School Climate & Safety

High Court Declines Kentucky Case Blaming School Violence on Media

By Mark Walsh — January 29, 2003 2 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The U.S. Supreme Court declined last week to hear an appeal from parents who had sought to hold media companies partly responsible for the 1997 school shooting spree in West Paducah, Ky., that killed three students.

It was the end of the line for a novel attempt to hold the producers of violent movies, video games, and Internet sites liable for school violence.

The families of victims Jessica James, Kayce Steger, and Nicole M. Hadley had sued 21 media companies, alleging that the violent content of their entertainment had motivated Michael Carneal, then a 14-year-old student at Heath High School, to go on the rampage that left the three girls dead and five other students wounded. Mr. Carneal pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for 25 years.

In the lawsuit, the parents contended that Mr. Carneal had been desensitized to violence by his frequent exposure to video games such as “Doom,” “Quake,” and “Redneck Rampage,” as well as by a violent sequence in the movie “The Basketball Diaries.” The defendants included AOL Time Warner Inc., Nintendo of America Inc., and Sega of America Inc.

Too Great a Leap

The parents lost in both federal district court in Paducah, Ky., and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit, in Cincinnati. Last August, a three-judge panel of the appeals court ruled unanimously that it would have been impossible for the media defendants to predict that their violent games, movie, and Internet sites would incite a particular young person to violence.

“We find that it is simply too far a leap from shooting characters on a video screen (an activity undertaken by millions) to shooting people in a classroom (an activity undertaken by a handful, at most) for Carneal’s actions to have been reasonably foreseeable to the manufacturers of the media,” the appellate court said in upholding that dismissal of the lawsuit.

The Supreme Court declined without comment on Jan. 21 to hear the parents’ appeal in James v. Meow Media Inc. (Case No. 02-740).

The Kentucky shootings presaged the more extensive 1999 violence at Columbine High School in Jefferson County, Colo., in which two student gunmen killed 12 students and one teacher before killing themselves. Among the tangle of mostly unsuccessful lawsuits against school employees, local police, gun manufacturers, and others in the Columbine case was a suit against the producers of violent video games and “The Basketball Diaries” movie. A federal district judge in Denver dismissed the media suit last March.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Families & the Community Webinar
Celebrate Family Engagement Day With Strategies That Work
Join National PTA and AASA to explore practical systems-wide family engagement strategies in celebration of National Family Engagement Day.
College & Workforce Readiness Webinar What Are the Fastest-Growing Career- and Work-Based Education Programs?
Join us to explore EdWeek Research Center survey data on which areas of CTE are expected to grow the fastest over the next 5 years.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Prove What Works: How to Know Which Literacy Evidence to Trust
Learn how to evaluate literacy research, question claims, understand outcomes, and make more confident, evidence-based decisions.
Content provided by Lexia Learning

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School Climate & Safety From Our Research Center Fake AI Images Are Targeting Students and Teachers. Schools Aren't Prepared
New data show that many educators aren't well-versed on the risk of deepfakes.
5 min read
In this photo illustration, a teenager uses her mobile phone to access social media on January 31, 2024 in New York City. Technology executives appeared at a Senate hearing to address accusations that their companies are endangering children's lives by not adequately policing predators and others who seek to harm and exploit young social media users.
In this photo illustration, a teenager uses her mobile phone to access social media on Jan. 31, 2024 in New York City. Experts say schools need specific policies for AI-generated "deepfakes."
Spencer Platt/Getty Images
School Climate & Safety School Lockdowns Are Common, But in Some Kinds of Schools More Than Others
A new study tries to quantify how frequent school lockdowns are, and where they happen most.
4 min read
Law enforcement blocks the entrance to Lexington High School in Lexington, South Carolina on September 17, 2026, during a lockdown as parents and families gathered across the street in the Lowes Foods gas station parking lot.
Law enforcement blocks the entrance to Lexington High School in Lexington, S.C. on Sept. 17, 2026, during a lockdown as parents and families gathered across the street. A new study finds 1 in 5 students have experienced a school lockdown by middle school.
Dwayne McLemore/The State via TNS
School Climate & Safety Opinion Am I Brave Enough to Die for My Students?
An unspoken fear haunts educators in the era of school shootings. It’s time we talk about it.
Bridget Farr
•
4 min read
Illustration of a large silhouette of a teacher and a group of children on the right. A door with a shadowed figure peering through the window is in the left of the frame.
Illustration by Vanessa Solis/Education Week + Canva
School Climate & Safety A Shooting Strikes an Elementary School. Some Doubt Policy Change Will Follow
Tragedies like the one in Bend, Ore., draw public outcry, but typically not swift change on school safety.
5 min read
Children place flowers at a makeshift memorial outside Silver Rail Elementary in Bend, Ore., Friday, Oct. 16, 2026, a day after a deadly shooting.
Children place flowers at a makeshift memorial outside Silver Rail Elementary in Bend, Ore., Friday, Oct. 16, 2026, a day after a deadly shooting. The child victims, ages 5, 8, and 11, include the youngest person killed in a school shooting since Education Week began<a href="https://www.edweek.org/leadership/school-shootings-this-year-how-many-and-where/2026/01" target="_blank" link-data="{&quot;cms.site.owner&quot;:{&quot;_ref&quot;:&quot;00000173-0561-d1f0-a17f-adef4bee0000&quot;,&quot;_type&quot;:&quot;ae3387cc-b875-31b7-b82d-63fd8d758c20&quot;},&quot;cms.content.publishDate&quot;:1792177418426,&quot;cms.content.publishUser&quot;:{&quot;_ref&quot;:&quot;00000180-d7b2-d193-a1b2-dfbba3aa0001&quot;,&quot;_type&quot;:&quot;6aa69ae1-35be-30dc-87e9-410da9e1cdcc&quot;},&quot;cms.content.updateDate&quot;:1792177418426,&quot;cms.content.updateUser&quot;:{&quot;_ref&quot;:&quot;00000180-d7b2-d193-a1b2-dfbba3aa0001&quot;,&quot;_type&quot;:&quot;6aa69ae1-35be-30dc-87e9-410da9e1cdcc&quot;},&quot;link&quot;:{&quot;disableUtmTracking&quot;:false,&quot;target&quot;:&quot;NEW&quot;,&quot;attributes&quot;:[],&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.edweek.org/leadership/school-shootings-this-year-how-many-and-where/2026/01&quot;,&quot;_id&quot;:&quot;000001a1-4619-d1d1-a3f3-f77b151b0000&quot;,&quot;_type&quot;:&quot;ff658216-e70f-39d0-b660-bdfe57a5599a&quot;},&quot;linkText&quot;:&quot; tracking these incidents&quot;,&quot;theme.brightspot-theme-default.:core:enhancement:Enhancement.hbs.enhancementAlignment&quot;:null,&quot;theme.brightspot-theme-default.:core:link:Link.hbs._template&quot;:null,&quot;theme.brightspot-theme-default.:core:link:Link.hbs.type&quot;:null,&quot;theme.brightspot-theme-default.:core:link:Link.hbs._preset&quot;:null,&quot;theme.brightspot-theme-default.:core:enhancement:Enhancement.hbs._preset&quot;:null,&quot;_id&quot;:&quot;000001a1-4619-d1d1-a3f3-f77b14b10001&quot;,&quot;_type&quot;:&quot;809caec9-30e2-3666-8b71-b32ddbffc288&quot;}"> </a>tracking those incidents eight years ago.
Joe Kline/AP