Law & Courts

Why the Pandemic’s Recession May Fuel Legal Push for More K-12 Aid

By Daarel Burnette II — October 20, 2020 5 min read
BRIC ARCHIVE
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Could the pandemic and its economic fallout add fuel to the legal battle for more K-12 aid and the overhaul of state funding formulas?

For school finance lawyers and the scholars who follow these cases, the answer is a decisive yes.

“Advocates for public education, educators, civil rights organizations, have to really step it up now even more so than ever before to make sure that state legislatures don’t cut K-12 aid during this pandemic,” said David Sciarra, the executive director of the Education Law Center, which has litigated several school funding cases, including one in Flint, Mich., regarding aid for children diagnosed with lead poisoning. “We know that when they do, that the poorest and most vulnerable districts are always going to take it on the chin.”

Others argue that the pandemic may even inspire a new round of lawsuits.

“During the last recession, people were afraid to sue in the first few years because they thought the courts would be less receptive or legislation would be harder to get through because states were broke,” said Derek Black, a scholar at the University of South Carolina who recently published Schoolhouse Burning, a book that argues the last decade was one of the most politically and financially devastating for public schools.

“But I think this time around, folks are thinking, ‘We gave you a pass during the last recession, but what we found is that you operated with a level of such bad faith, you won’t get a pass this time.’ They’re going to sue much more quickly.”

Legislatures vs. Courts

State attorneys general historically have argued that legislatures, not courts, should decide how to spend K-12 aid and that overhauling property, income, and sales tax systems is too politically difficult, especially during a recession when voters are financially struggling. Fiscal hawks have argued that low-income districts don’t properly manage their money and that money can’t actually improve academic outcomes.

But just last week, Delaware’s Democratic Gov. John Carney settled a case with the state NAACP and a coalition of school funding advocates alleging that Delaware’s antiquated school funding mechanism leaves students with special needs, English-language learners, and poor, Black, and Latino students attending severely underfunded schools that continually fail to meet the state’s own academic benchmarks.

According to the settlement, the state’s governor will be legally obligated by 2024 to propose a budget that will alter Delaware’s tax structure to annually provide at least $60 million for the state’s historically disadvantaged students.

The ruling showed that courts may institute decisions that hold states’ feet to the fire for years to come, said Michael Rebell, a professor and executive director of the Center for Educational Equity at Teachers College, Columbia University, who has tracked school funding litigation.

“Delaware basically said, ‘We’re not going to squeeze the state to come up with money during the middle of this pandemic when revenue is being cut, but we’ll make a settlement that’s looking at a future time period,” Rebell said.

Even after rulings as in the case of Delaware, it can take several years for legislatures to comply. But lawyers also point out that states can raise taxes and redistribute property tax revenue in order to provide low-income districts with more money during a recession.

The Delaware settlement came on the heels of rulings in Connecticut, New Mexico, and North Carolina in which politicians and judges alike agreed that school funding formulas failed to meet constitutional merit.

Similar school funding cases are set to be heard in New York, Pennsylvania, and Tennessee in the coming months.

Progress Wiped Out

The last recession was financially ruinous for poor and majority Black and Latino school districts, almost wiping out the progress states had made in the last half century in closing funding gaps between property-rich and property-poor school districts. Many of those school districts, even before the pandemic, had yet to financially recover from recession-era budget cuts.

The pandemic has again blown a crater in sales and income tax revenue on which property-poor school districts are heavily reliant. Without a substantial federal bailout, low-income districts are expected to lose millions of dollars in the coming years, which will undoubtedly have academic repercussions.

While school funding advocates have pinned their hopes on state courts as a backstop to budget cuts, cases take years to wind themselves through lower courts.

In 13 cases in the last decade alleging states’ K-12 spending was inadequate and/or inequitable, four state courts ruled in favor of the plaintiffs seeking changes to state K-12 spending, said Rebell, who is tracking cases. For cases in which plaintiffs were urging courts to force states to comply with previous rulings to provide more funds for schools, plaintiffs were successful eight out of 10 times.

“A lot of state courts were willing to say, ‘Even though it’s a recession, that doesn’t put students’ constitutional rights on hold. We said funding is inadequate, and we meant it and we’re going to follow through,’” Rebell said.

In the case of North Carolina, where the state’s supreme court ruled in January that the state has not provided a “sound, basic education” to a large segment of its student body, the legislature may be less willing to institute the sort of draconian budget cuts it would have without a ruling hanging over its head, Rebell and Sciara said.

But the mere threat of a lawsuit can also get legislatures to take more seriously political movements, such as the #RedforEd protests, in which teachers across several states rallied for better pay and more money for schools, to upend states’ inequitable funding strategies.

In Maryland last year, the state’s ACLU and NAACP threatened to reopen a school funding case after political wrangling stalled an effort to provide millions more dollars to low-income school districts.

For other school funding cases set to go to trial in the coming months, including in New York, Pennsylvania, and Tennessee, lawyers are gathering evidence provided by the pandemic to prove that states’ funding models continue to leave low-income districts unable to provide teaching and learning to their neediest students. Among their arguments: that many students don’t have access to laptop computers or broadband to sign into class; districts can’t afford to pay for the personal protective equipment necessary to avoid a coronavirus outbreak; and districts can’t afford to hire new staff members to avoid student crowding and maintain social distancing.

“When things get back to normal, what’s going to be the lingering impact of this thing?” Rebell asked. “How much of compensatory services are states going to need to provide to make up for what students have lost?”

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the October 28, 2020 edition of Education Week as Why the Pandemic’s Recession May Fuel Legal Push for More K-12 Aid

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Data Webinar
Working Smarter, Not Harder with Data
There is a new paradigm shift in K-12 education. Technology and data have leapt forward, advancing in ways that allow educators to better support students while also maximizing their most precious resource – time. The
Content provided by PowerSchool
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Deepen the Reach and Impact of Your Leadership
This webinar offers new and veteran leaders a unique opportunity to listen and interact with four of the most influential educational thinkers in North America. With their expert insights, you will learn the key elements
Content provided by Solution Tree
Science K-12 Essentials Forum Teaching Science Today: Challenges and Solutions
Join this event which will tackle handling controversy in the classroom, and making science education relevant for all students.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Law & Courts Supreme Court to Hear Case of Coach Who Prayed After Games in Defiance of School District
The U.S. Supreme Court will consider whether school districts may prohibit private religious expression by public school employees.
4 min read
Former Bremerton High School assistant football coach Joe Kennedy is in a conflict with the Bremerton, 
Wash., school district over his silent prayer after games.
Former Bremerton High School assistant football coach Joseph A. Kennedy stands at on the 50-yard line at Bremerton Memorial Stadium. The U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear an appeal over his dismissal for praying after football games.
Larry Steagall/Kitsap Sun via AP
Law & Courts Supreme Court Blocks Biden Vaccine Mandate Applying to Schools in Much of the Country
The justices ruled 6-3 to stay an Occupational Health and Safety Administration rule that covered schools in 26 states and two territories.
4 min read
Members of the Supreme Court pose for a group photo last April.
The U.S. Supreme Court blocked a federal vaccine mandate for large employers, including school districts in about half the states.
Erin Schaff/The New York Times via AP
Law & Courts Students Lose Appeal on Right to Civics Education, But Win Praise From Judges Anyway
A federal appellate court panel commended Rhode Island students for the novel effort, but said Supreme Court precedent stood in the way.
3 min read
Scales of justice and Gavel on wooden table and Lawyer or Judge working with agreement in Courtroom, Justice and Law concept.
Pattanaphong Khuankaew/iStock
Law & Courts High Court Appears Skeptical of Vaccine Mandate Covering Schools in Over Half the States
The Biden administration's OSHA rule applies to private employers with 100 or more workers, as well as school districts in 26 states.
4 min read
The Supreme Court shown Friday, Jan. 7, 2022, in Washington. The Supreme Court is taking up two major Biden administration efforts to bump up the nation's vaccination rate against COVID-19 at a time of spiking coronavirus cases because of the omicron variant.
The U.S. Supreme Court is weighing two Biden administration efforts to bump up the nation's vaccination rate against COVID-19.
Evan Vucci/AP