School Choice & Charters

Ohio Moves to Stem Abuse of New Vouchers

State warns schools about end-of-year enrollments by private school students.
By Erik W. Robelen — June 19, 2006 | Corrected: February 22, 2019 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Corrected: This story originally misidentified Tom Mooney’s position. He is the president of the Ohio Federation of Teachers.

Includes updates and/or revisions.

The Ohio Department of Education this month put school districts on notice that some parents have sought to game the state’s new voucher system for students in low-performing schools.

State officials say they have learned that, in a few cases, parents of children already in private schools have tried to enroll students in public schools where they would be eligible for the private-school- tuition aid.

“The Ohio Department of Education absolutely does not encourage this practice,” wrote Kimberly A. Murnieks, the chief program officer for the statewide voucher program, in a June 6 e-mail to districts.

The notice came just days before the June 9 deadline for families to apply for the vouchers, which can be used at secular or religious private schools. With plenty of vouchers, and open private-school spaces to spare, the department has announced that it will hold a second application period, from July 21 to Aug. 4.

Ohio this fall will welcome the first round of students to its statewide voucher program, which lawmakers approved last summer and is separate from its 11-year-old voucher program for Cleveland.

So far, the state has received nearly 2,600 applicants, well below the ceiling of 14,000 students who may participate. Some 46,000 students are eligible for the program, which offers vouchers worth up to $4,250 in grades K-8, and $5,000 for high school, to any student attending a public school in one of the two lowest categories of the state’s academic-accountability system for three straight years.

Making a Statement

While critics suggest the application rate, about 5.5 percent, is low, voucher advocates say they consider it robust when compared with the first year of voucher programs elsewhere.

Susan C. Zanner, the executive director of School Choice Ohio, a nonprofit organization established by the state last year to help with outreach, said it takes time to educate families, and then for families to take the steps needed.

“You have to go to the private school as a parent and a child, see if it’s a good fit, then take their required test for admission,” she said. “It’s not as if you can fill out an application on a street corner.”

Ohio Vouchers at a Glance

Ohio has two voucher programs that provide aid for tuition at secular or religious private schools: one specifically for Cleveland, and another for the rest of the state.


Established: 2005

Value: Up to $4,250 per child for grades K-8 and up to $5,000 for high school.

Eligibility: Any student in a public school that for three years has been in “academic emergency” or “academic watch,” the two lowest levels under Ohio’s accountability system. If demand exceeds supply, a lottery is to be held with preference given to students from low-income families.

Student participation: 2,568 students had applied for the 2006-07 school year by a June 9 deadline. Applications also to be accepted July 21-Aug. 4.

School participation: 256 private schools have said they will participate.


Established: 1995

Value: Up to $3,450, with state paying either 75 percent or 90 percent of school’s tuition, depending on family income.

Eligibility: Cleveland residents entering grades K-8 may apply, but vouchers may be used through grade 12. Students selected by lottery if demand exceeds supply, with preference given to those from low-income families.

Student participation: Roughly 5,600 students took part in 2005-06 school year.

School participation: Currently, 43 nonpublic schools in Cleveland, plus public schools in neighboring districts.

SOURCE: Ohio Department of Education

Ms. Murnieks said in an interview last week that “with any new program, it just takes a while to penetrate public consciousness, but I think that so far, the outreach efforts have been very successful.”

But Tom Mooney, the president of the Ohio Federation of Teachers, a vocal critic of vouchers, called the program “underutilized.” And he suggested a connection between the application rate and the reported last-minute attempts to secure eligibility.

“Word got out that the vouchers were not being utilized,” he contended. “There was actually, in some cases, an organized effort to encourage parents to go enroll in the public schools without ever intending to have their child set foot in one.”

Ms. Murnieks said the June 6 notice to districts came after the state had heard of some limited instances in which parents were improperly seeking the vouchers.

“There were isolated incidents, but I wanted to make a statement,” she said. “The public schools were wanting some guidance about how they could deal with such a situation which, obviously, was out of step with the intent of the program.”

The note to districts outlines the state definition for an “enrolled” student, but also said it will offer deference to districts in making final judgments in cases where parents attempted to enroll students in the final days or hours of the academic year.

Ms. Murnieks said the department will offer some recommendations about whether the state should make any administrative or legislative changes once it studies the matter more closely.

Eligibility Expanded

Earlier this spring, Ohio expanded the program’s eligibility pool, which is tied to the state’s accountability system.

Originally, it was limited to students who attend schools rated in the state’s lowest academic category, “academic emergency,” for three consecutive years. But the legislature in late March amended the law to make the vouchers accessible to students in the state’s second lowest category, “academic watch,” for three straight years.

The voucher program gives first preference to students from low-income families. Students from 23 school districts and 99 individual schools are currently eligible for the vouchers, Ms. Murnieks said.

Some news outlets have raised concerns about the application rate.

“Are the dollar amounts high enough?” The Columbus Dispatch asks in a June 9 editorial. “Does the state need to give private schools more incentive to participate? Most important, what can be done to make sure Ohioans know that the option is available?”

Mr. Mooney suggested that the program’s design creates barriers. He noted that, to get a voucher, a student must be accepted by a particular private school, and the school may decline to enroll a student, whether based on space constraints or the failure of a student to meet entrance requirements.

“I suspect that they are looking for students who will, quote, fit in, unquote,” he said. “I don’t mean that as a criticism [of the schools]. … That’s why they’re called private schools.”

Ms. Murnieks disputed Mr. Mooney’s reasoning.

“I have not had complaints from families that they were unable to find a private school [to attend],” she said, though she conceded that not all students may get their first choice.

“Some schools are more selective than others,” she said. “Some schools have more enrollment capacity than others.”

A version of this article appeared in the June 21, 2006 edition of Education Week as Ohio Moves to Stem Abuse of New Vouchers


Student Well-Being K-12 Essentials Forum Boosting Student and Staff Mental Health: What Schools Can Do
Join this free virtual event based on recent reporting on student and staff mental health challenges and how schools have responded.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Curriculum Webinar
Practical Methods for Integrating Computer Science into Core Curriculum
Dive into insights on integrating computer science into core curricula with expert tips and practical strategies to empower students at every grade level.
Content provided by
Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School Choice & Charters More Young Kids Opted for Private School After COVID Hit
Newly released federal data shed light on where some students who left public schools during the pandemic ended up.
3 min read
A teacher with group of students standing in private school campus courtyard and talking
School Choice & Charters Private School Choice Faces New Challenges as State Lawsuits Pile Up
The lawsuits target new, broader state programs that allow parents to use public money for private school expenses.
6 min read
Photo of collage of gavel and school building.
F. Sheehan for Education Week / Getty
School Choice & Charters Opinion Can a Network of Tiny, Teacher-Led Montessoris Spread Like Wildflowers?
Do the strengths of this school network hold lessons for traditional public schools?
5 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
School Choice & Charters Families Lament, Public School Advocates Celebrate End of Controversial Scholarship Tax Credit
The Illinois program prompted fierce debate over the merits of what some equate to a politically volatile school choice voucher program.
Jeremy Gorner, Dan Petrella, and Alysa Guffey, Chicago Tribune
8 min read
Karl, age 5, stands with his dad, Patrick Bittorf, on Nov. 10, 2023, as they join faculty members, students, parents and supporters at a news conference at Chicago Hope Academy to try to save the Invest in Kids tax credit scholarship program.
Karl, age 5, stands with his dad, Patrick Bittorf, on Nov. 10, 2023, as they join faculty members, students, parents, and supporters at a news conference at Chicago Hope Academy to try to save the Invest in Kids tax credit scholarship program.
Antonio Perez/Chicago Tribune via TNS