Teaching Profession

Why Did Duncan’s Letter Backfire?

By Anthony Rebora — May 11, 2011 1 min read

In case you missed the fireworks last week, Diane Ravitch recaps the negative reaction to Education Secretary Arne Duncan’s open letter to teachers during Teacher Appreciation Week. A memorable way of putting it:

It [the letter] should have been about as controversial as the president's annual Thanksgiving message, but in this case the letter backfired. Teachers reacted to the letter with outrage, as if it were addressed to the turkey community on Thanksgiving Day.

As Ravitch notes, the department insists that the negative feedback does not represent the views of the majority of teachers or at least teachers as a whole—which there may be some evidence for. But what’s your sense? Is there an alternative storyline here?

A version of this news article first appeared in the Teaching Now blog.