How a Proposed Tax Rule Could End Up Hurting School Vouchers

By Arianna Prothero — September 11, 2018 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

A tax rule proposed by the Trump administration as part of a crackdown on blue states trying to circumvent parts of the new GOP tax law could hurt school vouchers popular in many red states.

Tax-credit scholarships are voucher-like programs funded through tax breaks and private donations that have grown in popularity as a workaround to state constitutions that strictly prohibit public dollars flowing directly into private, religious schools, as they do in traditional voucher programs.

Private school choice advocates are up in arms that tax-credit scholarships are getting swept into another standoff between the Trump administration and Democratic-led states.

Under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act passed in 2017, wealthy residents in states such as New York and California face sizable increases in their federal tax bills because of a $10,000 cap on state and local tax deductions they can make on their federal returns. Democratic lawmakers allege the so-called SALT-cap unfairly targets left-leaning states.

In response, a few states came up with ways to circumvent the cap, modeled off of tax-credit scholarship programs, said Carl Davis, the research director at the left-leaning Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy.

State and local governments in Connecticut, New Jersey, and New York created charities where people could donate money to help fund public services such as education or health care and receive generous tax credits in return. Donors could turn around and claim 100 percent of the money they gave to those government-run charities as a charitable donation on their federal income tax return.

Other states are considering similar programs to help their high-earning residents.

But now the Treasury Department and the IRS have put the kibosh on the scheme with a new rule that says that people can no longer receive the federal charitable deduction on donations that they have also received a state tax-credit for—basically, no more double dipping.

And that includes tax-credit scholarship programs enacted well before the 2017 tax overhaul that use tax credits to incentivize donations to groups that provide scholarships to students to attend private schools.

Generous Programs

“These taxpayers want to look like philanthropists when they’re not,” said Davis. “The IRS is saying, we don’t care who you are donating to, if you get your money back, you get your money back, and you can’t count it as a charitable donation.”

Many tax-credit scholarship programs are so generous—sometimes offering a dollar-for-dollar tax-credit—that donors could actually make money off of their donation, if they claimed the federal deduction on top of the tax credit.

Davis said this is the case in 12 of the 18 states that have created tax-credit scholarships. Some states such as Florida and Illinois already prevent donors from claiming both state tax credits and federal charitable deductions on the same donations, he said.

Tax-credit scholarship programs that relied on offering big benefits to reel in donors interested in the tax breaks more than school choice stand to lose the most, said Leslie Hiner, the vice president of legal affairs at EdChoice, an advocacy, lobbying, and research organization.

School choice advocates were already worried that uncertainty over the new tax law was going to lead to a decline in donations to tax-credit scholarship programs—a concern that’s now compounded by the fact that the new IRS rule means there’s markedly less benefit to participating in many state programs.

“At this point, we’re dealing with a lot of unknowns,” said Hiner. “It’s not fair to taxpayers and it’s certainly not fair to these kids who are relying on these scholarships.”

Advocates Split

EdChoice estimates the new rule could impact 250,000 mostly low-income students. The proposed rule does not apply to corporate donations to tax-credit scholarship programs.

Voucher proponents have criticized the Treasury Department and the IRS, saying that the proposed rule could have been tailored to only target the new government-run charities that have popped up in response to the tax law.

While technically, yes, that would have been possible, it would have been a very political move, said Steven Rosenthal, a senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center.

“Just because you can draft a rule to hit one group but not another, doesn’t mean that it’s the correct rule from a policy standpoint,” said Rosenthal. “I don’t think it would be hard to give the red states, the school choice people, what they wanted ... but as a policy matter I think it would be completely inconsistent and foolish.”

But not all school choice advocates oppose closing the loophole. Excellence in Education, an influential education reform lobbying and advocacy group founded by former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, called the proposed rule “sound tax policy.”

“Just like no school choice supporter would advocate for a 130 percent state tax credit, neither should we push to preserve a loophole in the federal tax code that allows donors to turn a $1,000 donation into $1,300 in lower taxes,” Adam Pesheck, the managing director of opportunity policy at ExcelInEd, wrote in a recent policy brief. He proposed delaying the implementation of the rule in order to allow states to adjust.

This scuffle over the SALT-cap and school choice may not be over. There may be lawsuits and the Treasury Department and the IRS could reverse course, said Rosenthal.

“These are only proposed regulations,” he said.

Coverage of how parents work with educators, community leaders and policymakers to make informed decisions about their children’s education is supported by a grant from the Walton Family Foundation, at www.waltonk12.org. Education Week retains sole editorial control over the content of this coverage.
A version of this article appeared in the September 12, 2018 edition of Education Week as How a Proposed Tax Rule Could End Up Hurting School Vouchers


Special Education Webinar Reading, Dyslexia, and Equity: Best Practices for Addressing a Threefold Challenge
Learn about proven strategies for instruction and intervention that support students with dyslexia.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Personalized Learning Webinar
No Time to Waste: Individualized Instruction Will Drive Change
Targeted support and intervention can boost student achievement. Join us to explore tutoring’s role in accelerating the turnaround. 
Content provided by Varsity Tutors for Schools
Student Well-Being K-12 Essentials Forum Social-Emotional Learning: Making It Meaningful
Join us for this event with educators and experts on the damage the pandemic did to academic and social and emotional well-being.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal What the Federal 'Don't Say Gay' Bill Actually Says
The bill would restrict federal funds for lessons on LGBTQ identities. The outcome of this week's election could revive its prospects.
4 min read
Demonstrators gather on the steps of the Florida Historic Capitol Museum in front of the Florida State Capitol on March 7, 2022, in Tallahassee, Fla. Florida House Republicans advanced a bill, dubbed by opponents as the "Don't Say Gay" bill, to forbid discussions of sexual orientation and gender identity in schools, rejecting criticism from Democrats who said the proposal demonizes LGBTQ people.
Demonstrators gather on the steps of the Florida Historic Capitol Museum in Tallahassee on March 7, 2022. Florida's "Don't Say Gay" law was a model for a federal bill introduced last month.
Wilfredo Lee/AP
Federal Fed's Education Research Board Is Back. Here's Why That Matters
Defunct for years, the National Board for Education Sciences has new members and new priorities.
2 min read
Image of a conference table.
Federal Opinion NAEP Needs to Be Kept at Arm’s Length From Politics
It’s in all our interests to ensure NAEP releases are buffered from political considerations and walled off from political appointees.
4 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
Federal Feds Emphasize Legal Protections for Pregnant or Recently Pregnant Students, Employees
The U.S. Department of Education has released a new resource summary related to pregnancy discrimination in schools.
2 min read
Young girl checking her pregnancy test, sitting on beige couch at home.
iStock/Getty Images Plus