Federal

What 3 Former Education Secretaries Think of Their Old Department’s Future

By Brooke Schultz — January 21, 2025 6 min read
Former U.S. Secretaries of Education Arne Duncan, John King, and Margaret Spellings discuss the future of the U.S. Department of Education.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Amid growing calls—and even some early legislation—to dissolve the U.S. Department of Education, three former secretaries who ran the agency under a Republican and a Democratic president agreed that while some reform could be warranted, its work remained crucial, particularly as the nation’s students struggle to regain academic ground lost in recent years and schools report stubbornly high absenteeism.

Though President Donald Trump’s attempt in his first term to end the department—through a merger with the Department of Labor—eventually dissipated, he breathed new life into longstanding Republican calls to eliminate the agency during his 2024 campaign.

But, in a wide-ranging discussion hosted by the Brown Center on Education Policy at the Brookings Institution on Jan. 21, former education secretaries Margaret Spellings, John King Jr., and Arne Duncan argued that the department’s role in civil rights, data collection for accountability, and improving outcomes remain as important as ever.

See Also

People walk outside the U.S Capitol building in Washington, June 9, 2022.
People walk outside the U.S Capitol building in Washington, June 9, 2022. Legislation has been introduced in the Senate to abolish the Department of Education.
Patrick Semansky/AP

“I always say that the great military is our best defense as a nation, and a great education system is our best offense,” said Duncan, who served under Democratic President Barack Obama.

Here are some of the topics they tackled during the discussion.

The next secretary of education: Linda McMahon

Trump tapped Linda McMahon—the former World Wrestling Entertainment Inc. CEO and U.S. Small Business Administration leader—to serve as his second education secretary. Proponents of her appointment have said her business acumen will serve her well coming into the department, which oversees $1.6 trillion in federal student loans. Meanwhile, the nation’s largest teachers’ union, the National Education Association, called on the U.S. Senate to reject her appointment, saying she is unqualified due to a thin resume in public education.

Her background, however, could be a boon for department initiatives to focus on career preparation through community colleges and apprenticeships—a continuation of Biden administration efforts, Spellings said.

“I think that’s a place where we can find common cause, absolutely, with the Congress,” said Spellings, who served during Republican President George W. Bush’s second term. “Frankly, the Biden administration did a lot on that as well. So there’s some draft around workforce.”

Part of the job is using the bully pulpit and focusing public attention, said King, who served during Obama’s second term after Duncan stepped down.

See Also

Small Business Administrator Linda McMahon speaks during a briefing at the White House in Washington on Oct. 3, 2018.
Linda McMahon speaks during a briefing at the White House in Washington on Oct. 3, 2018, when she was serving as head of the Small Business Administration during President Trump's first administration. McMahon is now President-elect Trump's choice for U.S. secretary of education.
Susan Walsh/AP

“I think one question for Secretary McMahon will be: How does she want to use her bully pulpit? What is the thing she wants to elevate? I hope it will be urgency about improving outcomes, because that is a threat to the long-term health of our economy and our democracy. But that is a lever she can use, and she should think very carefully about how she wants to use it.”

Though McMahon hasn’t had any classroom experience herself, she’ll be joined in leadership by a seasoned educator—Penny Schwinn, the former Tennessee education commissioner whom Trump has tapped as deputy education secretary. Duncan described her as “a serious person; she’s smart, she cares about kids.”

“I am concerned about lots and lots and lots of things with the Trump administration. But today, I’m a little less concerned on the education side,” Duncan continued.

Concerns about the department getting pulled into ‘culture wars’

The three former agency heads spoke after Trump, on his first day back at the White House, had already begun flexing his executive muscle, issuing orders on diversity, equity, and inclusion; gender identity; and immigration.

King worries about the students those orders will affect: undocumented students, or students who have family members who are undocumented; LGBTQ+ students; and low-income students and students of color, who continue to achieve at lower levels than their white and higher-income peers.

“All of us need to be asking, who’s championing the needs of those most vulnerable students?” King said.

The department’s office for civil rights, which enforces federal civil rights laws in schools that receive federal funding, has been essential in fighting for those students, Duncan said.

During Trump’s first administration, students’ discrimination complaints related to sexual orientation and gender identity were less likely to result in changes at their schools than during the Obama administration, federal records showed. And the Education Department during Trump’s first term also confirmed it would not investigate complaints about restroom access for transgender students, which drew ire from civil rights groups.

Now, Trump has made clear that he doesn’t view Title IX—the nation’s law prohibiting sex discrimination at schools—as protecting students against discrimination based on gender identity and sexual orientation.

“If somehow OCR is weaponized … on just issues that have nothing to do with anything, it’s tremendously destructive and a huge waste of time and energy,” Duncan said.

A sense of urgency in tackling declining achievement

Both the Bush and Obama administrations pursued sweeping K-12 reform and accountability measures, with Bush’s No Child Left Behind Act creating a federal, test-based accountability system and Obama’s Race to the Top grant competition emphasizing preferred school reforms.

Today, after reading and math scores have hit their lowest levels in decades and chronic absenteeism has remained stubbornly high, the federal Department of Education needs to bring more urgency to fighting those problems, the former secretaries agreed.

“Let’s get back to talking about how well are students performing and reading, and math, those fundamental skills,” Spellings said. “I think we can all agree on those first principles without getting distracted by some of these red herring matters.”

See Also

U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona speaks during “The Impact: Our Fight for Public Education” event at the Department of Education’s headquarters in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 14, 2025.
U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona speaks during “The Impact: Our Fight for Public Education” event at the Department of Education’s headquarters in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 14, 2025. The event served as the capstone to Cardona's four years as education secretary under President Joe Biden.
Alyssa Schukar for Education Week
Federal As Biden Leaves Office, What Will His Education Legacy Be?
Brooke Schultz, January 15, 2025
12 min read

Perception of the department around hot-button issues like student loans

All three former secretaries entered the job with a focus on K-12 achievement, but they all learned in their tenures “that, really, the big bulk of the work at the Department of Education is focused on administering these very large loan and grant programs,” Spellings said.

Those programs are what influence public opinions about the agency.

The two biggest-ticket items for K-12 schools are Title I, an $18.4 billion program that sends money to schools to help low-income students, and IDEA, a $14.2 billion program that helps schools pay for special education services. IDEA also lays out the requirements schools need to follow in providing special education.

The department also oversees the federal student aid program and trillions of dollars in student loans.

The Biden administration’s bungled rollout of a simplified Free Application for Student Federal Aid, or FAFSA, became a dark cloud hanging over the department and undermined its credibility, Spellings said.

The Pew Research Center found in 2024 that the American public had a mixed view of the Department of Education, with 44 percent viewing it favorably, and just about as many—45 percent—holding an unfavorable view.

“I think there’s a real gap between the customer service side of the department and then the things that the department funds,” King said.

“I think there’s near unanimous support—both sides of the aisle—for IDEA and additional funding to support students with disabilities,” he said. “On the customer service side, the experience of so many Americans is the FAFSA and student loans, and that is not a positive, generally customer service experience, particularly recently.”

That’s one thing King hopes McMahon will tackle with her business background: working with Congress to secure the right resources and staffing to improve the public’s experience with the student loan system.

Events

School & District Management Webinar Fostering Productive Relationships Between Principals and Teachers
Strong principal-teacher relationships = happier teachers & thriving schools. Join our webinar for practical strategies.
Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and K-12 education jubs at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Artificial Intelligence Webinar
Promoting Integrity and AI Readiness in High Schools
Learn how to update school academic integrity guidelines and prepare students for the age of AI.
Content provided by Turnitin

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal Ed. Dept. Says SEL Can 'Veil' Discrimination. What Does This Mean for Schools?
A document from the Education Department flags social-emotional learning—a once bipartisan education strategy—as a means of discrimination.
Deeper learning prepares students to work collaboratively and direct their own learning.
There has been an uptick in political pushback against social-emotional learning, with the Education Department recently saying some schools "have sought to veil discriminatory policies" with terms like SEL.
Allison Shelley for All4Ed
Federal Civil Rights, Research, and More: What’s Hit Hardest by Massive Ed. Dept. Cuts
An analysis of the Trump administration's cuts to the agency shows its civil rights enforcement and research arms are hit particularly hard.
Chloe Kienzle of Arlington, Va., holds a sign as she stands outside the headquarters of the U.S. Department of Eduction, which were ordered closed for the day for what officials described as security reasons amid large-scale layoffs, Wednesday, March 12, 2025, in Washington.
Chloe Kienzle of Arlington, Va., holds a sign as she stands outside the headquarters of the U.S. Department of Education on Wednesday, March 12, 2025, in Washington. The department this week said it was cutting nearly half its staff.
Mark Schiefelbein/AP
Federal Opinion The Threat to Federal School Data Is a Threat to Us All
The erosion of this fundamental information will create immediate blind spots for districts and states.
Ronald L. Wasserstein
6 min read
A bar graph melts into a puddle.
iStock/Getty Images
Federal Ed. Dept. Will Shed Nearly Half Its Staff in Massive Reduction Under Trump
The U.S. Department of Education announced Tuesday it was getting rid of nearly half its staff through a variety of measures.
6 min read
The exterior of the Department of Education Building in Washington, DC on Thursday, December 14, 2017.
The exterior of the Department of Education building in Washington on Thursday, December 14, 2017. The department's Washington office and regional offices will be closed on Wednesday for "security reasons," according to an email sent to staff members.
Swikar Patel/Education Week