Classroom Technology

1 to 1 Learning

By Pamela Livingston — January 23, 2008 6 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Many of us watched as the 23rd space shuttle Discovery launched a two-week mission to the International Space Station in October. Elizabeth Mannix, Eric Agostinelli, Molly Schreiber, and Adele Smith watched as well, except that their perspective was from the ground at the Kennedy Space Center. The student journalists from Bishop Kearney High School in Rochester, N.Y., were covering the launch and mission.

Shuttle commander Pam Melroy, a 1979 graduate of Bishop Kearney, provided the connection, which allowed the students to enjoy press privileges and work side by side with adult professional journalists covering the event.

BRIC ARCHIVE

Empowered with laptop computers and coached by their teachers, the students sent frequent audio, video, and blog reports to local and national media. At the same time, they kept up with assignments in their classes back home using their laptops, never falling behind on important class assignments during the week they were in Houston.

This kind of self-directed learning, taking place at school or at a distant location, supporting a project with a curricular connection, and coached by master teachers with their own laptops, represents the best of possibilities of one-to-one computing.

We’re at an exciting place right now in education. Literally thousands of open-ended Web 2.0 tools are available for engaging learners and invigorating classrooms everywhere; options for online collaboration are increasing every day; and polls of U.S. adults say they support efforts to use technology to better prepare our students to compete in a highly technical global economy.

But how do we take our classrooms into the future, empower teachers and students with the tools and functions for the challenges ahead, and enable deep, sustained learning? Providing every student and teacher with his or her own laptop computer, I believe, is one important step we can take to achieve those goals.

What It Takes

Building and sustaining one-to-one computing programs does not happen overnight, even though some schools have believed this and suffered the fallout when their efforts failed.

See Also

Read the accompanying story,

Learning Even When Schools Are Closed

There have been several well-publicized failures. I’ve taken the time to read about these programs, and it seems that those that stumbled, or simply ceased to exist, have similarities.

For starters, school leaders did not seem to be willing to stick with the programs for the long haul, meaning any little problems or setbacks were seen as reasons not to continue investing in the programs.

Next, there seemed to be a lack of attention to the components needed to fix computers and keep the models current and operational. Proper attention includes a technical-support help desk, loaner computers, and a reasonable refresh cycle.

Also, to be successful, one-to-one computing initiatives must pay attention to policies and procedures, including consequences for inappropriate use of the laptops and whether the machines may be used at home.

Serious consideration of the goals of one-to-one programs need to be undertaken at the school, district, and state levels so that overarching questions of “why one-to-one?” are answered. A program needs a mission statement that really answers those questions and provides a road map for how the program will move forward. The mission for some is to improve students’ technology skills; for others, it is to create more opportunities for self-directed learning.

With the “why” questions answered, and a mission statement or resulting document crafted, a vision committee should be established to outline what else is needed for the program to succeed.

The vision committee must create a communications strategy so that teachers, parents, students, administrators, school board members, and community members feel well informed and part of the process. If you don’t keep people informed, you risk losing them as supporters of the effort.

Schools and districts sometimes make the mistake of holding back on communicating about one-to-one computing initiatives, not wanting to tell people about incomplete plans.

The next step is for the vision committee and people involved in running the program to become informed about best practices. Fanning out to observe and question schools, districts, and statewide programs results in an understanding of what’s working and what might have been tried along the way but didn’t work. Attending conferences that specialize in one-to-one computing is also helpful.

Weighing the Costs

The ways of paying for one-to-one computing initiatives are as varied as the schools that have taken this journey.

One-to-One Computing: Resources

One-to-One Wiki for International Society for Technology in Education members http://sig1to1.iste.wikispaces.net

Anytime, Anywhere Learning Foundation www.aalf.org

K12 Computing Blueprint— Resources for One-to-One www.k12blueprint.com/k12/ blueprint/index.php

Maine Learns—Maine’s Online Learning Community www.mainelearns.org

One-to-One Information Resources (includes case studies) www.k12one2one.org

Pennsylvania State University’s Center for One-to-One Computing in Education http://1to1.ed.psu.edu

Irving (Texas) Independent School District Site on One-to-One www.irvingisd.net/one2one/ documents.htm

Compiled by Pamela Livingston

But such an initiative is not cheap. For instance, Pennsylvania’s Classrooms for the Future program required initial funding of $20 million, and another $90 million was added this past fall. That state program serves 358 schools in 304 districts.

Some districts negotiate leasing and other deals with vendors, spreading costs over several years. Some require parents to foot part or all of the cost of laptops.

Other districts rethought their hardware-replacement policies and stopped buying classroom and lab computers in favor of laptops or tablets. One budgetary advantage of that step is that most schools have already determined and funded their replacement cycle for classroom computers, so money is available for purchasing the smaller devices.

No one formula and no one funding source are available.

One important cost-related issue is the type of computer platform you plan to use. Laptops? Tablet PCs? Something else?

These decisions need to be tied back to your mission and what you plan to do with your one-to-one initiative. There are pros and cons along the way, and budgeting will be a factor.

Many schools make platform one of the questions they ask other schools and districts when they visit—for instance, “Why did you choose these computers, and would you choose them again?”

One thing is sure whether you decide on tablets or laptops: They will need repairs. They’ll have problems, sometimes caused by the students or teachers, and other times just because they’re electronic devices. Batteries will fail, students will arrive without a charged laptop, and laptops and tablets will be dropped and break.

Deciding how they will be supported, and what spare computing devices, batteries, power cords, and other equipment are loaned and how will be important. For instance, experts generally advise against having fewer than 3 percent loaner devices, batteries, and power adapters. So if you have 100 laptops, you should have at least three loaners.

Many schools find that when they implement one-to-one programs, they require full-time, in-house people to fix them, and a help desk. Some schools and districts rely on vendor support, which can work well if there is on-site personnel from the vendor, but generally does not work well when the vendor has to be called and repairs have to be scheduled. Just remember that few things can be as frustrating as a broken machine when you’re trying to teach in a one-to-one computing environment.

Research suggests professional development is also an important element of successful one-to-one computing initiatives.

Teachers who have well-planned lessons that empower laptop learning, who encourage self-directed learning, and who feel comfortable with a roomful of students with laptops are likely to succeed.

Frequent professional development for teachers with a follow-up component that uses online learning usually works best.

Don’t shortchange professional development—invest in it and support it fully.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the January 23, 2008 edition of Digital Directions as 1 to 1 Learning

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Your Questions on the Science of Reading, Answered
Dive into the Science of Reading with K-12 leaders. Discover strategies, policy insights, and more in our webinar.
Content provided by Otus
Mathematics Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table: Breaking the Cycle: How Districts are Turning around Dismal Math Scores
Math myth: Students just aren't good at it? Join us & learn how districts are boosting math scores.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Achievement Webinar
How To Tackle The Biggest Hurdles To Effective Tutoring
Learn how districts overcome the three biggest challenges to implementing high-impact tutoring with fidelity: time, talent, and funding.
Content provided by Saga Education

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Classroom Technology 15 Reasons Teachers Say Social Media Isn't All Bad for Students
Many educators do see some positive impact from social media. For instance, the apps and platforms enable informal learning.
2 min read
Vector illustration of professional people holding social media icons like a thumb up, love, speech bubble and smile sign.
iStock/Getty
Classroom Technology This AI Tool Cut One Teacher's Grading Time in Half. How It Works
An AI Tool to grade computer science assignments tended to mirror the assessments of experienced educators.
4 min read
Vibrant Chatbot icon on black background.
E+
Classroom Technology More Teachers Are Using AI-Detection Tools. Here's Why That Might Be a Problem
Students are increasingly getting disciplined for using generative AI, a new survey finds.
7 min read
Close-up stock photograph showing a touchscreen monitor with a woman’s hand looking at responses being asked by an AI chatbot.
E+
Classroom Technology Science Fiction May Be the Key to Helping Students Understand AI
For educators seeking to help students understand the power of AI, fiction has become an indispensable teaching tool
8 min read
A 3d render of an abstract staircase and a glowing portal with a woman going into the portal.
E+/Getty