Law & Courts

U.S. Supreme Court Refuses to Reinstate West Virginia’s Transgender Athlete Ban

By Mark Walsh — April 06, 2023 4 min read
Hundreds of students carry signs and walk out of school on Transgender Day of Visibility outside Omaha Central High School on March 31, 2023 in Omaha, Neb. Students are protesting LB574 and LB575 in the Nebraska Legislature, which would ban certain gender-affirming care for youth and would prevent trans youth from competing in girls sports, respectively.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday declined to reinstate—for now—a West Virginia law that bars transgender female athletes from competing in girls’ school sports, over the dissent of two of its most conservative members.

The case “concerns an important issue that this court is likely to be required to address in the near future,” Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. wrote in a dissent joined by Justice Clarence Thomas. The issue, Alito said, is whether Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 or the 14th Amendment’s equal-protection clause prohibits a state “from restricting participation in women’s or girls’ sports based on genes or physiological or anatomical characteristics.”

Alito did not reveal his stance with regard to this case, West Virginia v. B.P.J. But he warned in a 2021 opinion that allowing transgender students to participate in sports “previously reserved for one sex” threatens to “undermine one of [Title IX’s] major achievements, giving young women an equal opportunity to participate in sports.” (Thomas joined that Alito dissent in Bostock v. Clayton County, Ga., in which the court held that federal employment-discrimination law covered sexual orientation and gender identity.)

The high court’s rejection of the emergency request from West Virginia allows a lower court injunction in favor of a 12-year-old transgender student, Becky Pepper-Jackson, to participate in girls’ track this spring.

“We are grateful that the Supreme Court today acknowledged that there was no emergency and that Becky should be allowed to continue to participate with her teammates on her middle school track team,” said a joint statement from Lambda Legal and the American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia.

New proposed rules for transgender sports eligibility under Title IX

The court’s action comes as transgender female participation in girls’ and women’s sports remains a major flashpoint. Some states have enacted bans, other legislatures are debating prohibitions, and other courts are considering pending cases.

On Thursday, President Joe Biden’s administration also announced that it is developing rules under Title IX to prohibit schools from categorically barring transgender students from joining teams that align with their gender identity, though it would allow them to be excluded from some competitive levels of sports.

In the West Virginia case, Pepper-Jackson challenged the 2021 Save Women’s Sports Act, which defines “female” as “an individual whose biological sex determined at birth is female.” A federal district judge had initially blocked the law but in January 2023 upheld it, if somewhat reluctantly. The judge held that it was “constitutionally permissible” for the West Virginia legislature to limit participation in school and college sports to classifications based on “biological sex.” Biological males generally outperform females athletically, the judge said, and thus the legislature was acting in a manner related to athletic performance and fairness in sports.

In February, a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit, in Richmond, Va., voted 2-1 to issue an injunction allowing Pepper-Jackson to compete while the merits of her appeal proceeded. The panel offered no reasoning for the decision.

That prompted West Virginia, joined by some intervening cisgender female athletes represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative Scottsdale, Ariz.-based legal organization, to ask the Supreme Court to get involved.

“Complete lack of analysis [by the 4th Circuit] is the first tell that something is amiss, as federal courts should not enjoin democratically passed legislation without at least providing a rationale,” the joint emergency application to throw out the injunction said.

Lambda Legal and the ACLU told the court that the law’s defenders had not appealed the 2021 injunction that briefly blocked it, and so it could hardly be an emergency to allow one transgender student to continue to participate in girls’ sports.

Alito, in his dissent to the court’s action denying the emergency application, focused on procedural considerations.

“Among other things, enforcement of the law at issue should not be forbidden by the federal courts without any explanation,” said Alito. He acknowledged that the state had not challenged the earlier injunction, but said that under the normal factors, the court would consider in deciding whether to block a lower-court injunction, “the state is entitled to relief.”

West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrissey, a Republican, said in a statement that the Supreme Court’s action “is a procedural setback, but we remain confident that when this case is ultimately determined on the merits, we will prevail.”

“We maintain our stance that this is a common sense law—we have a very strong case,” Morrissey added.

Events

Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
Ed-Tech Policy Webinar Artificial Intelligence in Practice: Building a Roadmap for AI Use in Schools
AI in education: game-changer or classroom chaos? Join our webinar & learn how to navigate this evolving tech responsibly.
Education Webinar Developing and Executing Impactful Research Campaigns to Fuel Your Ed Marketing Strategy 
Develop impactful research campaigns to fuel your marketing. Join the EdWeek Research Center for a webinar with actionable take-aways for companies who sell to K-12 districts.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Law & Courts Oklahoma Nonbinary Student's Death Shines a Light on Families' Legal Recourse for Bullying
Students facing bullying and harassment from their peers face legal roadblocks in suing districts, but settlements appear to be on the rise
11 min read
A photograph of Nex Benedict, a nonbinary teenager who died a day after a fight in a high school bathroom, is projected during a candlelight service at Point A Gallery, on Feb. 24, 2024, in Oklahoma City. Federal officials will investigate the Oklahoma school district where Benedict died, according to a letter sent by the U.S. Department of Education on March 1, 2024.
A photograph of Nex Benedict, a nonbinary teenager who died a day after a fight in a high school restroom, is projected during a candlelight service at Point A Gallery, on Feb. 24, 2024, in Oklahoma City. Federal officials will investigate the Oklahoma school district where Benedict died, according to a letter sent by the U.S. Department of Education on March 1, 2024.
Nate Billings/The Oklahoman via AP
Law & Courts Supreme Court Declines Case on Selective High School Aiming to Boost Racial Diversity
Some advocates saw the K-12 case as the logical next step after last year's decision against affirmative action in college admissions
7 min read
Rising seniors at the Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology gather on the campus in Alexandria, Va., Aug. 10, 2020. From left in front are, Dinan Elsyad, Sean Nguyen, and Tiffany Ji. From left at rear are Jordan Lee and Shibli Nomani. A federal appeals court’s ruling in May 2023 about the admissions policy at the elite public high school in Virginia may provide a vehicle for the U.S. Supreme Court to flesh out the intended scope of its ruling Thursday, June 29, 2023, banning affirmative action in college admissions.
A group of rising seniors at the Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology gather on the campus in Alexandria, Va., in August 2020. From left in front are, Dinan Elsyad, Sean Nguyen, and Tiffany Ji. From left at rear are Jordan Lee and Shibli Nomani. The U.S. Supreme Court on Feb. 20 declined to hear a challenge to an admissions plan for the selective high school that was facially race neutral but designed to boost the enrollment of Black and Hispanic students.
J. Scott Applewhite/AP
Law & Courts School District Lawsuits Against Social Media Companies Are Piling Up
More than 200 school districts are now suing the major social media companies over the youth mental health crisis.
7 min read
A close up of a statue of the blindfolded lady justice against a light blue background with a ghosted image of a hands holding a cellphone with Facebook "Like" and "Love" icons hovering above it.
iStock/Getty
Law & Courts In 1974, the Supreme Court Recognized English Learners' Rights. The Story Behind That Case
The Lau v. Nichols ruling said students have a right to a "meaningful opportunity" to participate in school, but its legacy is complex.
12 min read
Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court William O. Douglas is shown in an undated photo.
U.S. Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas, shown in an undated photo, wrote the opinion in <i>Lau</i> v. <i>Nichols</i>, the 1974 decision holding that the San Francisco school system had denied Chinese-speaking schoolchildren a meaningful opportunity to participate in their education.
AP