School Climate & Safety

Advocates Agree: Police Shouldn’t Handle Routine Discipline in Schools

By Eesha Pendharkar — June 29, 2023 7 min read
A school resource officer in Anderson, Calif., walks a middle school student back to class on Dec. 9, 2013.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The debate over police in schools is a divided one, but on one point, most people agree: school resource officers should not be involved in the routine discipline of students. When they are, research has shown, students of color and students with disabilities are more likely to be affected by overly harsh penalties

However, they disagree on whether police should be in schools in the first place, according to the Center for Policing Equity, which released data-based recommendations last month.

“School-based police are not an effective tool to make students safe in schools, particularly Black and brown students,” said Scarlet Neath, policy director for CPE, an advocacy and research organization focused on redesigning public safety for minority communities.

“The evidence we combed through was very clear on the subjects of the harms that come from stationing police in schools.”

But the National Association of School Resource Officers says ending school policing entirely is a radical and unnecessary approach, and while there are districts that have put law enforcement in schools and have not done a very good job of it, properly trained SROs are an essential component of school safety.

For more than a decade, the pendulum has been swinging between schools adding more on-campus officers in the aftermath of high-profile acts of school violence and schools re-evaluating law enforcement on campus because of data that show the disproportionate negative impacts on students of color and those with disabilities. It can be a difficult issue for school leaders who often feel community pressure and pressure from teachers and staff members who are worried about safety.

Still, advocacy groups like CPE and organizations that support police in schools such as NASRO agree that administrators—not SROs—are responsible for handling student discipline issues. School police should only be involved if there is a threat of a student having committed a felony. That responsibility should lie with school administrators, both organizations said.

“Just the idea of a law enforcement officer or even an SRO, being involved in that decision … that’s pretty radical,” said Mo Canady, the executive director of NASRO. “That really is what educators, and in particular administrators, are supposed to be trained to deal with.”

How the presence of SROs impacts students of color

School resource officers are law enforcement officers assigned specifically to schools. A vast majority of them are armed, and they often undergo some training on issues that impact schools, such as adolescent behavior, cyberbullying, and implicit bias, according to Canady. Training requirements for SROs vary from state to state.

About 51 percent of public schools have a school resource officer on campus, according to a 2022 study by the U.S. Department of Education. The presence of school resource officers—and how they impact the well-being of students of color—has been debated for more than a decade, with mixed research about the benefits of having law enforcement stationed at schools.

Some studies have shown that SROs decrease the incidence of serious violence at school, such as physical assaults. But they also increase the use of out-of-school suspensions, transfers, expulsions, and referrals to law enforcement agencies, the same studies found.

“While some studies showed that SROs had an impact on reduced crime, you have to keep in mind that sometimes things are characterized as crimes that would otherwise not be if it weren’t for the presence of police,” Neath from CPE said.

“The same behavior can be perceived as a disciplinary infraction or as a crime depending on who you know, observing and characterizing.”

This impacts Black students and disabled students disproportionately, the CPE report said. Police officers arrest Black students 2.8 times as often as white students, and disabled students 3.3 times as often as students without disabilities, according to the report. More than 80 percent of students who have been assaulted by school police between 2011 and 2021 were Black, according to a report from the Advancement Project, which analyzed a decade of data on police assaults at school.

About 1 in 6 sworn SROs are Black, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics.

SROs should be trained in implicit bias, which means recognizing the snap judgments people can make based on race or gender, Canady said. NASRO has provided this training for about eight years, and based on anecdotal evidence it has made a difference in how students perceive SROs, he said. NASRO does not do data collection, Canady said.

Canady said SROs should make sure to connect with minority students, “so that they (understand) what our role is and what it’s not.”

“And that we are there to be an advocate for them and protect them,” he added.

Districts cut ties with SROs over the law few years, but some are reinstating them

In the wake of the murder of George Floyd by Minneapolis police in 2020, several districts began severing ties with school resource officers.

From May 2020 through June 2022, at least 50 districts serving over 1.7 million students ended their school policing programs or cut their SRO budgets, according to data compiled by Education Week. However, as of last year, eight of those districts that had removed police from schools reversed course and added them back.

Other districts, such as Minneapolis, replaced school resource officers with different types of security personnel, according to EdWeek data.

But in light of increased violence in schools, including in the number of school shootings over the past couple of years, some districts have reinstated SROs. The most recent example is Denver Public Schools, whose board voted to reinstate SROs in 13 schools following two school shootings in February and March.

Instead, Neath said districts should turn to approaches such as adding mental health supports for students, and implementing restorative justice practices, which are a set of strategies educators can use to help students resolve conflicts with the guidance of trained staff in small groups, before resorting to suspension or expulsion to address behavior incidents.

When should schools involve the police?

School district policies should explicitly state that administrators or teachers should not ask for police involvement unless a student causes or threatens serious physical harm to other students or staff, or possesses a firearm or explosive, according to the CPE recommendations.

These are some factors districts should consider when deciding if law enforcement needs to be involved, according to CPE:

  • The student’s age, developmental needs, or known trauma history;
  • Whether the behavior is related to a student’s disability;
  • The severity of the alleged behavior and the degree of harm to people in the school, including students and staff members;
  • The perspective of any harmed students

Examples of conduct issues that should never warrant police involvement according to CPE include:

  • Any physical violence and fighting, such as pushing, hitting, or shoving, which does not result in injury requiring medical attention;
  • Any name-calling, slurs, bullying, and other verbal harassment that do not present any risk of serious physical harm;
  • Disturbances or disruptive behavior such as running, shouting, noise, and profanity;
  • Dress-code violations, cell phone use violations (including posting a video of a fight), and any other school disciplinary violations that are not criminal offenses;
  • Forgery;
  • Insubordination;
  • Loitering or trespassing;
  • Losing or damaging school property;
  • Mutually voluntary sexual behavior among peers of the same age;
  • Taking or attempting to take another student or school staff’s property without their permission;
  • Threats of harm which, in context, are clearly metaphorical (such as “I’m going to beat you up”);
  • Truancy or tardiness;
  • Use or possession of controlled substances such as marijuana, cannabis, alcohol, tobacco, and nicotine products;
  • Vandalism and graffiti

Within that list, there are some things that would fall within the criminal code, such as possession of marijuana, or vandalism, and some that would not, like cell phone use and dress code violations, non-serious fights, or name-calling. Canady said. For things that don’t fall into the criminal code, SROs should not be involved, he said.

“The bottom line is, we train officers not to become involved in formal disciplinary matters in a school environment unless it becomes a criminal matter,” he said.

Events

Budget & Finance Webinar Staffing Schools After ESSER: What School and District Leaders Need to Know
Join our newsroom for insights on investing in critical student support positions as pandemic funds expire.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Achievement Webinar
How can districts build sustainable tutoring models before the money runs out?
District leaders, low on funds, must decide: broad support for all or deep interventions for few? Let's discuss maximizing tutoring resources.
Content provided by Varsity Tutors for Schools
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
College & Workforce Readiness Webinar
Roundtable Webinar: Why We Created a Portrait of a Graduate
Hear from three K-12 leaders for insights into their school’s Portrait of a Graduate and learn how to create your own.
Content provided by Otus

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School Climate & Safety Uvalde Shooting Victims' Families Sue State Police, Settle With City for $2M
The families say they also agreed a $2 million settlement with the city, which will be used on better training for local police.
3 min read
Crosses are surrounded by flowers and other items at a memorial on June 9, 2022, for the victims of a shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas. The families of 19 people who were killed or injured in the shooting and their attorneys are set to make an announcement, Wednesday, May 22, 2024.
Crosses are surrounded by flowers and other items at a memorial on June 9, 2022, for the victims of a shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas. The families of 19 people who were killed or injured in the shooting and their attorneys are set to make an announcement, Wednesday, May 22, 2024. Friday will mark the two-year anniversary of the shooting where a gunman killed 19 students and two teachers.
Eric Gay/AP
School Climate & Safety Opinion How Do Restorative Practices Work?
Traditional punitive measures tend to reap more misbehavior.
13 min read
Images shows colorful speech bubbles that say "Q," "&," and "A."
iStock/Getty
School Climate & Safety What Helped These K-12 Leaders After School Shootings
School shootings leave deep and lasting impact on the community, including those charged with leading students and staff in the aftermath.
5 min read
School staff cheer as students returned to in-person classes at Central Visual and Performing Arts High School in St. Louis on Tuesday, Jan. 17, 2023, following a shooting on Oct. 24, 2022, that killed a student and a teacher. Kacy Shahid, then the school's principal, faced the challenge of guiding the school community through recovery as she struggled herself to process the events.
School staff cheer as students returned to in-person classes at Central Visual and Performing Arts High School in St. Louis on Tuesday, Jan. 17, 2023, following a shooting on Oct. 24, 2022, that killed a student and a teacher. Kacy Shahid, then the school's principal, faced the challenge of guiding the school community through recovery as she struggled herself to process the events.
Jim Salter/AP
School Climate & Safety Another State Will Let Teachers Carry Guns. What We Know About the Strategy
Tennessee lawmakers passed a bill allowing teachers to carry guns with administrators' permission a year after the Covenant School shooting.
5 min read
People protest outside the House chamber after legislation passed that would allow some teachers to be armed in schools during a legislative session on April 23, 2024, in Nashville, Tenn.
People protest outside the House chamber after legislation passed that would allow some teachers to be armed in schools during a legislative session on April 23, 2024, in Nashville, Tenn. Tennessee could join more than 30 other states in allowing certain teachers to carry guns on campus. There's virtually no research on the strategy's effectiveness, and it remains uncommon despite the proliferation of state laws allowing it.
George Walker IV/AP