Opinion
Artificial Intelligence Opinion

‘Just Say No’ Didn’t Keep Teens Off Drugs. It Won’t Work for AI, Either

If we truly care about our students’ critical thinking skills, we must teach them AI literacy
By David Nurenberg — September 03, 2026 5 min read
Collage image of a person holding a magnifying glass, standing on a head with a digital grid representing the brain. Voice/conversational bubbles in the background.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

No one has to convince me of AI’s destructive, demoralizing impact on education; as a teacher, I experience daily the countless ways artificial intelligence erodes the cognitive, creative, and persistive abilities of students. With the most understandable of intentions, we teachers implore students not to surrender their thinking to the bots, preaching ethics and honesty, even as we know that “just say no” failed at deterring youth drug abuse and teen sexual activity.

Then, usually, we go right on teaching as if AI didn’t exist, praying students won’t touch the shiny magic button that promises to solve all their problems.

The majority of students do press that button sometimes, even “good kids” who are seriously dedicated to learning but run short on time or confidence. Policing AI use is impossible. In-class writing assessments privilege quick thinking over deep thinking, and no take-home assignment, however creative or personal, is fully “AI-proof.” We can’t design our way around AI; if we truly care about developing students’ critical thinking skills, we must take the digital bull by the horns and teach them AI literacy.

AI literacy cannot just be siloed in computer science courses. My discipline, English, has been one of the biggest victims of AI’s temptations to cognitively outsource, even as the AI age has made the kind of analytic skills we teach ever more important. Ironically, reversing that trend may require humanities classes to fire up Claude and ChatGPT so we can teach students how to critique them.

To teach AI literacy, I invite my high school English students to examine what large language models have to “say” about the novels we’re reading. The students use those canned analyses as counterexamples to the creative, discursive yet defensible readings they themselves generate. They also form counter-theses to disagree with what an LLM says a novel’s themes are, supported by textual evidence they locate. They scour LLM summaries for omissions and inaccuracies. By examining AI, not as a means of producing a product, but as an additional “text” to critique, students both build their analytic faculties and, hopefully, begin to suspect AI’s “expertise.”

We also compare LLM-generated essays with human-generated ones, teasing out AI’s sophisticated-sounding yet generic prose, identifying “fluff” words that sound fancy but say nothing. Students learn to populate their own analytic writing with “funky” devices like anthimeria, synesthesia, anastrophe, and even occasional colloquialisms. In a world where everyone has access to LLMs, I want my students to discover the value of developing genuine voice to stand out.

Sometimes we “invite” LLMs to join our literary discussions. After an initial thrill, students grow frustrated with AI’s repetition, its inability to understand the essence of many of their questions, and particularly its sycophancy. When students begin groaning and asking to shut Claude up, I suspect they’ve learned something special about human interaction.

My students compare their manual note-taking process to the output of AI note-taking tools, paying attention to what gets included or excluded in summaries, what gets emphasized or downplayed. They identify how phrasing choices (e.g., “protestors” vs. “agitators”) create different meanings. As the bots seek to give us what we want, the students develop a habit of asking, “What am I not seeing?”

When we do research, the students evaluate whether LLM searches accurately report their sources, to what extent AI draws from ideologically extreme sites, and how wording a query (e.g., “is abortion safe” vs. “is abortion murder”) often leads to politically slanted results. Students learn how actual source data often differs wildly from AI’s summaries of it. They see the “oracle” has clay feet.

To better understand AI’s social and cultural context, we study the antidemocratic, anti-humanist politics of AI boosters like CEO Sam Altman, venture capitalist Peter Thiel, and philosopher Curtis Yarvin. We feed chatbots “political” questions to track their biases and censorship strategies. We explore computer scientist Joy Buolamwini’s work on algorithmic bias and test for ourselves how AI image generation requests for, say, “doctor,” return mainly white males. Students seriously rethink their impressions of AI tools as objective or simply utilitarian.

Finally, we study human cognition vs. machine “thinking,” how our brains don’t just rely on pattern recognition but also make intuitive leaps. We use Edward De Bono’s lateral thinking activities to practice the kind of divergent idea generation that LLMs are incapable of.

It may seem counterintuitive that to save students’ independent thinking from AI, we may have to engage them with AI, but if we appreciate that students learn via doing, then we cannot simply lecture them about the advantages of puzzling through challenging cognitive tasks themselves.

I have watched my students steadily lose their awe of AI, as well as their sense of it as a “time-saver,” given all the fact-checking and other auditing its flaws demand. Their experience tracks with multiple studies that demonstrate the value of AI literacy. (In one study, AI literacy, more than actual familiarity with literature, better predicted participants’ ability to detect AI authorship of text).

Research suggests that although Generation Alpha’s defaults to utilizing AI, they simultaneously mistrust it. My challenge has expanded beyond encouraging AI skepticism to helping students avoid general cynicism; a student who believes truth is inaccessible is just as imperiled as an overcredulous one.

The Brookings Institution and the American Psychological Association now call for AI literacy education at all levels of schooling, yet many teachers find any classroom use of AI to be anathema. Teaching AI literacy is not necessarily capitulation to the AI companies’ self-declared inevitability, just as teaching fire safety doesn’t mean you’re pro-arson.

I still protest data center construction, vote for candidates who challenge Big Tech, and publicly name AI’s many economic, ecological, and philosophical harms. But students need more than our moral outrage right now, however justified. They need us to help them analyze and critique the AI-infused world that has been forced upon them. They need teachers to do what we do best and what no bot can truly do: teach.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
McKinney-Vento Transportation Strategies: Managing Cost & Protecting Access
Explore McKinney-Vento transportation strategies to manage costs, respond quickly to changing needs, and protect student access.
Content provided by HopSkipDrive
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Families & the Community Webinar
Celebrate Family Engagement Day With Strategies That Work
Join National PTA and AASA to explore practical systems-wide family engagement strategies in celebration of National Family Engagement Day.
College & Workforce Readiness Webinar What Are the Fastest-Growing Career- and Work-Based Education Programs?
Join us to explore EdWeek Research Center survey data on which areas of CTE are expected to grow the fastest over the next 5 years.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Artificial Intelligence Reports AI and Teacher Preparation: Results of a National Survey
Based on a 2026 survey, this whitepaper highlights the perspectives of teacher educators on preparing current and prospective teachers to use AI in their classrooms.
Artificial Intelligence Why AI Won’t Replace Teacher Judgment: A Professor’s Microwave Lesson
Preparing teachers to use AI means showing them the technology's potential and pitfalls.
10 min read
Fairfax, VA - October 20, 2026: Sophomore, Elaina Fseisi, 21, uses an AI tool to decipher her emotions. George Mason University Students learn about Artificial Intelligence, AI, in the class, Integrating Technology in PreK-6, taught by Dr. Jered Borup, in Fairfax on Tuesday, October 20, 2026. The class Introduces technology as a tool for working with children across a range of contexts, including early childhood and elementary classrooms.
George Mason University sophomore Elaina Fseisi, 21, uses an AI tool to detect her emotions as part of a class about the role of artificial intelligence in education on Oct. 20, 2026, in Fairfax, Va. Students in the class are learning about the benefits and drawbacks of the technology and how to integrate it into instruction when they become teachers.
Sarah Voisin for Education Week
Artificial Intelligence Harvard Taps 5,000 Studies to Show How AI Helps or Hinders Learning
AI’s effects on learning can differ depending on a child's age and what skills they’re developing.
5 min read
An Oregon middle schooler uses a laptop in school. Parents in Portland are seeking ways to cut down on device use during class on Sept. 4, 2026.
Middle school students in Portland, Ore., use laptops for a classroom lesson on Sept. 4, 2026. A new Harvard resource provides recommendations on age-appropriate use of artificial intelligence in education.
Mark Graves/The Oregonian via TNS
Artificial Intelligence Anthropic Agrees to Protections for Teachers Who Use Claude
AI giant will allow districts more contract protections for privacy and safety.
2 min read
Pages from the Anthropic website and the company's logos are displayed on a computer screen in New York on Thursday, Feb. 26, 2026.
The Anthropic website and logos is displayed on a computer screen in New York on Feb. 26, 2026. The company agreed to safeguards on Claude for Teachers demanded by a teachers’ union.
Patrick Sison/AP