NAEP Shows Promise as 'Preparedness' Yardstick
Research Finds Overlap of 12th Grade Content With That of Other Exams
Initial studies have delivered early but promising indications that it might be possible to use the exam known as “the nation’s report card” for a brand-new purpose: to gauge students’ preparedness for college or work.
At its quarterly meeting here last week, the National Assessment Governing Board, which sets policy for the National Assessment of Educational Progress, released results of studies comparing the content covered in the 12th grade assessment with the content in the SAT and ACT college-entrance exams; in the Accuplacer, a course-placement test used by colleges; and in WorkKeys, a job-skills test used by employers.
The studies found some differences in the tests’ content, but they also found “considerable overlap.” The overlap is enough to make researchers optimistic, NAGB officials said, about proceeding with the rest of the work needed to make a full determination of whether it would be appropriate to say that certain ranges of NAEP scores correlate with preparedness for work or higher education.
They cautioned, however, that the content analyses alone do not provide enough information to enable that. A flock of related studies is under way to help the board determine whether NAEP can be used to make meaningful statements about career or college preparedness, with a decision slated for late 2011.
Among the areas being probed are the statistical relationships between NAEP scores and other exams; the skills measured by NAEP that represent those necessary for entry into certain job-training programs; and how well students at various points on the NAEP scale fare in college and work.
One of the studies contemplated, a comparison of how freshmen at Texas colleges performed on NAEP, will probably be abandoned because too few of those students were willing to sit for the exam in a pilot administration, NAGB officials said. That study could have informed the overall research by, among other things, enabling a comparative look at the scores of students who are placed in credit-bearing courses and those who are placed in remedial courses.
The governing board’s inquiry into the use of NAEP as a college- or work-preparedness indicator grew out of work that began in 2002, when it established a special commission to examine strands of questions about the 12th grade NAEP. As the commission’s work progressed, the question of using the exam as a gauge for endeavors beyond high school took shape. The board approved that program of research in March 2009, right after the 12th grade NAEP on which the research is to be based was administered. ("Plans Advance to Link NAEP to College, Work Readiness", Dec. 3, 2008.)
The “content alignment” studies released Nov. 19 found that the content covered by the 12th grade NAEP is similar to but broader than the content in the SAT, ACT, and Accuplacer exams. Some differences were found in the amount of cognitive rigor the tests demanded of students, the types of reading texts they used, how much each exam used multiple-choice or open-ended questions.
The studies found that “some” of the content of NAEP is similar to that of WorkKeys, but WorkKeys tests some content absent from NAEP. The mathematics and reading skills assessed by WorkKeys, for example, focus on applying skills to workplace settings.
The assessment board’s work flows into an increasingly active dialogue on how to measure college and career readiness. In trying to create its own statements on the issue, the board is taking pains to clarify what its definitions do—and do not—mean.
In a presentation to the board last week, Executive Director Cornelia Orr explained that the term “preparedness” was deliberately chosen to connote the academic skills necessary to qualify for placement into entry-level college courses or job-training programs without remediation. That definition excludes certain skill sets that some others include as part of the “readiness” picture, ranging from work-study habits and teamwork to personal qualities such as persistence.
That approach also differs from some others, in that it focuses on what is necessary to enter college coursework or job-training, not what is necessary to achieve a specific level of success in them. The ACT’s college-readiness benchmarks, for instance, identify threshold scores on the ACT exam that establish the likelihood that students will earn passing grades or better in entry-level, credit-bearing college courses.
Vol. 30, Issue 13, Page 9
Get 10 free stories, e-newsletters, and more!
- Project Manager, First the Seed Foundation Educational Programs
- First the Seed Foundation, VA
- Director of Auxiliary Programming
- Lovett School, Atlanta, GA
- Head of School
- Augusta Preparatory Day School, Martinez, GA
- Director of College Counseling
- Augusta Preparatory Day School, Martinez, GA
- Director of Information Technology
- Charles E. Smith Jewish Day School, Rockville, MD