Law & Courts

Transgender Students’ Rights Get Skeptical Hearing in Federal Appeals Court

By Mark Walsh — February 24, 2022 5 min read
Transgender student Drew Adams speaks with reporters outside of the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta on Dec. 5, 2019.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

While several federal courts around the country have consistently recognized transgender student rights in recent years, oral arguments this week before a full federal appeals court suggest a potential victory for those seeking to limit such rights.

A ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit, in Atlanta, to uphold a Florida school district’s restrictions on restroom access for a transgender boy could set up a clash in the U.S. Supreme Court, which has grown more conservative since a 5-4 majority provided a major victory on LGBTQ rights just two years ago.

And the latest legal developments come as multiple state legislatures weigh bills that would restrict transgender students in school sports or from using restrooms that correspond to their gender identity.

“In the last seven or eight years, transgender students’ claims under Title IX or the equal-protection clause [of the U.S. Constitution] have been succeeding,” said Anthony Michael Kreis, an assistant professor of law at Georgia State University and an LGBTQ rights advocate. The fact that the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit, in Atlanta, tossed out an earlier panel decision in favor of a transgender student and heard reargument as the full court was “alarming,” he said.

“I think there is a good chance the court will radically undo the progress that has happened across the country, and in ways that will tee it up for the U.S. Supreme Court,” Kreis said.

President Joe Biden has weighed in on transgender student rights

The Florida case was argued at a time when some 130 bills are pending in state legislatures that would restrict transgender students in some form, according to the American Civil Liberties Union, which advocates for such students.

Indiana, Iowa, and Utah are moving forward with measures that would limit transgender girls from participating in school sports, the ACLU says. In Arizona, bills on sports and restroom access are advancing. And the Florida House of Representatives on Thursday passed a controversial bill that would prohibit classroom discussion about sexual orientation or gender identity “in primary grade levels or in a manner that is not age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate for students.”

The measure “defines that there are certain instructions related to gender and sexual orientation that are just not appropriate at certain ages, and we define that as kindergarten through 3rd grade,” state Rep. Joe Harding, a Republican who is sponsoring the bill, told Fox News.

At the White House on Wednesday, Press Secretary Jen Psaki reminded reporters that President Joe Biden had issued a statement against the Florida bill earlier this month.

Biden said on Feb. 9 that “every member of the LGBTQI+ community—especially the kids who will be impacted by this hateful bill—to know that you are loved and accepted just as you are. I have your back, and my administration will continue to fight for the protections and safety you deserve.”

The Biden administration participated on Feb. 22 in the argument before the en banc, or full, 11th Circuit court in support of Andrew Adams, a former student in the St. Johns County school district in northern Florida.

Adams challenged a school board policy that barred him from the boys’ restroom after he began presenting as a boy when he entered Nease High School in Ponte Vedra, Fla., in 2015.

The St. Johns district had adopted a policy that included using transgender students’ preferred pronouns, but it declined to allow transgender students to use restrooms or locker rooms consistent with their gender identity.

The district refused to accept Adams’s amended Florida birth certificate, which lists him as male, and instead relied on his birth certificate from the time of his enrollment, which listed Adams as female.

A federal district court ruled for Adams on claims under the 14th Amendment’s equal-protection clause and Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, which bars sex discrimination in federally funded schools.

A three-judge panel of the 11th Circuit ruled for Adams on the equal-protection claim over the strong dissent of one judge. The full 11th Circuit, which is dominated by Republican appointees and considered one of the most conservative among the federal appeals courts, agreed to throw out the panel decision and rehear the case.

The judges ask pointed questions involving gender-fluid students

Jeffrey Slanker, a lawyer representing the St. Johns school board, said, “There is a privacy interest in using the bathroom separate and apart from the other biological sex.”

He was pressed by some members of the court during an hourlong argument with livestreamed audio.

“Why wouldn’t the school district adopt a similar policy that other school districts and some states as a whole have adopted, which is, students use the bathrooms of the gender that they identify with?” said Judge Robin S. Rosenbaum.

Tara L. Borelli, representing Adams for the Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund, told the court that “Andrew Adams is treated differently because he was identified as one sex at birth and he identifies as male today.”

She was questioned hard by several members of the court. Judge Barbara Lagoa asked her how schools should handle a gender-fluid student. Judge Kevin C. Newsom asked about an “anatomical, biological boy who is bullied and asks to be in girls’ physical education class.” Why wouldn’t that boy be considered as treated differently under the law if a school refused his request, the judge asked.

Another judge asked why the court should discount the government’s interest in avoiding sexual assaults in restrooms or locker rooms “just because they haven’t happened?”

Elizabeth P. Hecker, a lawyer with the U.S. Department of Justice’s civil rights division, also argued in support of Adams, focusing on the view that the board’s policy violates Title IX.

“The school board’s asserted interest is in privacy, and forcing Mr. Adams out of the boys’ restroom does nothing to promote privacy here,” she said.

A group of 18 states filed a friend-of-the-court brief in support of the school board.

“Even if Title IX could plausibly be interpreted to require educational institutions to ignore biological sex when assigning transgender students to restrooms, the states certainly did not have clear notice of that requirement,” their brief says.

Chris Erchull, a staff attorney with GLBTQ Legal Defenders & Advocates, a Boston-based group that filed a brief in support of Adams, said the case can be viewed narrowly as one about a single transgender student’s denial of access to the restroom consistent with his gender identity.

“But the arguments showed there is some tension there,” he said. “Some people do want to look at this as a broad question.”

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Recruitment & Retention Webinar
Substitute Teacher Staffing Simplified: 5 Strategies for Success
Struggling to find quality substitute teachers? Join our webinar to learn key strategies to keep your classrooms covered and students learning.
Content provided by Kelly Education
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Artificial Intelligence Webinar
AI in Education: Empowering Educators to Tap into the Promise and Steer Clear of Peril
Explore the transformative potential of AI in education and learn how to harness its power to improve student outcomes.
Content provided by Panorama Education
English Learners Webinar Family and Community Engagement: Best Practices for English Learners
Strengthening the bond between schools and families is key to the success of English learners. Learn how to enhance family engagement and support student achievement.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Law & Courts Court Battles and Presidential Election Have Big Implications for Title IX Regulation
A federal appeals court heard arguments about whether some provisions of the Title IX regulation should be allowed to go into wider effect.
4 min read
Image of a gavel
iStock/Getty
Law & Courts Top Affirmative Action Foe Has New Target: Scholarships for Aspiring Minority Teachers
The legal activist behind the U.S. Supreme Court college admissions decision has now sued over an Illinois minority scholarship program.
3 min read
A picture of a gavel on a target.
Bill Oxford/Getty
Law & Courts This State Requires Schools to Teach the Bible. Parents and Teachers Are Suing
Opponents of an Oklahoma directive that compels schools to teach the Bible are suing the state’s superintendent of public instruction.
4 min read
Image of a young boy pulling the bible off of a bookshelf.
D-Keine/E+
Law & Courts States Sue TikTok Over 'Addictive' Design Features. What That Means for Schools
The lawsuits are the newest fight targeting social media platforms' algorithms.
3 min read
The United States government laws on certain social media applications such as TikTok
iStock/Getty