Education Funding

Mass. School Funding Comes Up Short, Judge Rules

By John Gehring — May 05, 2004 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

A Massachusetts judge ruled last week that while the state has spent billions of dollars on K-12 education over the past decade and has successfully set rigorous academic standards, the state must do more to help students from low-income families in its poorest districts.

The 358-page decision from Suffolk Superior Court Judge Margot Botsford found that the students from 19 school districts who brought the case were being shortchanged by the current school funding system.

She wrote that the school aid system has, among other problems, resulted in inadequate facilities, overcrowded classrooms, and an uneven implementation of state curriculum standards.

The decision represents the remedy phase of a 1993 school finance ruling from the state’s highest court, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, which found the state was not fulfilling its constitutional duty to provide an adequate education for all students.

That case, McDuffy v. Secretary of the Executive Office of Education, led to the state’s landmark education reform act in 1993. The law ushered in academic standards tied to an accountability system and called for major increases in school funding. Over the past decade, Massachusetts has spent about $30 billion on K-12 education.

But in 1999, the plaintiffs returned to the high court, arguing the state still had not done enough to meet its obligation under the Massachusetts Constitution to provide an adequate education to all children.

The justices sent the case back to superior court with directions that Judge Botsford make recommendations based on the latest findings in the ongoing litigation. As part of her review, four districts—Brockton, Lowell, Springfield, and Winchedon—were established as “focus districts” seen as representative of the plaintiffs’ claims.

“When one looks at the state as a whole, there have been some impressive results in terms of improvement in overall student performance,” Judge Botsford wrote in her April 26 decision.

“Nevertheless, the factual record establishes that the schools attended by the plaintiff children are not currently implementing the Massachusetts curriculum frameworks for all students, and are not currently equipping all students with the McDuffy capabilities,” she continued. “The inadequacies of the educational program provided in the four focus districts are many and deep.”

The judge recommended that state education leaders come up with an analysis of how much money would be needed to bring the districts up to speed, provide a preschool program for 3- and 4-year-olds, and improve funding for special education and school facilities.

The recommendations will be sent to the supreme court, which will review them and make a final decision in the case.

Judicial Concerns

David P. Driscoll, the state commissioner of education, said in an April 26 statement that the findings were “consistent with the efforts already under way by the administration, the legislature, and other education groups around the state. As commissioner, I am committed to providing all schools with the tools and resources they need to achieve even greater student success.”

But Rebecca McIntyre, a co-counsel for the plaintiffs, said the ruling was clear that the current approach does not go far enough.

“The most important finding is that the state is still not meeting its constitutional duty to provide all schoolchildren with a constitutionally sufficient education,” she said. “School funding is inadequate.”

State leaders must step up and recognize the need for action, she added: “I understand the legislature is claiming it’s strapped for cash, but we’re talking about a constitutional duty, and that’s not optional.”

The judge did not give a dollar figure on how much new money would be needed to address the problems.

Gov. Mitt Romney, speaking to reporters after an address to the Massachusetts Association of School Committees on April 27, said he believed that the judiciary in his state had overstepped its role when it recently recognized a right to same-sex marriage, and said he hoped that would not be the case with education.

“I’m certainly hopeful that in the area of funding for schools, they allow our state board of education, our legislature, and the rest of the executive branch to have the say,” the Republican governor told reporters.


Classroom Technology Webinar Building Better Blended Learning in K-12 Schools
The pandemic and the increasing use of technology in K-12 education it prompted has added renewed energy to the blended learning movement as most students are now learning in school buildings (and will likely continue

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Education Funding The Political Spotlight on Schools' COVID Relief Money Isn't Going Away
Politicians and researchers are among those scrutinizing the use and oversight of billions in pandemic education aid.
7 min read
Business man with brief case looking under a giant size bill (money).
iStock/Getty Images Plus
Education Funding Here's How Schools Can Use Federal COVID Aid to Solve Bus Driver and Other Transportation Woes
The Education Department outlines districts' options for using relief money to solve nationwide problems in getting kids to and from school.
2 min read
Students catch their bus near Ambridge Area Senior High School on the first day of Pennsylvania's mask mandate for K-12 schools and day care centers on Tuesday, Sept. 7, 2021, in Ambridge, Pa.
Students catch their bus near Ambridge Area Senior High School in Ambridge, Pa., earlier this year on the first day of Pennsylvania's mask mandate for K-12 schools.
Andrew Rush/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette via AP
Education Funding High Schoolers to Decide How to Spend $1.5 Million in COVID Funding
State officials called Connecticut's new Voice4Change campaign “a first-in-the-nation statewide student civic engagement initiative.”
1 min read
Image is an illustration of a school receiving financial aid.
Collage by Laura Baker/Education Week (Images: E+, Nuthawut Somsuk/iStock/Getty)
Education Funding North Carolina Must Spend $1.75B to Narrow Education Gap, Judge Orders
The judge's order has angered GOP lawmakers and will likely set up a constitutional showdown between the three state government branches.
4 min read
Image of money.