Opinion
School Climate & Safety Commentary

The Harsh Discipline of No-Excuses Charter Schools: Is It Worth the Promise?

By Joanne Golann & Mira Debs — June 09, 2019 5 min read
BRIC ARCHIVE

The school was calling again. This time, it was for humming. Esmeralda, a middle-class Latina mother whose daughter attended a high-performing charter school in a northeastern city, was incredulous as she recounted the conversation. (As education researchers, we use pseudonyms to preserve anonymity).

“I said, ‘Did she curse?’ ‘No.’ I said, ‘Did she disrespect another student?’ ‘No.’ I said, ‘Did she disrespect you?’ ‘No. She was humming.’”

Another time, the school called when her daughter laughed during a fire drill. The punishment was a day spent wearing a yellow shirt and no talking with her peers. These frequent phone calls made Esmeralda feel disciplined, too.

It would be one thing if a no-excuses environment were the only way for urban schools to ensure order and achievement."

“I’ll swallow my pride,” she told us, balancing her discomfort with her daughter’s impressive reading gains.

In our recent study with co-author Anna Weiss, “‘To Be Strict on Your Own': Black and Latinx Parents Evaluate Discipline in Urban Choice Schools,” we interviewed many parents who echoed Esmeralda’s experience, questioning whether a system of harsh discipline was worth the promise of academic achievement.

In the past decade, the no-excuses charter model has proliferated around the country through prominent charter networks, including KIPP, Uncommon Schools, Success Academy, YES Prep, and Achievement First, all of which combine a college-prep curriculum with strict discipline and a longer school day.

These schools have been celebrated for Black and Latino students’ high-test scores and now form the most prevalent charter option in a number of American cities.

No-excuses students are typically required to wear uniforms, sit straight, with their hands folded on the table, and their eyes continuously on the teacher. At breaks, they walk silently through the halls in single-file lines. Students who follow these stringent expectations are rewarded with privileges, while violators are punished with demerits, detentions, and suspensions.

When some have challenged this model as unethical and racist, supporters point to parent demand. Eva Moskowitz, the CEO of Success Academy, which now runs 47 no-excuses charter schools with long waiting lists in New York City, has argued that parents who “believe in stricter discipline” are “voting with their feet” by enrolling their children in these schools. (Incidentally, Success Academy was recently found to have violated FERPA privacy laws in revealing identifying details about a child in response to the child’s parent complaining about the school’s disciplinary practices on “PBS News Hour.”)

As researchers who have taught in and studied these schools, we found that parents’ attitudes were not that simple. The Black and Latino parents we interviewed in a no-excuses middle school valued discipline, but viewed it as more than rule following. They wanted demanding academic expectations alongside a caring and structured environment that would help their children develop the self-discipline to make good choices.

Recognizing the peer pressures their children faced, these parents told us that they did not want their children to become “robots” or “little mindless minion[s], just going by what somebody says.” Their concerns echo an earlier study that one of us (Joanne Golann) published in 2015, questioning whether the no-excuses model’s emphasis on obedience adequately prepares students for the self-directed learning skills they need to be successful in college.

There are, however, other school models that offer parents a better balance of academics and a nurturing school environment. In our study, we also interviewed Black and Latino parents whose children were enrolled at two public Montessori magnet schools. These parents, we found, also valued structure and high academic expectations. But they liked that their children were not being punished and had the freedom to choose their work and collaborate with peers on projects.

The parents who spoke with us questioned the assumption that different families need or even want stricter kinds of schools. One Black middle-class mother whose daughter attended a Montessori school was frustrated that her experience was the exception for Black children rather than the norm: “Why is it that a certain population has to have so much structure in order to be successful compared to another population?”

It would be one thing if a no-excuses environment was the only way for urban schools to ensure order and achievement. But while many Montessori schools are private, there are more than 500 whole- or partial-school public Montessoris around the country, roughly half of which are located in cities. These schools, which can include district-run, magnet, and charter schools, are racially diverse: Students of color constitute a majority of total enrollment in the whole-school public Montessoris. Public Montessori schools are also rapidly expanding, having roughly doubled in size since 2000.

Montessori schools aren’t perfect: A 2015 study showed Black students in a public Montessori school were still disciplined at higher rates than their White peers, even though overall discipline rates were lower than other area public schools. Researchers and practitioners have called for more Montessori teachers of color and training in culturally responsive practices to support the diverse population of students. But public Montessori schools have demonstrated academic benefits for Black and low-income students without having to constantly monitor student behavior.

Charter schools were originally designed to respond to the needs and desires of families and local communities. To give parents the choices they want and deserve, school districts and charter authorizers should encourage a diversity of school choices—including those that foreground student independence and downplay punishment. They also need to hold charter schools accountable at the approval and renewal stage by measuring school culture, including student satisfaction, teacher turnover, and school suspension rates, and by closely examining the nature of school disciplinary practices.

It’s encouraging that a number of no-excuses schools are responding to criticisms by incorporating social-emotional learning, making schools trauma informed, and using restorative justice circles to reduce suspensions. But this culture change is not easy, and the model is not changing fast enough. Recently, students have protested the disciplinary system at Success Academy’s high school in New York City. A disciplinary scandal at one Achievement First high school in New Haven, Conn., led to leadership change and a commitment by the network to improve school culture for students.

Parents from all backgrounds want strong academics and respect for their children, where no one has to swallow their pride. Why can’t their children have it?

Follow the Education Week Commentary section on Twitter.

Sign up to get the latest Education Week Commentaries in your email inbox.
A version of this article appeared in the June 19, 2019 edition of Education Week as Is Strict Discipline What Charter School Parents Want?

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Classroom Technology Webinar
Educator-Driven EdTech Design: Help Shape the Future of Classroom Technology
Join us for a collaborative workshop where you will get a live demo of GoGuardian Teacher, including seamless new integrations with Google Classroom, and participate in an interactive design exercise building a feature based on
Content provided by GoGuardian
School & District Management Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table With Education Week: What Did We Learn About Schooling Models This Year?
After a year of living with the pandemic, what schooling models might we turn to as we look ahead to improve the student learning experience? Could year-round schooling be one of them? What about online
School & District Management Webinar What's Ahead for Hybrid Learning: Putting Best Practices in Motion
It’s safe to say hybrid learning—a mix of in-person and remote instruction that evolved quickly during the pandemic—is probably here to stay in K-12 education to some extent. That is the case even though increasing

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School Climate & Safety Sponsor
Putting safety first: COVID-19 testing in schools
Are schools ready to offer a post-pandemic place to learn?
Content provided by BD
School Climate & Safety How Biden's New Actions on Guns Could Affect Students and Schools
President Joe Biden announced steps to prevent gun violence through executive action and a push for state and federal legislation.
5 min read
High school students rally at the Capitol in Washington on Feb. 21 in support of those affected at the Parkland High School shooting in Florida.
High school students rally at the U.S. Capitol in February 2018, three days after a former student shot and killed 17 people at a high school in Parkland, Fla.<br/>
J. Scott Applewhite/AP
School Climate & Safety What the Research Says Teens Are Driving COVID-19 Surges. Can Schools Counteract That?
Teenagers and young adults are now driving COVID-19 cases in some states, and experts say schools may be critical in preventing outbreaks.
4 min read
BRIC ARCHIVE
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
School Climate & Safety Opinion Empowering Teachers and Parents to Speak Up on School Safety
Rick Hess shares practical suggestions from Max Eden on how to ensure school discipline reforms are indeed keeping students and staff safe.
3 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty