Mathematics

Academics Urge Riley To Reconsider Math Endorsements

By Debra Viadero — November 24, 1999 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Nearly 200 mathematicians, physicists, and other scholars urged U.S. Secretary of Education Richard W. Riley last week to withdraw his department’s seal of approval from math programs for students in kindergarten through 12th grade.

Venturing deep into the “math wars” for the first time, federal officials last month designated 10 mathematics programs as either “exemplary” or “promising” based on a two-year review of their effectiveness. (“Ed. Dept. To Release List of Recommended Math Programs,” Oct. 6, 1999.) But the academics, in a signed letter published as a full-page advertisement in The Washington Post Nov. 18, said the government had acted too hastily.

Some of the programs, they asserted, neglect to teach skills as basic as multiplying two-digit numbers or dividing fractions.

“How can anybody call that exemplary?” said David Klein, a mathematics professor at California State University—Northridge and one of five co-authors of the letter. “It just doesn’t make sense.”

The 192 scholars and educators joining Mr. Klein included four Nobel laureates, Arizona’s state schools superintendent, a handful of prominent education researchers, and two recipients of the Fields Medal, the top honor for mathematicians. The newspaper ad, costing around $67,000, was paid for by the Packard Humanities Institute, a foundation based in Los Altos, Calif.

‘Prevailing Standards’

The high-profile plea, however, is not expected to move the U.S. Department of Education to back down from its endorsements, according to Linda P. Rosen, the department’s top math education adviser. “I don’t know how closely the signers of the letters looked at the materials,” she said. “But I do know the process the expert panel went through, and what was clear was that students who were using these materials were showing higher achievement.”

At issue in the debate are fundamental disagreements over the best way to teach math. All the programs on the Education Department’s list reflect national standards for teaching the subject that were written by the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics 10 years ago. Those guidelines, which are being revised, emphasize a more integrated, hands-on approach to learning math than students get in traditional classes.

“They’re the prevailing standards in the country, so we thought that would make sense,” Mr. Riley said last week of the review, which was ordered by Congress nearly five years ago.

But the standards have come under heavy attack in recent years with critics contending that programs based on them are short on basic math skills and heavy on calculator use, among other problems. Parents in Plano, Texas, even went to federal court in August to protest that district’s use of the Connected Mathematics program, one of the “exemplary” programs named by the department.

“This only lowers the standards for math education,” charged Betty Tsang, a physicist at Michigan State University in East Lansing and a co-author of the letter. She said she became familiar with Connected Mathematics, a program created at her own university, through her daughters’ school. “What it does is teach to the lowest common denominator,” she said.

Membership Criticized

The scholars also complained that department panels appointed to review the math programs lacked “active research mathematicians.’' At least two of the 17 experts on the final review panel were university-based mathematicians. But most of the field reviewers who took a first pass at the programs were teachers.

“It’s a shame when mathematicians are criticizing other mathematicians,” said Ann Watkins, who is one herself as well as an original architect of the Core-Plus Mathematics Project, another program on the “exemplary” list.

“When I look at these programs,” said Eric Robinson, an associate professor of mathematics at Ithaca College in New York, “what I see trying to be done goes way beyond arithmetic. Mathematics is also about thinking.”

But Hung-His Wu, another co-author of the letter, said he was driven to write and publish the message out of a “sense of duty.”

“If something is declared exemplary, there is a lot of pressure on people who do not really know math to use it, and, if we know that is not the case, we should stand up and say so,” said Mr. Wu, a professor of mathematics at the University of California, Berkeley.

The Education Department plans to review math curricula again next year. Mr. Riley said the next panel would reassess the status of math standards before deciding on its criteria for success.

Related Tags:

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Assessment Webinar
Rethinking STEM Assessment: Strategies for Administrators
School and district leaders will explore strategies to enhance STEM assessment practices across their district, within schools and classrooms.
Content provided by Project Lead The Way
Federal Webinar Keeping Up with the Trump Administration's Latest K-12 Moves: Subscriber-Exclusive Quick Hit
EdWeek subscribers, join this 30-minute webinar to find out what the latest federal policy changes mean for K-12 education.
Artificial Intelligence Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table: Math & Technology: Finding the Recipe for Student Success
How should we balance AI & math instruction? Join our discussion on preparing future-ready students.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Mathematics What Math Learned in School Is Most Important? Adults and Their Managers Don't Agree
Americans don’t always agree about which skills are the most crucial, according to a new survey from Gallup.
5 min read
Elementary math teacher Margie Howells teaches a fifth grade class at Wheeling Country Day School in Wheeling, WV, on Tuesday, Sept. 5, 2023. Howells said that she turned to the science of math after wondering why there weren't as many resources for dyscalculia as there were for dyslexia. Reading the research helped her become more explicit about things that she assumed students understood, like the fact that the horizontal line in a fraction means the same thing as a division sign. "I'm doing a lot more instruction in vocabulary and symbol explanations so that the students have that built-in understanding," said Howells.
Elementary math teacher Margie Howells teaches a 5th grade class at Wheeling Country Day School in Wheeling, W.V., on Sept. 5, 2023. A new survey of U.S. adults finds that they don't agree on the math skills that are most crucial.
Gene J. Puskar/AP
Mathematics Is It Bad to Memorize All Those Algorithms in Math?
Algorithms are at the heart of math debates. Math experts chime in on the topic.
5 min read
A seventh grade student writes on the whiteboard in class in M-Cubed Academy at Community Lab School in Charlottesville, Va., on June 21, 2023.
A seventh grade student writes on the whiteboard in class in M-Cubed Academy at Community Lab School in Charlottesville, Va., on June 21, 2023. Although most scholars say learning math algorithms like regrouping in addition are essential, some worry that schools don't do enough to support the concepts undergirding these common procedures.
Cal Cary/The Daily Progress via AP
Mathematics Q&A How This Teacher Makes Math a Team Sport—and Gets Kids Excited to Participate
Fifth grade teacher Michaela Sicuranza helped lead her Title I school to a math championship. Here's how she gets kids excited about math.
5 min read
Image of pep rally gear with "2-4-6-8"
DigitalVision Vectors
Mathematics Three Ways to Build Student Confidence in Math
Experts talk about math anxiety and ways to ease it.
3 min read
Fifth grade students attend a math lesson with teacher Alex Ventresca, right, during class at Mount Vernon Community School, in Alexandria, Va., Wednesday, May 1, 2024.
Fifth grade students attend a math lesson with teacher Alex Ventresca, right, during class at Mount Vernon Community School, in Alexandria, Va., Wednesday, May 1, 2024. Math anxiety prevents students from learning, but experts in the subject offer ways to help students.
Jacquelyn Martin/AP