Opinion
Teaching Profession Opinion

Developing an Evaluation System for Teachers - Lessons Learned

By Stu Silberman — July 02, 2013 1 min read

Developing an Evaluation System for Teachers - Lessons Learned

Many states are developing new systems to evaluate teachers. While some have been successful, others have encountered significant problems. The Prichard
Committee for Academic Excellence has been studying issues related to teacher effectiveness for the last year and a half, and one of our areas of focus is
the way teachers are evaluated. As part of its review, our group of teachers, administrators, legislators, and advocates heard a presentation on the
Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) and the progress on Kentucky’s Professional Growth and Effectiveness System (PGES).

These articles provide more details about new evaluation systems across the country:


New system: Half a teacher’s evaluation will be based on an observation ... OhioTeachers Could Strike Over State’s New Teacher Evaluation System


City, Teachers’ Union Praise State-Imposed Teacher Evaluation


Feds, state in standoff on new teacher rating system - Chicago


Texas districts test new teacher evaluation systems for state model. Against all odds, there is something that’s smaller in Texas. Who knew it would be
controversy?


Good scores not enough to stop criticism of new evaluation


Memphis’ new teacher evaluation system

One writer detailed why some systems don’t work in

Teacher Evaluations: Where They Went Awry.

In another piece,

Teacher Evaluations: We’ve Got to Come Up With a Better System,

we learn more about the way California uses test scores. I share these to emphasize the fact that there is serious controversy about these new systems.

Kentucky, a leader in many reform areas, is moving slowly in its development of a new evaluation system. By making the deliberate decision to go slower,
the state has allowed greater participation and input from stakeholders and is learning daily from the experiences of other states and their systems.
Kentucky’s process is detailed in an issue brief produced as part of the Prichard’s Team on Effective Teaching work,

Evaluating Teachers: Kentucky’s Approach to Creating a Successful System

, work that has been sponsored by the Committee on Economic Development.

As we all advocate to have high-quality teachers in every classroom we must support systems that focus on teachers’ growth. It is so
important not to rush to get this done but instead to encourage the input and feedback of all stakeholders.

Related Tags:

The opinions expressed in Public Engagement & Ed Reform are strictly those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.