore up the ability of charter schools to do that, then we curtail their ability to fully serve students with disabilities in ways that a regular public school system may not be able to.”

In March 2024, Education Week announced the end of the Quality Counts report after 25 years of serving as a comprehensive K-12 education scorecard. In response to new challenges and a shifting landscape, we are refocusing our efforts on research and analysis to better serve the K-12 community. For more information, please go here for the full context or learn more about the EdWeek Research Center.

A version of this article appeared in the January 08, 2004 edition of Education Week


School Climate & Safety K-12 Essentials Forum Strengthen Students’ Connections to School
Join this free event to learn how schools are creating the space for students to form strong bonds with each other and trusted adults.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Creating Confident Readers: Why Differentiated Instruction is Equitable Instruction
Join us as we break down how differentiated instruction can advance your school’s literacy and equity goals.
Content provided by Lexia Learning
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
IT Infrastructure & Management Webinar
Future-Proofing Your School's Tech Ecosystem: Strategies for Asset Tracking, Sustainability, and Budget Optimization
Gain actionable insights into effective asset management, budget optimization, and sustainable IT practices.
Content provided by Follett Learning

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Special Education The Pros and Cons of AI in Special Education
AI can make special educators' jobs easier by handling paperwork and serving as an adaptive tool. But there are privacy and other concerns.
9 min read
Student being assisted by AI
Nicole Xu for Education Week
Special Education These Grants Could Help Students With Disabilities Access Jobs, Training
The Ed. Dept. is investing $236 million to help with transitions to careers and post-secondary education.
3 min read
Collage of a woman in a wheelchair on a road leading to a large dollar sign. In the woman's hair is a ghosted photo of hands on a laptop.
Collage by Gina Tomko/Education Week + Getty
Special Education Download DOWNLOADABLE: Does Your School Use These 10 Dimensions of Student Belonging?
These principles are designed to help schools move from inclusion of students with disabilities in classrooms to true belonging.
1 min read
Image of a group of students meeting with their teacher. One student is giving the teacher a high-five.
Laura Baker/Education Week via Canva
Special Education Inside a School That Doesn’t Single Out Students With Special Needs
Students with disabilities at this school near Seattle rarely have to leave mainstream rooms to receive the services they need.
8 min read
During recess at Ruby Bridges Elementary School in Woodinville, Wash., students have cards with objects and words on them so that all students, including those who cannot speak, can communicate. Pictured here on April 2, 2024.
During recess at Ruby Bridges Elementary School in Woodinville, Wash., students have access to cards with objects and words on them so that all students, including those who do not speak, can communicate. Pictured here, a student who has been taught how to lead and use commands with a campus service dog does so under the supervision of a staff member on April 2, 2024.
Meron Menghistab for Education Week