A Think Tank Takes the Plunge

December 19, 2006 10 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The Thomas B. Fordham Foundation has long had a lot to say about education in the United States—what’s wrong with it and how to fix it.

But now, the outspoken Washington think tank isn’t just talking anymore. It’s parachuted down from the policy stratosphere into the thick of K-12 schooling, taking responsibility for overseeing a batch of charter schools in southwest Ohio.

The nine schools serve some 2,700 students, mostly from low-income and minority families. They run the gamut from two charters operated by the for-profit Edison Schools Inc. to a school started by a Baptist minister.

A national authority on charters and an unabashed champion of the idea, the Fordham Foundation appears to be the only think tank in the country to serve as a charter school authorizer. Called sponsors in Ohio, authorizers are responsible for issuing charters to the independent but publicly funded schools, monitoring them for performance, and deciding whether their charters should be renewed or revoked.

Fordham’s move into charter authorizing comes amid concern about the poor academic performance of many Ohio charters and as advocates nationally are calling for greater attention to the role authorizers play in charter school quality. Fordham officials say they hope the foundation will be a model authorizer, even while acknowledging that the proposition is a risk that could ultimately tarnish the organization’s reputation.

“We were almost dragged into this originally,” said Chester E. Finn Jr., Fordham’s president and an assistant U.S. secretary of education under President Reagan. “It’s much easier to talk the talk and write about other people.”

See Also

Now that it has taken the plunge, Fordham faces no shortage of difficulties. Some of the schools it assumed oversight for in July of last year face severe challenges, and are well under enrollment capacity. In one of its schools, in fact, the former head has been indicted on charges of stealing money from school coffers and falsifying enrollment records.

Critics, meanwhile, say private organizations, still a rarity in authorizing, are ill suited to provide oversight of public schools, regardless of their intentions. And some analysts suggest that aspects of the Fordham arrangement, such as giving grants to schools it sponsors, pose conflicts of interest that could impede its role as an accountability agent.

“When they’ve invested, then it’s hard to say, ‘We’ve made a mistake,’ ” said Gary Miron, an education professor at Western Michigan University who studies charters.

And yet, Fordham is also earning plaudits for taking on its unusual role.

“The Fordham Foundation has over the years been highly critical of a lot of education practices, especially related to public education,” said Thomas J. Lasley, the dean of the University of Dayton’s education school. “What Fordham did, which was a real risk, was to say, ‘We’re willing to enter the fray.’ ”

‘Exhausted Every Option’

With consensus building that Ohio’s state education agency had done a poor job as a sponsor, the state’s charter law was amended in 2003 to set a deadline—July 2005—for the state to step down from that role. As a result, many charters risked becoming orphans subject to closure.

The legislation for the first time permitted private nonprofit groups such as Fordham to apply to the state to become sponsors. School districts, public universities, and regional educational service centers can also serve as sponsors in the state.

Thomas B. Fordham Foundation

Click on link to see detail

  • The Dayton Academy (Dayton)
  • STATE RANKING: Continuous Improvement
  • DESCRIPTION: Opened in 1999. Operated by Edison Schools Inc., a for-profit educational management organization. School consists of several academies, or schools-within-a-school.

  • HTML; echo $text1; } ?>

  • East End Accelerated Community School (Dayton)
  • STATE RANKING: Continuous Improvement
  • DESCRIPTION: Opened in 2002, arising from a community center. Uses the Accelerated School Model.

  • HTML; echo $text2; } ?>

  • Dayton View Academy (Dayton)
  • STATE RANKING: Academic Watch
  • DESCRIPTION: Opened in 2000. Operated by Edison Schools. School consists of several academies.

  • HTML; echo $text3; } ?>

  • The Omega School of Excellence (Dayton)
  • GRADE SPAN: K-2, 5-8
  • STATE RANKING: Academic Emergency
  • DESCRIPTION: Opened in 1999 by a minister at the Omega Baptist Church. Recently hired a nonprofit charter-management operator, and reconstituted by replacing the principal and teachers.

  • HTML; echo $text4; } ?>

  • Cincinnati Speech and Reading Center (Cincinnati)
  • GRADE SPAN: K-12

  • DESCRIPTION: Opened in 2005. Targets students with speech and reading disabilities. Shares space and some staff with the W.E.B. DuBois Academy. On probation for failures in meeting its charter contract.

  • HTML; echo $text5; } ?>

  • W.E.B. DuBois Academy (Cincinnati)
  • GRADE SPAN: K-12

  • STATE RANKING: Effective
  • DESCRIPTION: Opened in 2000. School has been considered one of the highest-performing charters in Ohio. On probation for failures in meeting its charter contract.

  • HTML; echo $text6; } ?>

  • Veritas/Cesar Chavez Academy (Cincinnati)
  • GRADE SPAN: K-12

  • DESCRIPTION: Opened in 2005. Spinoff of W.E.B. DuBois Academy. Targets gifted African-American and Hispanic students. On probation for failures in meeting its charter contract.

  • HTML; echo $text7; } ?>

  • Phoenix Community Learning Center (Cincinnati)

  • STATE RANKING: Effective
  • DESCRIPTION: Opened in 2001. Focuses on character education, kinship, and community involvement. Uses the Ohio Curriculum Model, with a “workshop approach” and inquiry-based projects.

  • HTML; echo $text8; } ?>

Note: “State ranking” denotes a school’s performance ranking for the 2005-06 school year under Ohio’s school accountability system, which is based on 25 categories, including test results and graduation and attendance rates. From the lowest-performing to the highest, the rankings are: Academic Emergency, Academic Watch, Continuous Improvement, Effective, and Excellent. N/A means the category is not applicable because the school was not open long enough to receive a ranking. SOURCE: Thomas B. Fordham Foundation
Show all | Collapse box

“Our first impulse was to recruit and train other sponsors,” Mr. Finn said. But when that effort brought disappointing results, Fordham officials decided to step forward.

“We’ve exhausted every option,” Mr. Finn wrote in a 2004 memo to Fordham’s board of trustees. “Can we do it well? No guarantees. But we have a fighting chance.”

The board backed the move, but not every member liked the idea. “I was against it,” said the education historian Diane Ravitch, a professor at New York University and a longtime professional collaborator of Mr. Finn’s. “I don’t think think tanks should run schools, but I was outvoted.”

Referring to Mr. Finn by his nickname, she added: “Checker is a controversial figure, and I told him he would have a target on his back.”

In September 2004, Fordham was approved as the state’s first private nonprofit sponsor. Minnesota is the only other state with a charter law that explicitly permits private nonprofit groups to be authorizers.

See Also

Read the related story,

The Dayton area was a logical place for Fordham to get started. Although the foundation has its headquarters in Washington, its roots are here and it has long had an active presence in the community.

Some analysts say the foundation has played a big part in making Dayton—a city with a history of low-performing public schools—a hotbed of public school choice. Charters hold a larger market share here than in any other city but New Orleans. Nearly 30 percent of the city’s 23,000 public school students attended charters last school year, according to the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, a research and advocacy group in Washington.

Enviable Access

Given its national profile, the Fordham Foundation has access to resources many charter authorizers would envy. Last year, for example, it secured a three-year, $1.8 million grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to underwrite its charter sponsoring work. It also can easily tap leading experts for help.

Fordham itself has a modest grantmaking arm, too. In 2005, it paid out $553,000 in grants, with about half of that spent in Ohio. It has provided grants to Ohio charter schools, including ones it now sponsors.

Improving Ohio's Plunge

Amid serious concerns about the quality of Ohio’s charter schools, top state leaders recently asked the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, the sister organization of the Fordham Foundation, along with two national charter groups, to devise proposals to remedy the situation.

In an October report, the groups said the state should:

• Initiate a “housecleaning” process that requires the poorest-performing charter schools to obtain reapproval or close;

• Deter “sponsor hopping” by banning any closed school or school on probation from seeking a new sponsor, the term in Ohio for a charter authorizer;

• Implement a mandatory performance-based “sponsor-evaluation system” that clearly spells out the responsibilities of sponsors and contains progressive penalties for poorly performing sponsors;

• Conduct a study of actual sponsorship costs, and use state money to pay for sponsoring work;

• Reduce the reporting and compliance burden on charters by conducting a top-to-bottom review of all such demands;

• Provide charter operators with better access to facilities financing;

• Make other changes to ensure “reasonable parity” in funding between charter schools and regular public schools;

• Remove state-level caps on charter schools; and

• Eliminate geographic restrictions on where new charter schools can be located.

SOURCE: “Turning the Corner to Quality: Policy Guidelines for Strengthening Ohio’s Charter Schools,” by the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, and the National Association of Charter School Authorizers

The foundation runs its sponsorship operation out of a small second-story office in the historic Oregon district of Dayton.

Fordham officials say they prefer to interfere little with schools’ work. “If they’re organizationally strong and they’re delivering the goods, our approach is to, as much as possible, stay out of their way and encourage their development and improvement,” said Terry Ryan, Fordham’s vice president for Ohio programs and policy, who spends about half his time on sponsorship.

But Fordham officials say they are serious about strong academic expectations and public transparency. Taking a cue from authorizers it admires, the foundation in late November published the first of what it calls an annual accountability report on its sponsorship. The 144-page document describes Fordham’s role and provides detailed information about the schools it oversees, including academic benchmarks they made or missed.

The heart of the sponsorship operation, the report says, is the accountability plan agreed to by each school. It sets measurable goals, most of which relate to performance on state assessments and other tests. The foundation executes oversight through site visits and an online document-housing database it’s using.

Fordham also has volunteered for a pilot evaluation system for charter school authorizers the state launched this year to promote better-quality sponsorship.

And it’s taken to heart Ohio’s requirement that sponsors provide technical assistance to the schools they oversee. For instance, it paid for the Englewood, Colo.-based Center for Performance Assessment to help schools use test data to improve instruction. It also brought in a national charter expert to conduct evaluations at schools with low state ratings.

‘Painful Stories’

Fordham’s grants to charters typically are about $5,000 or $10,000, but it recently dug deeper into its pocket to help out the Omega School of Excellence, a school to which it has long-standing ties. Founded by a minister at the Omega Baptist church in Dayton, the charter has seen a backward slide over the past couple of years in academics, finances, and enrollment. With encouragement from Fordham, the school has put in place a new teaching staff and principal. The foundation this year gave it a $100,000 matching grant to help it stay afloat.

At the same time, Fordham recently took steps to crack down on the W.E.B. DuBois Academy and its two sister schools in Cincinnati. The former superintendent for the DuBois Academy was indicted in October. Fordham last month placed the schools on probation, citing numerous violations of their charter contracts.

Board members for several schools describe the foundation as more engaged sponsor than the Ohio Department of Education was. “Fordham has asked us to raise the bar,” said Donald B. Jentleson, the board president for the East End Accelerated Community School in Dayton. “Having them push us, having them provide us with technical assistance, has been a very positive relationship.”

As a leading critic of charter schools in the state, the Ohio affiliate of the American Federation of Teachers has often butted heads with Fordham and opposed allowing nonpublic groups to become authorizers. But Tom Mooney, the Ohio Federation of Teachers’ late president, said in an interview last month, shortly before his death, that while he still opposed that policy, he thought Fordham officials were “sincere in what they’re trying to do.”

“Fordham wants to be a responsible sponsor, and impose higher standards of quality,” he said.

Mr. Ryan, who has worked at Fordham since 2001, said the experience of being a charter authorizer had led him to better appreciate the tremendous challenge of educating disadvantaged students in urban communities.

“I’m amazed at some of the really, really painful stories that 6-year-olds and 7-year-olds are bringing to school, and the efforts of schools to deal with these things,” he said. “I’ve gained more respect for traditional educators.”

Coverage of new schooling arrangements and classroom improvement efforts is supported by a grant from the Annenberg Foundation.
A version of this article appeared in the December 20, 2006 edition of Education Week as A Think Tank Takes the Plunge


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Mathematics Webinar
Pave the Path to Excellence in Math
Empower your students' math journey with Sue O'Connell, author of “Math in Practice” and “Navigating Numeracy.”
Content provided by hand2mind
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Recruitment & Retention Webinar
Combatting Teacher Shortages: Strategies for Classroom Balance and Learning Success
Learn from leaders in education as they share insights and strategies to support teachers and students.
Content provided by DreamBox Learning
Classroom Technology K-12 Essentials Forum Reading Instruction and AI: New Strategies for the Big Education Challenges of Our Time
Join the conversation as experts in the field explore these instructional pain points and offer game-changing guidance for K-12 leaders and educators.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal Opinion Republicans Keep Talking About Abolishing the Education Department. Why?
GOP presidential candidates have pledged to ax the federal agency. But it's unlikely they'll be able to keep those promises.
4 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
Federal Dianne Feinstein's Fight to Stop Gun Violence in Schools Central to Her Legacy
The California Senator will be remembered for her strong support of gun restrictions to stop school shootings.
5 min read
Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., speaks to members of the media as crowds of people participate in the "March for Our Lives" rally in support of gun control on March 24, 2018, in San Francisco.
Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., speaks to members of the media as crowds of people participate in the "March for Our Lives" rally in support of gun control on March 24, 2018, in San Francisco.
Josh Edelson/AP
Federal Obituary Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein of California, an Advocate for Liberal Priorities, Dies at Age 90
Feinstein pushed for bans on military-style weapons after the 2012 mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut.
10 min read
Senator Dianne Feinstein shakes hands with supporters of Planned Parenthood on July 6, 2018, in Oakland, Calif.
Senator Dianne Feinstein shakes hands with supporters of Planned Parenthood on July 6, 2018, in Oakland, Calif.
Lea Suzuki/San Francisco Chronicle via AP
Federal Biden Credits School Shooting Survivors as He Creates Gun Violence Prevention Office
President Biden announced the first-ever White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention, fulfilling a long-time goal of school shooting survivors.
5 min read
President Joe Biden speaks about gun safety on Sept. 22, 2023, from the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington. Rep. Maxwell Frost, D-Fla., applauds at left.
President Joe Biden speaks about gun safety on Sept. 22, 2023, from the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington. Rep. Maxwell Frost, D-Fla., applauds at left.
Jacquelyn Martin/AP