School Choice & Charters

A Private School Choice Program Is Illegal, State Court Rules. What Comes Next?

By Mark Lieberman — September 11, 2024 4 min read
Pictogram chalk drawing of a blue man holding scales.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Education savings accounts are dead in South Carolina—for now—after the state Supreme Court ruled Wednesday that the state’s newest private school choice program violates the state’s constitution.

The Education Trust Fund Scholarship Program, which Republican Gov. Henry McMaster signed into law in the spring of 2023, offers parents up to $6,000 in state funds for a wide range of private education expenses, including private school tuition, fees, transportation, and supplies. The legislature allocated funding for up to 5,000 students who previously attended a public school, and whose families earn up to 200 percent of the federal poverty level, to receive ESA funds this school year.

Eligibility was set to expand over the next two years to ultimately reach 15,000 students from families earning up to 400 percent of the federal poverty level by the 2026-27 school year.

In a 3-2 verdict on Sept. 11, however, judges ruled that the state constitution prohibits state lawmakers from directing “public funds to the benefit of private schools.”

“This is what our constitution forbids,” Justice D. Garrison Hill wrote in the majority opinion.

The ruling came in response to a legal challenge of the program by the South Carolina NAACP, the South Carolina Education Association, and six public school parents. The plaintiffs alleged that the ESA program violated constitutional restrictions on public spending for private institutions.

Ellen Weaver, the elected state superintendent of education and a Republican, said in a statement that the ruling “wreaks havoc on participating students and their families.”

“Families cried tears of joy when the scholarship funds became available for their children, and today’s Supreme Court ruling brings those same families tears of devastation,” she said.

The department didn’t respond to follow-up questions about the nature of that havoc. Step Up for Students, an advocacy group for private school choice, reported in July that families would start receiving funds later that month. Under the South Carolina law, this fall was the first in which families would receive money to enroll their children in private school.

Advocates knew ahead of time that this outcome was a possibility, said Chris Lubienski, a private school choice critic who is a professor of education policy at Indiana University.

“They went ahead with this knowing there were serious questions about legality,” Lubienski said. “That did set those families up for chaotic disruption.”

Lawmakers in the South Carolina House passed legislation in March to put the education savings account program on track for universal eligibility in the 2026-27 school year. But Senate leaders signaled they were reluctant to take up the legislation as this case was pending in state courts.

The families of slightly fewer than 2,900 students received ESA funds this school year. The state rejected another 5,000 students’ applications, according to data provided to the South Carolina Gazette.

Legal wrangling over ESAs is far from over

The ruling has immediate implications for participating families in South Carolina, as the court ordered the state to stop spending funds on ESAs. It also raises broader questions about the viability of private school choice programs currently in place in numerous other states.

Critics of private school choice are pursuing similar lawsuits in Ohio, Utah, and Wisconsin. The South Carolina case offers private school choice critics a potential roadmap.

The South Carolina verdict, however, may not be a “singular precedent in and of itself,” Lubienski said. State courts’ reactions to private school choice have been mixed, and each state constitution’s language on education is different.

Still, South Carolina isn’t the first state to see its private school choice program overturned. The Nevada Supreme Court in 2016 nixed a similar education savings account offering. Kentucky’s Supreme Court in 2022 knocked down state-funded tax-credit scholarships on constitutional grounds. West Virginia’s ESA was halted for four months before the state Supreme Court permitted it to proceed.

Seventeen states offer educational savings accounts to some or all families, according to Education Week’s tracker of private school choice legislation. Alabama, Louisiana, and Wyoming earlier this year became the latest states to offer them. Lawmakers in Texas and Tennessee are likely to consider new or expanded ESA offerings in their upcoming legislative sessions.

The South Carolina Policy Center, a right-leaning think tank that helped craft the ESA legislation, is pushing for Weaver and the state treasurer, Curtis Loftis, to appeal this week’s decision to the U.S. Supreme Court, which would then have to decide whether to take it up.

“Ultimately, we are severely disappointed for all the students in need who will no longer have an opportunity to pursue a higher-quality education that meets their needs,” said Sam Aaron, research director for the organization.

Advocates for ESAs in South Carolina could also try to restore the shuttered program by asking voters to approve a constitutional amendment that explicitly allows state funds to flow to private schools. The majority verdict itself raises that possibility: “Our General Assembly knew how to draft an amendment to present to the people that would allow public funding for private schools, but it did not,” Hill wrote.

But based on history, such a proposal could face an uphill battle. Of the 16 times states in the last half-century have asked voters to weigh in on school choice, school choice has only won out on two occasions, according to a brief by researchers at Indiana University-Bloomington. In both cases—Georgia and Washington—voters were throwing support behind charter schools, not private schools.

More ballot items on private school choice are on the horizon. This November, voters in Colorado, Kentucky, and Nebraska will weigh in.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
(Re)Focus on Dyslexia: Moving Beyond Diagnosis & Toward Transformation
Move beyond dyslexia diagnoses & focus on effective literacy instruction for ALL students. Join us to learn research-based strategies that benefit learners in PreK-8.
Content provided by EPS Learning
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School Climate & Safety Webinar
How to Use Data to Combat Bullying and Enhance School Safety
Join our webinar to learn how data can help identify bullying, implement effective interventions, & foster student well-being.
Content provided by Panorama Education
Classroom Technology Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table: Is AI Out to Take Your Job or Help You Do It Better?
With all of the uncertainty K-12 educators have around what AI means might mean for the future, how can the field best prepare young people for an AI-powered future?

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School Choice & Charters Explainer How States Use Tax Credits to Fund Private School Choice: An Explainer
Twenty-one states have programs that give tax credits for donations to organizations that grant private-school scholarships.
12 min read
budget school funding
iStock/Getty
School Choice & Charters Private School Choice in the 2024 Election, Explained
Three states will ask voters to weigh in on private school choice, and another state could pave the way for more funding for choice.
7 min read
3D illustration of a character walking on the road leading to many different paths with open doors. The pathway and doors are light in color against a dark blue backgroud.
iStock/Getty
School Choice & Charters How Private School Choice Complicates Public School Budgets
Districts are seeing higher costs and fuzzier enrollment projections as more states give parents public funds for private education.
12 min read
Illustration of a person holding a bag of money with a hole in it, where coins are falling out, with a chart behind showing loss.
iStock/Getty
School Choice & Charters Opinion What Is the State of School Choice?
A leading authority on school choice describes recent legislative trends and new research findings.
10 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty