Student Well-Being

High Court Hears Case On Tobacco-Ad Ban Near Schools

By Mark Walsh — May 02, 2001 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The tobacco industry last week urged the U.S. Supreme Court to strike down Massachusetts regulations designed to limit children’s exposure to cigarette advertising near schools and parks.

The state’s set of rules, which in practical terms mostly affects tobacco advertising at retail stores, is pre-empted by a federal cigarette-advertising law and also violates the tobacco companies’ First Amendment rights, said Jeffrey S. Sutton, the lawyer for four major cigarette manufacturers

“It abridges free speech,” Mr. Sutton said. “It does suppress a substantial amount of speech directed at adults about a lawful product.”

But lawyers for the state and the U.S. Department of Justice told the justices on April 25 that the regulations were legal and justified by the dangers of youth tobacco use.

“The state’s interest in preventing school-age children from smoking is truly compelling,” said Barbara D. Underwood, the acting U.S. solicitor general.

William W. Porter, a Massachusetts assistant attorney general, said that if the court accepted the tobacco industry’s arguments, then no state could ban cigarette ads “from Little League fields or ... near schools.”

The showdown in Lorillard Tobacco Co. v. Reilly (Case No. 00-596) is the tobacco industry’s second visit to the high court in as many years. Last year, it won a major victory when the court ruled 5-4 that the Food and Drug Administration lacked authority from Congress to begin regulating nicotine as a drug. That ruling brought a swift end to the agency’s proposal for broad rules aimed at reducing youth smoking, which included a ban on outdoor tobacco advertising within 1,000 feet of a school or playground.

Rules on Hold

Massachusetts adopted its own tobacco regulations in early 1999, just a few months after the nation’s five largest tobacco companies reached a “master settlement agreement” with 46 states in their liability litigation over tobacco-related health costs. The agreement, which Massachusetts officials signed, called for the cigarette companies to pay more than $200 billion over 25 years to the states. The companies also voluntarily accepted restrictions on outdoor advertising, including a ban on billboards and a ban on any outdoor advertising at retail stores larger than 14 square feet.

The Massachusetts rules, which are on hold pending the outcome of the case, prohibit outdoor tobacco advertising at stores within 1,000 feet of a school or park and would ban interior tobacco displays below five feet from the floor in those stores. They were upheld last year by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit, in Boston.

The state argued in court papers that, despite the settlement’s ban on outdoor cigarette advertising, its regulations would advance the battle against youth smoking because tobacco companies were shifting more of their advertising dollars to store ads and point-of-sale promotions.

Joining the state’s side were the National School Boards Association and its state affiliate, the Massachusetts Association of School Committees, which said in a friend-of-the-court brief that children merit “special solitude” in balancing their protection against the First Amendment rights of the tobacco companies.

‘Highly Addictive’

During a lively oral-argument session, the justices weighed whether the state’s restrictions were pre-empted by the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act. The 1969 statute says that “no requirement or prohibition based on smoking and health shall be imposed under state law with respect to advertising or promotion of any cigarettes” whose packages carry federally mandated warning labels.

Some justices did not appear convinced that the law was meant to preclude state regulation of outdoor tobacco advertising.

“When you read the federal statute, it does seem to be directed at what was on cigarette labels,” Justice Sandra Day O’Connor told Mr. Sutton.

“We’re dealing with a commodity like no other,” said Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. “This is highly addictive and especially dangerous to children, who can get hooked at age 13 and not get off it for the rest of their lives.”

But Justice Antonin Scalia said the 1969 statute seems to be “a fairly broad ban against state regulation” of tobacco advertising.

On the First Amendment issue, Justice Scalia made a comparison to regulation of pornography.

“We’ve been very insistent that you can’t keep it away from adults,” he said.

Mr. Porter replied that while parents can take steps to keep pornography from their children, “here parents have no opportunity to block tobacco advertising children see as they walk to school each day.”

Justice Clarence Thomas, who rarely speaks during arguments, asked Ms. Underwood whether a state could prohibit “fast food joints,” such as McDonald’s, from advertising to children if the state believed its food was unhealthy.

In response, Ms. Underwood drew a distinction between cigarettes and fast food. The addictive nature of tobacco and the belief that many children pick up the smoking habit between the ages of 14 and 18, she said, were important justifications for the advertising restrictions.

The justices are expected to rule in the case by the end of the court’s term in early summer.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the May 02, 2001 edition of Education Week as High Court Hears Case On Tobacco-Ad Ban Near Schools

Events

Student Well-Being K-12 Essentials Forum Boosting Student and Staff Mental Health: What Schools Can Do
Join this free virtual event based on recent reporting on student and staff mental health challenges and how schools have responded.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Curriculum Webinar
Practical Methods for Integrating Computer Science into Core Curriculum
Dive into insights on integrating computer science into core curricula with expert tips and practical strategies to empower students at every grade level.
Content provided by Learning.com
Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Student Well-Being Teen Girls Are Being Victimized by AI-Generated Nude Images
AI-generated deepfake nude images of teens were circulated at a schools in New Jersey and Washington.
5 min read
Dorota Mani sits for an interview in her office in Jersey City, N.J., on Nov. 8, 2023. Mani is the parent of a 14-year-old New Jersey student victimized by an AI-generated deepfake image.
Dorota Mani sits for an interview in her office in Jersey City, N.J., on Nov. 8, 2023. Mani is the parent of a 14-year-old New Jersey student victimized by an AI-generated deepfake image.
Peter K. Afriyie/AP
Student Well-Being How Districts Can Keep After-School and Summer Learning Alive After ESSER Dries Up
Roughly 8 in 10 school districts spent some of their federal COVID relief funds on after-school or summer learning.
4 min read
Multi-ethnic preschool boys playing with blocks.
E+ / Getty
Student Well-Being Kids Are Getting Priced Out of Youth Sports. How Schools Can Help
The rising costs of participating in organized youth sports is making these activities unaffordable for many families.
3 min read
Graham Bacigalupi, of Team Louisiana, watches from the dugout during the DYB, formerly Dixie Youth Baseball, Little League tournament in Ruston, La., on Aug. 8, 2023.
Graham Bacigalupi, of Team Louisiana, watches from the dugout during a Little League tournament in Ruston, La., on Aug. 8, 2023.
Gerald Herbert/AP
Student Well-Being All Public Schools Can Now Get Free COVID-19 Tests. Here's How
The Education Department is encouraging schools to share the COVID-19 tests with staff, families, and the broader community.
2 min read
COVID-19 antigen home tests indicating a positive result are photographed in New York on April 5, 2023.
COVID-19 antigen home tests indicating a positive result are photographed in New York on April 5, 2023.
Patrick Sison/AP