Teaching Profession

Study Ranks Teachers’ Union Strength

By Stephen Sawchuk — November 06, 2012 5 min read

Whether it’s the right to strike, a flush membership, or an attentive legislature, the factors that build the political strength and reputation of a state’s teachers’ unions are multiple and interwoven, concludes a long-awaited analysis.

Released last week by the Washington-based Thomas B. Fordham Institute and the New York City-based advocacy group Education Reform Now, the report ranks states’ unions into five tiers, from strongest to weakest, based on an analysis of 37 criteria in five areas. Hawaii’s statewide union—now teetering on the edge of a strike—was deemed the strongest and Arizona’s the weakest.

A few of the report’s findings seem obvious: Mandatory bargaining laws and fuller coffers appear to help unions strengthen their hands. But for the most part, the study unearths few cut-and-dried patterns across the states.

“Let us admit that its conclusions are more nuanced, even equivocal, than we’re accustomed to,” Fordham officials write in the report’s foreword.

The source of the report raised some concerns among unions. The right-leaning Fordham group and Education Reform Now, the nonprofit 501(c)3 wing of Democrats for Education Reform, a political action committee, have both tussled with teachers’ unions in the past. And union officials criticized the analysis on several fronts, including that such officials were not given a chance to review the findings before publication.

“It appears the report is deeply flawed and misleading,” Randi Weingarten, the president of the American Federation of Teachers, said in a statement. “It seems to omit many factors, including poverty.”

How to Use

Others felt that the report’s impact would best be gauged in terms of the uses others would make of it.

Level of Power

11unions c11

A new report categorizes the power of states’ teachers’ unions based on 37 criteria in five areas.

11unions c1s

SOURCE: Thomas B. Fordham Institute

The findings could, on the one hand, be used as a road map to weaken unions, or alternatively as a resource by those who believe strong unions play an important role in setting and improving education policy, said Jonathan S. Gyurko, a New York City-based education consultant who provided input into the study’s design.

“There is a dearth of research in this area. If this report prompts more research and more reaction, good,” said Mr. Gyurko, who has previously worked both for Ms. Weingarten and for the New York City education department. “If it exacerbates antagonistic relationships and impedes thoughtful dialogue about new policies, it’s been a disservice.”

Nuanced Factors

As interest in pay schedules and benefits has grown, scholars have often struggled to come up with good proxies for union strength beyond membership density and bargaining status. The report tries to analyze that question through a number of lenses.

“People don’t want to take this on because it’s messy, and it’s complicated, and it’s really hard to do,” said Amber Winkler, the Fordham Institute’s vice president for research. “We tried to look at what we thought most reasonable people would use as a measure of union strength.”

Individuals who provided input into the project design included: Mike Antonucci, an independent watchdog and critic of teachers’ unions; Dan Goldhaber, a well-known researcher at the University of Washington, in Bothell, who has studied pay schedules; and Katharine O. Strunk, an assistant professor of education policy at the University of Southern California, in Los Angeles, who has used empirical methods to examine the imprint of teachers’ unions on policy.

Each state’s unions were ranked on findings in five areas:

• Financial resources and membership numbers;

• Involvement in politics, including share of financial contributions to candidates and political parties;

• Scope of collective bargaining, including the right to “agency fees"—paid by nonmembers who benefit from union services—and the legality of strikes;

• Degree of alignment between the unions’ traditional positions on teacher workplace rules and charter schools, and state policies governing those areas; and

• Perceived influence, based on a survey of “key stakeholders” within each state.

After testing various ways of weighting the findings in each of the areas, the report’s authors decided to count them equally. Each was worth 20 percent, with subcomponents making up an equal share of that particular component’s overall score. In states with both National Education Association and AFT affiliates, the authors examined both unions, combining their resources.

The analysis does not address the hot-button topic of whether unionization affects student achievement. Generally, scholars say it is difficult to establish cause-and-effect relationships between unionization and outcomes, and the Fordham report’s findings are descriptive rather than causal.

“It’s a good first attempt to put together a lot of data on state-level teachers’ unions and associations that just doesn’t exist in one place,” Ms. Strunk of USC said. “It provides a data source for others to use. I don’t think the report claims to do much more than that.”

Among the findings, the study notes that state factors, such as the scope of bargaining, play a large role in determining whether the unions’ imprint is felt on education policy. Illinois’ mandatory-bargaining law, coupled with a broad scope of bargaining, for instance, allows teacher evaluation to become a major splinter issue in contract negotiations in Chicago, the report says.

But that pattern isn’t universal: Alabama’s NEA affiliate was deemed to be one of the 20 strongest unions, even though bargaining is not required in the state, nor is the union permitted to charge agency fees.

The report also postulates that, in some states, the relative weakness of the teachers’ unions might be because laws there are already largely favorable to teachers. Mississippi’s laws on charters and teacher work rules generally align with its union’s positions, even though it is not among the bigger or wealthier NEA affiliates, the report points out.

Though the project is probably the most detailed analysis ever conducted on the relative strength of teachers’ unions, Mr. Gyurko wondered whether it missed the opportunity to highlight a potentially more relevant comparison.

“The study and method tell us less about the strength of the union as compared to other stakeholders within the same state,” such as education advocacy groups or a robust charter school lobby, he said. “That’s the comparison—the balance of power—that is actually interesting when it comes time to making new state policies or advocating for change.”

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the November 07, 2012 edition of Education Week as Study Ranks Strength of Teachers’ Unions by State

Events

School & District Management Live Event EdWeek Leadership Symposium
Education Week's Premier Leadership Event for K12 School & District Leaders.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Well-Being Webinar
A Holistic Approach to Social-Emotional Learning
Register to learn about the components and benefits of holistically implemented SEL.
Content provided by Committee for Children
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Well-Being Webinar
How Principals Can Support Student Well-Being During COVID
Join this webinar for tips on how to support and prioritize student health and well-being during COVID.
Content provided by Unruly Studios

EdWeek Top School Jobs

President and CEO
Alexandria, Virginia
National Association of State Boards of Education
Interdisciplinary STEAM Specialist
Smyrna, Georgia
St. Benedict's Episcopal School
Interdisciplinary STEAM Specialist
Smyrna, Georgia
St. Benedict's Episcopal School
Arizona School Data Analyst - (AZVA)
Arizona, United States
K12 Inc.

Read Next

Teaching Profession Q&A Nation's Top Teachers Discuss the Post-Pandemic Future of the Profession
Despite the difficulties this school year brought, the four finalists for the National Teacher of the Year award say they're hopeful.
11 min read
National Teacher of the Year Finalists (clockwise from top left): Alejandro Diasgranados, Juliana Urtubey, John Arthur, Maureen Stover
National Teacher of the Year Finalists (clockwise from top left): Alejandro Diasgranados, Juliana Urtubey, John Arthur, Maureen Stover
Courtesy of CCSSO
Teaching Profession Teachers Are Stressed Out, and It's Causing Some to Quit
Stress, more so than low pay, is the main reason public school teachers quit. And COVID-19 has increased the pressure.
7 min read
Image of exit doors.
pavel_balanenko/iStock/Getty
Teaching Profession Opinion Should Teachers Be Prioritized for the COVID-19 Vaccine?
Not all states are moving teachers to the front of the vaccination line. Researchers discuss the implications for in-person learning.
6 min read
Teacher Lizbeth Osuna from Cooper Elementary receives the Moderna vaccine at a CPS vaccination site at Roberto Clemente High School in Chicago, Ill., Thursday, Feb. 11, 2021.
Chicago public school teacher Lizbeth Osuna receives the COVID-19 vaccine at a school vaccination site last week.
Anthony Vazquez/Chicago Sun-Times via AP
Teaching Profession Chicago Teachers Approve School Reopening Plan: ‘We Got What We Were Able to Take’
Chicago Teachers Union members have voted in favor of a reopening deal, signaling that in-person classes can resume Thursday as planned.
Hannah Leone & Katherine Rosenberg-Douglas
4 min read
Chicago Public Schools CEO Janice Jackson speaks during a news conference at City Hall in Chicago on Feb. 7, 2021. The Chicago Teachers Union has approved a deal with the nation’s third-largest school district to get students back to class during the coronavirus pandemic, union officials announced early Wednesday, Feb. 10, 2021.
Chicago Public Schools CEO Janice Jackson speaks during a news conference at City Hall in Chicago on Feb. 7. The Chicago Teachers Union has approved a deal with the nation’s third-largest school district to get students back to class during the coronavirus pandemic.
Brian Cassella/Chicago Tribune via AP