Law & Courts

Appeals Court Upholds Connecticut’s Pro-Transgender Student Athletics Policy

By Mark Walsh — December 16, 2022 3 min read
A multiple exposure of a wooden gavel and a long row of columns from a courthouse.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

A federal appeals court on Friday upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit challenging Connecticut’s policy that allows transgender girls to compete in girls’ sports, holding that the cisgender female track athletes challenging the policy lacked legal standing and that the state athletics body could not have been on notice that its policy potentially violated Title IX.

The unanimous decision in the high-profile case of Soule v. Connecticut Association of Schools, by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit, in New York City, is modest in scope in the sense that the court did not outright decide whether the pro-transgender policy should be upheld—or as the plaintiffs argued, struck down—under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, which bars sex discrimination in federally funded education programs.

The appeals court did, however, appear to express agreement with the interpretation that Title IX does protect transgender students. As the debate over transgender students rights and battles over whether transgender female athletes may compete at the highest levels of interscholastic sports rages on, the decision is likely to be scrutinized closely.

The 2nd Circuit panel upheld the district court decision that the case was moot because two prominent transgender track athletes, Andraya Yearwood and Terry Miller, had graduated from high school and the four cisgender female athletes who objected to the transgender-inclusive policy of the Connecticut Interscholastic Athletics Association were unlikely to have to compete against other transgender girls before they graduated.

The appeals court also rejected arguments by the cisgender female athletes that state athletic records should be corrected because the association’s policy deprived them of “the chance to be champions.”

The court noted that the cisgender track athletes sometimes defeated Yearwood and Miller in state competitions.

“Revising the records would not give plaintiffs ‘a chance to be champions’,” Judge Denny Chin wrote for the panel. “Plaintiffs have not shown that there is a proper legal framework for invalidating or altering records achieved by student-athletes who competed in conformity with the applicable rules.”

The appeals court went on to hold that the athletics association, a recipient of federal funding subject to Title IX, was not on notice that its policy might violate the federal anti-discrimination law. The court noted that guidance from the U.S. Department of Education’s office for civil rights has “fluctuated” under the administrations of Presidents Donald Trump and Joe Biden.

See also

Sivan Kotler-Berkowitz, 17, a transgender student-athlete, plays soccer with his brother, Lev, at a Massachusetts park on Sept. 3, 2022.
Sivan Kotler-Berkowitz, 17, a transgender student-athlete, plays soccer at a Massachusetts park.
Angela Rowlings for Education Week

“Even when promulgating and rescinding its uidance, OCR never clearly provided that allowing transgender students to participate on athletic teams consistent with their gender identity violates Title IX,” Chin said.

The 2nd Circuit recognized the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Bostock v. Clayton County, which held that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects employees based on sexual orientation and gender identity. Chin noted that several lower courts have ruled that Title IX, which has similar language on sex discrimination as Title VII, protects transgender students in schools.

“Although these cases from our sister circuits do not address the exact issue of participation of transgender athletes on gender-specific sports teams, such authority nonetheless establishes that discrimination based on transgender status is generally prohibited under federal law, and further supports the conclusion that the CIAC and its member schools lacked clear notice that the policy violates Title IX,” Chin said.

The American Civil Liberties Union, which represents the transgender athletes as intervenors in the case, hailed the ruling.

“Trans student-athletes belong on our sports teams and in our schools, and all trans youth should be celebrated and protected for who they are,” Elana Bildner, a senior staff lawyer with the ACLU Foundation of Connecticut, said in a statement. “Today, the courts have once again dismissed this lawsuit seeking to attack trans student-athletes. The record shows that our clients played by the rules, and the court agreed.”

Christiana Kiefer, a senior counsel with Alliance Defending Freedom, a Scottsdale, Ariz.-based legal organization representing the cisgender athletes, said in a statement, “The 2nd Circuit got it wrong, and we’re evaluating all legal options, including appeal. Our clients—like all female athletes—deserve access to fair competition. Thankfully, a growing number of states are stepping up to protect women’s athletics.”

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Classroom Technology Webinar
Academic Integrity in the Age of Artificial Intelligence
As AI writing tools rapidly evolve, learn how to set standards and expectations for your students on their use.
Content provided by Turnitin
Recruitment & Retention Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table: Chronic Teacher Shortage: Where Do We Go From Here?  
Join Peter DeWitt, Michael Fullan, and guests for expert insights into finding solutions for the teacher shortage.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
The Science of Reading: Tools to Build Reading Proficiency
The Science of Reading has taken education by storm. Learn how Dr. Miranda Blount transformed literacy instruction in her state.
Content provided by hand2mind

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Law & Courts Supreme Court Asks for Biden Administration's Views on Legal Status of Charter Schools
Stemming from a suit over a North Carolina school's dress code, the issue is whether "public" charter schools act with government authority.
3 min read
Thunder storm sky over the United States Supreme Court building in Washington DC.
iStock/Getty Images Plus
Law & Courts West Virginia Law Barring Transgender Girls From School Sports Upheld by Federal Judge
The decision is a turnabout for the judge, who cast doubt on the law in 2021 and issued an order allowing a transgender girl to compete.
4 min read
Judge gavel on law books with statue of justice and court government background. concept of law, justice, legal.
iStock/Getty Images Plus
Law & Courts A Teacher Argued His MAGA Hat Was Protected Speech. Here's What a Federal Appeals Court Said
Did a principal violate a teacher's rights when she told him not to bring his Donald Trump-inspired hat to a racial-sensitivity training?
4 min read
Image of a gavel
iStock/Getty
Law & Courts School District Policy Basing Restroom Access on 'Biological Sex' Upheld by Appeals Court
The sharply divided appellate court rules against transgender student Drew Adams and possibly tees up a major fight in the Supreme Court.
5 min read
Transgender student Drew Adams speaks with reporters outside of the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta on Dec. 5, 2019.
Transgender student Drew Adams speaks with reporters outside a federal courthouse in Atlanta in 2019. The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit ruled against him on Dec. 30.
Ron Harris/AP