South Korea's 'Top Performance' Numbers Should Not Be Applauded
To the Editor:
As a student from South Korea who is now studying in the United States, I find it surprising that many people here applaud the South Korean education system. The Center on International Education Benchmarking lists South Korea as a "top performer," and even Arne Duncan, the former U.S. secretary of education, has asked why the United States can't be more like South Korea. As a recent Commentary argued, the United States should not blindly applaud and emulate countries that perform well on international assessments.
I want to share what South Korea's high performance on these assessments is not telling you.
First, beyond South Korea's impressive scores on international exams, there are unhappy, sleep-deprived, and suicidal South Korean students. South Korean students report levels of happiness that are among the lowest for youths in developed nations. High school students report sleeping an average of 5.5 hours per day in order to study. Alarmingly, slightly more than half of South Korean teenagers reported having suicidal thoughts in response to a 2014 poll conducted by the country’s Korea Health Promotion Foundation; over 40 percent of the respondents listed academic pressure and uncertainty over their futures as their greatest concern.
Second, South Korea's high scores are a reflection of private tutoring rather than the public education system itself. About 77 percent of South Korean students participate in an average of 10 hours of private tutoring a week. This percentage is more than double the average rate of private tutoring in countries tracked by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. In 2013, South Korean parents paid the equivalent of $18 billion for private tutoring in order to give their children a competitive advantage.
Moreover, in the education system where high performance is all that matters, struggling students as well as students with disabilities are often neglected and left behind.
Thus, no matter how high the country ranks on international tests, our seemingly impressive test scores come at too high a price.
As a South Korean, I call on the world to see what is beyond my country's high scores on international assessments. Until South Korea addresses its pressing educational issues, such as student well-being, reliance on private tutoring, and support for students with disabilities, the country should not be considered a model system for the United States.
Vol. 35, Issue 24, Page 20
Vol. 35, Issue 24, Page 20
Get more stories and free e-newsletters!
- Learning Disabilities Special Education Teacher
- Stevens Point Area Public School District, WI
- Cristo Rey Fort Worth, Fort Worth, TX
- ECE Lead & Assistant Teachers
- Tutor Time Learning Center, Multiple Locations
- Instructional Coach - Math
- Carondelet Leadership Academy, Saint Louis, MO
- Early Preschool Teacher - Sign on Bonus
- Childtime Learning Center, Multiple Locations