Special Education

Supreme Court Backs Family in Case on Denial of Service Dog in School

By Mark Walsh — February 28, 2017 4 min read
Ehlena Fry, a Michigan 6th grader who has cerebral palsy, sits with Wonder, her retired service dog. She had been denied use of the dog by her former school district.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The U.S. Supreme Court has given a unanimous—but, for now, partial—victory to a family that sued a Michigan school district under federal disabilities laws after the district barred a service dog for a child with cerebral palsy.

In Fry v. Napoleon Community Schools (Case No. 15-497), the high court held that a student or family suing a school district over a disability-related issue does not always have to go through, or “exhaust,” all the procedures under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act before going to court.

The court held that IDEA procedures need not be exhausted when the essence, or “gravamen,” of a lawsuit centers on a violation of other federal disabilities law rather than the special education law’s core guarantee of a “free, appropriate special education.”

“If, in a suit brought under a different statute, the remedy sought is not for the denial of a FAPE, then exhaustion of the IDEA’s procedures is not required,” Justice Elena Kagan wrote in an opinion for the court.

The case involved Ehlena Fry, a Michigan student who was denied the use of her service dog by her former district, the Napoleon Community Schools. Kagan said a federal appeals court did not undertake the proper analysis of whether the suit was mainly about special education or essentially about vindicating the child’s rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 or the Rehabilitation Act of 1973.

Kagan suggested that it was more likely the latter since Fry was seeking to use her service dog for better accessibility at school.

“The Frys’ complaint alleges only disability-based discrimination, without making any reference to the adequacy of the special education services E.F.'s school provided,” Kagan wrote.

“On remand,” Kagan added, “the court below should establish whether (or to what extent) the Frys invoked the IDEA’s dispute-resolution process before bringing this suit. And if the Frys started down that road, the court should decide whether their actions reveal that the gravamen of their complaint is indeed the denial of a FAPE, thus necessitating further exhaustion.”

Stacy Fry, Ehlena’s mother, said in an interview that she was elated by the decision, especially the 8-0 judgment of the court.

“For us, it’s just that no child should have their life put on hold because they choose to be as independent as possible by using a medically prescribed service dog,” she said. “This is huge for families going through discrimination. If they’re not arguing their education, they can avoid the legal drag-out of that.”

‘Close to Total Victory’

Ehlena Fry is now in the 6th grade in the nearby Manchester, Mich., district. She no longer relies on her service dog, a goldendoodle named Wonder, at school. But her family is seeking damages in their disability-discrimination suit, a remedy they could still receive after another round or two of court proceedings.

Michael J. Steinberg, the legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan, which represented the Fry family, called the decision “pretty close to total victory,” adding, “We feel very good about winning on remand” when the case returns to the lower courts.

The lawyer for the Napoleon district did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justices Anthony M. Kennedy, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen G. Breyer, and Sonia Sotomayor joined Kagan’s opinion.

Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. filed an opinion concurring in part and concurring in the judgment, joined by Justice Clarence Thomas. Alito said he objected to some of the “clues” that Kagan’s opinion provided to the lower courts that might handle similar cases.

Kagan stressed that the IDEA guarantees individually tailored educational services, while the ADA and Rehabilitation Act “promise nondiscriminatory access to public institutions.”

She said “one clue” to whether a suit against a school essentially concerns denial of a free, appropriate public education or disability-based discrimination can come by asking whether the plaintiff could bring the same claim if the alleged conduct had occurred at, say, a public library instead of a school.

And, she said, one could ask whether an adult at a school, such as an employee or a visitor, could bring the same grievance.

“When the answer to those questions is yes, a complaint that does not expressly allege the denial of a FAPE is also unlikely to be truly about that subject,” Kagan said. “After all, in those other situations, there is no FAPE obligation, and yet the same basic suit could go forward.”

“But when the answer is no,” she wrote, “then the complaint probably does concern a FAPE, even if it does not explicitly say so; for the FAPE requirement is all that explains why only a child in the school setting (not an adult in that setting or a child in some other) has a viable claim.”

Alito declined to join that portion of Kagan’s opinion, saying in his concurrence that her clues “are likely to confuse and lead courts astray.”

A version of this article appeared in the March 01, 2017 edition of Education Week as High Court Backs Family in Case of Service Dog at School


Classroom Technology Webinar Building Better Blended Learning in K-12 Schools
The pandemic and the increasing use of technology in K-12 education it prompted has added renewed energy to the blended learning movement as most students are now learning in school buildings (and will likely continue

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Special Education Florida Changed Rules for Special Education Students. Why Many Say It’s Wrong
The new rule contains a more specific definition of what it means to have a “most significant cognitive disability.”
Jeffrey S. Solochek, Tampa Bay Times
7 min read
Richard Corcoran, the Commissioner of the Florida Department of Education sits next to Florida Department of Education Board Chair Andy Tuck as they listen to speakers during Thursday morning's Florida Department of Education meeting. The board members of the Florida Department of Education met Thursday, June 10, 2021 at the Florida State College at Jacksonville's Advanced Technology Center in Jacksonville, Fla. to take care of routine business but then held public comments before a vote to remove critical race theory from Florida classrooms.
Richard Corcoran, Florida’s education commissioner, and Andy Tuck, the chair of the state’s board of education, listen to speakers at a meeting  in June.
Bob Self/The Florida Times-Union via AP
Special Education 6 Ways to Communicate Better With Parents of Students With Learning Differences
For students who learn or think differently, a strong network of support is key. Here are 6 tips for bridging the communication gap between families and schools.
Marina Whiteleather
3 min read
network of quote bubbles
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Special Education Whitepaper
4 Ways to Support Students at Risk for Dyslexia
Read this white paper: Dyslexia Screening and the Use of Acadience™ Reading and discover four distinct ways educators can improve student...
Content provided by Voyager Sopris Learning
Special Education New York City Will Phase Out Controversial Gifted and Talented Program
The massive change is aimed at addressing racial disparities in the biggest school system in the country.
Michael Elsen-Rooney, New York Daily News
4 min read
Students write and draw positive affirmations on poster board at P.S. 5 Port Morris, an elementary school in The Bronx borough of New York on Aug. 17, 2021. New York City will phase out its program for gifted and talented students that critics say favors whites and Asian American students, while enrolling disproportionately few Black and Latino children, in the nation's largest and arguably most segregated school system.
Students write and draw positive affirmations on poster board at P.S. 5 Port Morris, an elementary school in The Bronx borough of New York on Aug. 17, 2021. New York City will phase out its program for gifted and talented students that critics say favors whites and Asian American students, while enrolling disproportionately few Black and Latino children, in the nation's largest and arguably most segregated school system.
Brittainy Newman/AP