School & District Management

There’s a Downside to Attending an Academically Selective School, Study Says

By Sasha Jones — October 26, 2018 1 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

When sending their children to school, parents will often aim for schools with high scores and challenging programs, but according to a new analysis of data from Project TALENT, selective schools with a higher average achievement level may actually exert a negative influence on students’ long-term success.

The nationally representative, longitudinal study of over 377,000 high school students found that while students who attend socioeconomically advantaged high schools tend to complete more schooling, earn higher annual incomes, and work in more prestigious jobs 11 and 50 years later, those who attend selective, high-achieving schools tend to experience the opposite.

The report, published by the Association for Psychological Science, claims that students in high-achievement schools had relatively lower expectations due to social comparison. In other words, these students, many of whom might’ve been near the top of their class in a more academically diverse school, develop a less positive self-image when all of their classmates are high-achieving.These expectations then negatively impacted students’ attainment levels in the future.

“The permanent comparison with high-achieving peers seemed to harm students’ beliefs in their own abilities and that was associated with serious consequences for their later careers,” lead researcher Richard Göllner said in a press release.

Project TALENT is a comprehensive study that collected data from students in grades 9 through 12 from 1,226 high schools beginnning in 1960. Achievement was assessed by standardized tests. Parents’ educational attainment and students’ educational expectations were used to assess students’ socioeconomic background and achievement in high school.

In follow-ups, educational attainment, annual earnings, houshold income, and occupational prestige were assessed.

Moving forward, Göllner and the other researchers involved plan to examine teacher-related factors that may help counter some of the negative effects of social comparison.

A version of this news article first appeared in the Inside School Research blog.