School & District Management

Study Finds Benefits to District Competition

By Debra Viadero — March 26, 1997 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

School districts spend less and do a better job in metropolitan areas where they compete with other districts for students, concludes an unorthodox study.

“When a district has a lot of competition,” said Caroline Minter Hoxby, the author of the study, “I think it makes everybody in the school district think about the kind of job they’re doing.”

Ms. Hoxby, an economist at Harvard University and the National Bureau of Economic Research, based her conclusions on an examination of “natural choice” among school districts in 320 metropolitan areas across the nation. Her study, which has not yet been published, was released earlier this year.

While much of the debate over school choice has focused on whether parents should have more options in deciding which schools--public or private--their children will attend, Ms. Hoxby pointed out that families already exercise choice when they decide where to live.

“Let’s say there are three or four things you consider when you buy a house,” Ms. Hoxby said. “You look at what the house and the neighborhood is like, the commute, and the schools.”

For some cities, such as Los Angeles or Miami, families in which the major breadwinner works downtown have only one district to choose from in the surrounding area. In Boston, on the other hand, 45 districts lie within a 30-minute commute of the city.

Ms. Hoxby attempted to measure the degree of public school choice that families have and then determine the effects on districts.

“If you lived in Connecticut, for example, what would happen if everyone in Fairfield County had to go to one school district instead of choosing among a lot of small ones?” she said.

Too Simplistic?

One finding to emerge from her analysis is that a large increase in public school choice--for example, a rise from two to 10 school districts available to the typical family--lowers per-pupil spending by about $400, or 7 percentile points. Some of that change stems from lower teacher salaries and some from higher ratios of students to teachers, according to the report.

But Bruce Fuller, an associate professor of public policy and education at the University of California, Berkeley, said that Ms. Hoxby’s spending analysis may be too simplistic.

“We do know that urban districts tend to spend more money per pupil, but part of that is they have greater student needs,” he said. A lower ratio of students to teachers, for example, might be explained by higher numbers of English-language and special education teachers in those districts.

In looking at student achievement, Ms. Hoxby used eight different measures, ranging from standardized-test scores to figures on student enrollment in two- and four-year colleges after high school. She found that a large increase in choice leads to an improvement of 7.5 percentile points in a student’s 8th grade math scores, a 4 percent increase in the probability of a student’s graduating from a four-year college, and a $903 increase in annual income at around age 32.

Where there is more public school choice, Ms. Hoxby also found, fewer parents choose private schools for their children.

All of the effects the study found were smaller in states where the state, rather than local property taxes, pays the greater share of local school costs.

Sorting Not Increased

The report also suggests that this type of natural choice among districts does not lead to more “sorting” among students--segregation by income or race. Critics of school choice proposals often contend that such policies will increase social stratification.

“This appears to be because racial and income segregation occur just through having more schools, not more districts,” Ms. Hoxby writes.

“It doesn’t make a difference whether you have one district or 100 districts, people will still sort themselves out,” Ms. Hoxby added in an interview.

Ms. Hoxby published a controversial study late last year suggesting that teacher unionization leads to overall increases in student dropout rates. (“Education’s ‘Dark Continent,’” Dec. 6, 1996.)

Her new study may generate as much debate.

Mr. Fuller, who co-edited a collection of school choice studies that was published last year, said Ms. Hoxby’s study supports other research suggesting that parents in smaller suburban districts tend to resist school choice plans, presumably because they are happy with their schools.

“Size probably matters, and smaller is probably better,” he said.

But he said Ms. Hoxby also appeared to ignore other factors that might explain differences in student achievement.

“I think it sort of adds fuel to the argument that we should break up big urban districts,” he added. “But it ignores the equity issue.” Many large districts were formed in the first place, he noted, so that schools in poorer neighborhoods would be funded at the same level as those in wealthier communities.

Related Tags:

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
McKinney-Vento Transportation Strategies: Managing Cost & Protecting Access
Explore McKinney-Vento transportation strategies to manage costs, respond quickly to changing needs, and protect student access.
Content provided by HopSkipDrive
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Families & the Community Webinar
Celebrate Family Engagement Day With Strategies That Work
Join National PTA and AASA to explore practical systems-wide family engagement strategies in celebration of National Family Engagement Day.
College & Workforce Readiness Webinar What Are the Fastest-Growing Career- and Work-Based Education Programs?
Join us to explore EdWeek Research Center survey data on which areas of CTE are expected to grow the fastest over the next 5 years.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management Principals Wake Up 15 Times a Night. 5 Ways to Reclaim Your Health
School leaders are at risk for burnout and health challenges. These strategies can help.
3 min read
Alarm clock after midnight with person sleeping in the background
Vanessa Solis/Education Week + Getty
School & District Management No Education Background? Some Say That Helps School Boards
People of all professional backgrounds can add value to school boards.
1 min read
Image of a venn diagram that shows a school board must have members that can study education interests but must also be award of wider community interests as well.
Laura Baker/Education Week
School & District Management Opinion Why I Challenged 60 Ed. Leaders to Endure a Student’s Fragmented School Day
One question changed how I think about my school’s master schedule.
Eric R. Mace
•
5 min read
A student figure meanders around a fragmented school day.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week + Getty
School & District Management Spotlight Planning Smarter School Environments: From Budgets and Accessibility to Technology and Design
See how schools are connecting physical spaces, digital tools, accessibility, and smarter planning to shape learning environments.