February 01, 2003 6 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Redesigning Senior Year
by Nancy Faust Sizer
(Heinemann, 272 pages, $23)

At most high schools, teachers complain about “senioritis” like septuagenarians griping about the aches and pains of age. The syndrome, which manifests itself among seniors as progressive disengagement, is easy to diagnose but almost impossible to cure.

While hardly a new phenomenon, senioritis has become much more acute in recent years, writes veteran high school history teacher Sizer. She’s not the first to make this assertion; indeed, a prominent national commission has been formed to study the problem and propose remedies. But the case Sizer makes for change is particularly noteworthy because she draws both from personal experience—she’s taught in public and private institutions—and from her own research, which includes detailed interviews with some 150seniors from a diverse group of 26 schools across the country.

One after another, these students describe the senior year as “blow-off” time, a kind of extended end- of-adolescence celebration. The reasons Sizer offers for this attitude are varied and somewhat contradictory. On the one hand, the current generation of high schoolers, particularly those from the middle class, have been given just about everything they want by their baby boomer parents—extravagant birthday parties, diverse entertainment, and self-esteem-boosting pats on the back. As Sizer astutely notes, they have been raised in an “atmosphere of welcome and admiration.” It’s no wonder so many feel a sense of entitlement.

Yet these kids who’ve been indulged in so many ways also have had to compete more vigorously than ever before to get accepted to the colleges of their choice. This means they’ve had to take and do well in a number of specific courses as well as score high on the SAT. They’ve also had to pad their high school records with all sorts of impressive nonacademic experiences. “I need extracurricular activities to dress up my college applications,” one senior acknowledges. “One way or another, I have to pump up the stats.” By senior year, many are burned out.

For all practical purposes, seniors consider themselves finished with high school once they’ve submitted their college applications. Knowing that the remaining courses and grades count for little, many relax and refuse to work, and they expect their teachers to ease up, too. Those teachers who don’t, Sizer writes, risk “more than disengagement; they may face punishment.”

So what should high schools do? The author, who is married to well-known progressive educator Theodore Sizer, proposes that the senior year become a time for students to examine issues pertinent to this transitional period of their lives. Much of this would be done, Sizer writes, in the “senior seminar,” during which students would read and discuss literature “about leaving home, about formative experiences, about autonomy and community.” In a more practical vein, they might also undertake a comparative study of college curricula or costs.

Sizer also wants seniors to immerse themselves in long-term projects on topics that engage them emotionally and intellectually. Students interested in theater might write and produce plays. A promising young scientist might study the causes of pollution in a local lake or stream. At the end of the year, they would present their projects to members of the school community.

Unfortunately, most of these ideas will not be easy to implement at typical high schools. Thanks in part to college and university admission requirements, most secondary school academic programs are inflexible, obliging students to continue amassing traditional credits right up to graduation. Still, reworking the senior year along the lines Sizer suggests is certainly a worthwhile goal if we want graduates to leave high school with a genuine sense of accomplishment. Too many now leave feeling disappointed with themselves for their dismal senior-year performances.

Besieged Schools, Bewildered Parents, Betrayed Kids and the Attack on Excellence

by J. Martin Rochester
(Encounter Books, 316 pages, $26.95)

In what is essentially a back-to-basics tract, Rochester, a professor of political science at the University of Missouri at St. Louis, denounces a wide rangeof popular classroomapproaches—cooperative learning, whole language, fuzzy math, and others—as examples of the progressivism that is ruining public education. He tersely dismisses progressivism as “absolute nonsense” and “an utter failure” and claims it’s the reason our kids can no longer read and write and why they need intensive remediation when they enter college.

This book is typical of the anti-public school genre, relying heavily on personal experience—Rochester’s children attended public schools in the 1980s—and collected anecdotes, most of them examples of teacher stupidity. He then juxtaposes these highly subjective impressions with hand-picked test-score data and the like to give his argument an objective air.

Amazingly, while attacking the laxity and trendiness of public education, he virtually ignores the imposing impact in recent years of the standards and accountability movement. And in one spot, he decries a perceived drift toward less and less homework, when, in fact, the current trend is exactly the opposite. If Rochester’s book, to borrow his own words, isn’t absolute nonsense, it’s certainly an utter failure.

How Ideology Trumped Evidence
edited by Richard L. Allington (Heinemann, 288 pages, $23.50)

A professor of education at the University of Florida and a highly regarded reading expert, Allington writes that he was preparing “to slide into retirement” until a disturbing development caught his attention. Policymakers at the federal and state levels, he noticed, were using dubious “findings” from the 2000 National Reading Panel Report to write legislation requiring rigid phonics instruction in public schools.

Although hardly an apologist for whole language (he has criticized its excesses), Allington decided to stay and fight what he and the other reading specialists who contributed to this volume see as wayward ideology masquerading as scientific research. The result is a compelling book that calls into question the ascension of phonics instruction to the exclusion of almost everything else.

The authors amass substantial evidence to show that they are not exaggerating when they warn thata “nothing but phonics” trend is sweeping the country. At least 26 states have passed “phonics bills,” many with specific language about the “appropriate” way to teach reading. Pennsylvania, for one, stipulates that schools should offer “an exact, concentrated, thorough, sequential presentation of phonetic knowledge through techniques and practices which are introduced incrementally, logically, and systematically.”

What the authors find particularly galling is that lawmakers and education bureaucrats rarely mention children reading and discussing rich literature. The emphasis, it seems, is on what one contributor describes as “decodable texts.” Allington himself writes that the current state and national frameworks for teaching reading emphasize “the lowest-level proficiencies—the ones that are easiest to accomplish and measure.”

Ironically, U.S. 4th graders finished second in recent international comparisons of reading achievement, ahead of such high- literacy countries as Sweden and France. Maybe, one wonders after finishing this persuasive volume, politically motivated policymakers are trying to “fix” something that isn’t broken at all.

—David Ruenzel

Related Tags:


Budget & Finance Webinar Leverage New Funding Sources with Data-Informed Practices
Address the whole child using data-informed practices, gain valuable insights, and learn strategies that can benefit your district.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Classroom Technology Webinar
ChatGPT & Education: 8 Ways AI Improves Student Outcomes
Revolutionize student success! Don't miss our expert-led webinar demonstrating practical ways AI tools will elevate learning experiences.
Content provided by Inzata
Classroom Technology K-12 Essentials Forum Tech Is Everywhere. But Is It Making Schools Better?
Join us for a lively discussion about the ways that technology is being used to improve schools and how it is falling short.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Curriculum Letter to the Editor Curriculum Is More Than Academic Requirements
"The reality our children face requires of them a lot more than a mastery of academics," says this letter writer.
1 min read
Education Week opinion letters submissions
Gwen Keraval for Education Week
Curriculum Roblox Makes Its Move Into STEM Education. What Are the Risks for Schools?
Roblox counts 60 million daily users. Now it's pushing into K-12 schools—with the help of influential nonprofit partners.
3 min read
Pathogen Patrol is PLTW's first learning experience on Roblox, providing educators with innovative tools to help students enhance their critical thinking abilities, learn in unique ways, and work together in teams.
Pathogen Patrol is Project Lead the Way's first K-12 learning experience on Roblox, a virtual environment that is increasingly popular with kids. Nonprofit PLTW integrated it into its K-12 curricula to help students learn how the human body fights off infections.
Business Wire via AP
Curriculum Opinion Making the Case for Restoring Wisdom to America’s Schools
A Johns Hopkins professor discusses how to improve what he sees as a siloed, incoherent education system to best serve students.
7 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
Curriculum Swim Lessons Save Lives. Should Schools Provide Them?
A push is on in some states to make swim lessons part of the school curriculum.
5 min read
Close up of African American person's legs in the pool.