Equity & Diversity

Study: Most School Districts Have Achievement Gaps

By Sarah D. Sparks — May 10, 2016 5 min read

In education, a rising tide of resources does not necessarily lift all boats.

Racial achievement gaps exist in nearly every community across the country with a measurable black or Hispanic population—and many districts with a traditional commitment to education and resources to serve all students instead have the worst inequities, according to new research comparing achievement gaps across state lines.

Using a database of five years of test scores from more than 40 million students nationwide, Stanford University researchers Sean Reardon, Demetra Kalogrides, and Kenneth Shores analyzed how racial achievement gaps look in different parts of the country, and how segregated schools widen those gaps.

Average Test Scores by School District

BRIC ARCHIVE

SOURCE: © (2016) Sean F. Reardon, Demetra Kalogrides, Erin Fahle, Kenneth Shores, and Benjamin Shear. Stanford Education Data Archive: seda.stanford.edu

“I think we like to think, ‘Here we have this problem, but it’s fixable. We know we could figure it out.’ It’s not clear we’ve figured it out,” said Reardon, a professor of poverty and inequality in education at Stanford. “There’s some deep ... problems that we as a society haven’t faced up to yet.”

The Stanford researchers and Harvard University education professor Andrew Ho linked scale scores for state tests to the scales for the National Assessment of Educational Progress in the same grades and subjects, and used that yardstick to compare average achievement gap trends for students in 3rd through 8th grades in more than 12,000 districts across the country, from 2009-2013.

Minding the Gaps

How Scholars Linked 215 Million Test Scores

State differences in testing and accountability systems have frustrated researchers and families alike since the early days of the No Child Left Behind Act, but a massive new database provides a link to compare achievement trends in districts across the country.

The new Stanford Education Data Archive, a four-year project by researchers at Stanford and Harvard universities, compiles 215 million state test scores from 40 million students—every test taken by a public school student in grades 3 through 8 from 2009-2012—and disaggregated by race, grade, subject, and proficiency level. The data cover more than 12,000 of the nation’s 14,000-plus school districts and 384 metropolitan areas, encompassing both regular and charter public schools. It is the largest and most comprehensive database of its kind to date.

Sean F. Reardon, a professor of poverty inequality in education, his colleagues at Stanford, and Harvard education professor Andrew Ho, analyzed the performance of different student groups in each district. They ranked districts in each state, both overall and separately, by racial/ethnic categories, by comparing their performance at multiple proficiency levels: “below basic,” “basic,” “proficient,” and “advanced.” This allows them to compare districts within a state, but not across state lines.

To compare districts across states, they “linked” state scores to performance on the nationally representative National Assessment of Educational Progress, in the related subjects and grade levels, Ho said.

Crosswalking the Data

An earlier federal crosswalk study of state tests and the NAEP, which is a set of large, nationally sampled tests in core subjects like math and reading, found that states set their proficiency thresholds at widely disparate levels. A 4th grader who was deemed a proficient reader on state tests in Arizona or Virginia could have significantly lower scores on NAEP than a proficient reader in neighboring New Mexico or West Virginia, for example.

The researchers were able to confirm that the NAEP linking system worked by comparing the differences they predicted among major U.S. urban districts to those districts’ actual performance on the NAEP’s most recent Trial Urban District Assessment, which compares NAEP results in 21 urban districts throughout the country. For example, the system accurately predicted that Chicago 4th graders would perform about a half-grade level, or 10 scale-score points, below New York 4th graders in reading in the 2013 TUDA.

Their validation checks show that this method enables them to conduct research on differences among districts both within and across states. “It’s statistically complicated, but it gives answers that are very accurate,” Reardon said.

The data “don’t tell us which school districts are better than others ... because test scores of kids in a district are the result of everything that’s contributed to the kid’s development since conception,” he warned. “These [data] are really good for big picture stuff, but it shouldn’t be used to rank schools that are statistically very similar to each other.”

A large data set from the studies has been made available to researchers and the public, and Reardon is working to bring in foundations to provide grants for those who want to mine it. However, the statistical method could be used to add and analyze new test data, to help compare educational achievement and progress across the country as states explore different testing regimes and accountability measures under the Every Student Succeeds Act.

—Sarah D. Sparks

That five-year period enabled researchers to focus on districts completing a decade of state and federal accountability initiatives designed to close academic gaps between white students and their black and Hispanic peers. Of the 2,500 school districts with a large enough sample of black students to measure their achievement gaps, Reardon and his colleagues found only one with no black-white gap: Detroit.

“Detroit is not the poster child for reducing the achievement gap,” Reardon said in an interview with Education Week. “The achievement gap is zero in Detroit largely because everyone’s doing really poorly, not because black students are doing particularly well.”

Several of the other districts with the lowest achievement gaps have similar profiles of high poverty and multiple attempts at education overhauls, suggesting their low achievement gaps come from lower performance overall.

Moreover, the researchers found some of the biggest black-white achievement gaps in the country—where black students lag their white peers by more than 1.5 full standard deviations, or four to five grade levels on the NAEP scale—in relatively prosperous university towns, including Berkeley, Calif. (home of University of California, Berkeley), and Evanston, Ill. (home of Northwestern University).

“Richer places have bigger achievement gaps than poorer places, all else being equal—which is quite striking and disturbing, since you’d hope that those places that have the most resources would be most effective at reducing the gaps,” Reardon said. He has a theory on why these higher education centers haven’t produced more equitable K-12 achievement: “Increased competition … a hyper achievement orientation.”

When competition increases, black and Hispanic families often lose out. Prior research shows on average, a black family lives in a poor neighborhood and their children attend schools with fewer resources than white families at the same income level.

Groups like the Education Trust, which work with districts to close achievement gaps, have seen that dynamic in practice.

“Equality doesn’t necessarily mean ‘the same,’” said Sonja Brookins Santelises, the Education Trust’s vice president of K-12 policy and practice and the newly tapped CEO of Baltimore city schools. “Higher-income families are investing more in personal wealth in the education of their children, beyond what comes from the school. If you give a low-income student the exact same resource as an upper-income student, but the need is greater for the low-income student, the gap is going to expand.”

Segregation ‘Feedback Cycle’

That parental drive to find the best education for their kids could ramp up economic segregation in neighborhoods, too.

Estimated White-Black Achievement Gap

BRIC ARCHIVE

SOURCE: Sean F. Reardon, Demetra Kalogrides, Erin Fahle, Kenneth Shores, and Benjamin Shear. Stanford Education Data Archive

A separate study by Ann Owens, an assistant sociology professor at the University of Southern California, found that neighborhoods in the 100 largest cities became steadily more isolated by income between 1990 and 2010—but the segregation was driven by families with school-age children.

“There’s really a feedback loop, and it’s often framed as, we can never have integrated schools while we have segregated neighborhoods,” Owens said. “But the flip side is true, as well: As long as schools are unequal and linked to neighborhoods, that’s going to play a big role in neighborhood segregation.”

A second study using the Stanford data looked at the effects of 16 different facets of racial segregation, including school and residential isolation, segregation within and between districts, racial or socioeconomic isolation, and differences in students’ likelihood of being exposed to peers of other races or income groups.

While all types were associated with wider achievement gaps that worked against black and Hispanic students, the strongest gap predictor was the difference in poverty rates between schools with large populations of white or black and Hispanic students.

Estimated White-Hispanic Achievement Gap

BRIC ARCHIVE

SOURCE: Sean F. Reardon, Demetra Kalogrides, Erin Fahle, Kenneth Shores, and Benjamin Shear. Stanford Education Data Archive

The finding “suggests it’s something about school quality—not only about racial segregation, but about the fact that racial segregation in America almost inevitably leads to these kind of disparities in [students’] exposure to poverty and differences in the kinds of resources that schools have.”

Other studies have found systemic differences in resources and in the types of assignments given to students in high-poverty schools; in a 2015 study, for example, 8th graders in high-poverty schools were given shorter writing assignments calling for less critical thinking.

Going forward, the researchers are trying to identify common factors in districts where achievement gaps for black and Hispanic students are narrowing.

“Really, there are very, very few school districts that serve a large proportion of poor students and that have achievement that’s even at the national average,” Reardon said. “That suggests we may not be able to just ‘school reform’ our way out of that kind of inequality.”

A version of this article appeared in the May 11, 2016 edition of Education Week as Rich Districts Post Widest Racial Gaps

Events

School & District Management Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table: Strategies & Tips for Complex Decision-Making
Schools are working through the most disruptive period in the history of modern education, facing a pandemic, economic problems, social justice issues, and rapid technological change all at once. But even after the pandemic ends,
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Education Funding Webinar
From Crisis to Opportunity: How Districts Rebuild to Improve Student Well-Being
K-12 leaders discuss the impact of federal funding, prioritizing holistic student support, and how technology can help.
Content provided by Salesforce.org
Classroom Technology Online Summit Technology & the Pandemic: What’s Next for Schools?
When it comes to the use of technology, what’s next for schools?  Join the discussion to tackle issues surrounding this important question.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Equity & Diversity Explainer What Is Critical Race Theory, and Why Is It Under Attack?
Debates about critical race theory are coming to your district, board room, and classroom. Here's what you need to understand about the academic concept—and how it's portrayed in political circles.
10 min read
Illustrations.
Mary Hassdyk for Education Week
Equity & Diversity Group Seeks Federal Probes Into Schools That Pledge to Address Systemic Racism
Parents Defending Education, a group critical of anti-racism and "woke" education, says such district efforts may violate federal law.
8 min read
Image of a scale.
wildpixel/iStock/Getty
Equity & Diversity Opinion Does Your District's Way of Decisionmaking Reinforce Systemic Racism?
Leaders must ask if their vision of student success reflects what Black and brown families say is most important, write John B. Diamond and Jennifer Cheatham.
Jennifer Cheatham & John B. Diamond
5 min read
three leaders escape from behind bars
francescoch/iStock/Getty Images Plus
Equity & Diversity Why Two Superintendents of Mostly White Districts Are Actively Fighting Anti-Black Racism
Predominantly white school districts across the country have started addressing systemic racism in the classroom, but not every district is doing it, and those who are brace for backlash.
5 min read
Outdoor education teacher Mark Savage challenges his students with a game in class at Brewer High School in Brewer, Maine on April 30, 2021.
Outdoor education teacher Mark Savage challenges his students with a game in class at Brewer High School in Brewer, Maine in April.
Linda Coan O’Kresik for Education Week