Education Funding

Rochester Students File Class Action Against New York

By Mary Ann Zehr — October 14, 1998 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Poor children in Rochester, N.Y., are suing the state, claiming that its laws are keeping youngsters like them in an urban district without the resources to serve them properly.

Specifically, the class action filed late last month contends that New York’s laws inhibit the 37,200-student Rochester school district’s ability to overcome a concentration of student poverty.

“The request is that the state commissioner be required to develop a plan to ameliorate the effects of the concentration of poverty,” said Bryan Hetherington, the chief counsel for the nonprofit Public Interest Law Office of Rochester and one of the lawyers representing the plaintiffs.

Rochester resident Tamara N. Shields said her daughter, Desirae Morris, is named among the plaintiffs because she is not receiving a good education in the city’s schools.

Ms. Shields, a community college student who earns less than $20,000 a year and lives in her uncle’s apartment with her daughter, said she can’t afford to send Desirae, who is repeating the 2nd grade this year, to a private school or a public school in another district.

“This lawsuit is all about the kids not getting the attention [they need] in the school system--due to money,” Ms. Shields said.

Bill Hirschen, a spokesman for state Commissioner of Education Richard P. Mills and the state department of education, declined to comment on the issues in the case. “We don’t comment on cases that are being investigated,” he said.

The lawsuit, Paynter v. New York, was filed Sept. 29 in a trial court in Monroe County. The plaintiffs--all poor minority children--are pitted against the state, the state board of regents, the regents’ chancellor, the education commissioner, and the education department.

Poverty and Learning

The lawsuit cites studies showing how high concentrations of poverty in districts almost inevitably lead to poor student performance. It points out that 90 percent of students in the Rochester district qualify for federal free or reduced-price lunches, which is the highest percentage among New York’s five largest urban districts.

It also includes statistics comparing the achievement of Rochester students with that of their counterparts in the suburbs. In the 1996-97 school year, for example, fewer than one in five Rochester students passed the state regents’ English and language arts exam, while nearly four out of five students in the suburbs did so. Only 27 percent of freshmen entering the city’s schools in 1993 graduated in 1997; in contrast, 84 percent of the freshmen in neighboring suburban schools graduated.

“The parents who have started this lawsuit are bringing to light an issue that this community has been too slow to acknowledge,” Clifford B. Janey, the superintendent of the Rochester district, said in a statement issued the day the case was filed.

“When the vast majority of children in any school district live in poverty, the sheer number of students who need special attention and support can make it very challenging for the district as a whole to achieve educational success,” Mr. Janey said.

The Rochester lawsuit is modeled after a Connecticut case that argued racial isolation in the Hartford schools violated tenets of the state constitution. In 1996, Connecticut’s highest court agreed.

Three kinds of state laws have kept low-income Rochester children from receiving the “sound basic education” that the New York Constitution guarantees, Mr. Hetherington said.

The state laws that create school district boundaries make it difficult for the Rochester system to merge with any suburban districts or groups of suburban districts to change the mix of low-income families and high-earning families in the system.

A law that requires children to attend school in the district where they reside, unless their parents are able to pay the tuition and transportation costs to send them to another public district, also contributes to an urban concentration of poverty, the lawsuit claims. Finally, the plaintiffs contend that the state housing agency’s reluctance to override zoning restrictions against the construction of low-income housing in the suburbs has contributed to keeping poor people in the city only.

While the plaintiffs assert that state laws contribute to high concentrations of poverty in other large urban districts, their suit does not seek statewide remedies.

“If in fact a local Rochester solution was worked out, we’d be thrilled,” said Mr. Hetherington. “If it worked out to better education statewide, we’d be even more thrilled.”

The state had 30 days to respond to the suit and could ask that the deadline be extended.

Related Tags:

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Well-Being Webinar
Attend to the Whole Child: Non-Academic Factors within MTSS
Learn strategies for proactively identifying and addressing non-academic barriers to student success within an MTSS framework.
Content provided by Renaissance
Classroom Technology K-12 Essentials Forum How to Teach Digital & Media Literacy in the Age of AI
Join this free event to dig into crucial questions about how to help students build a foundation of digital literacy.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Education Funding Inside a Summer Learning Camp With an Uncertain Future After ESSER
A high-poverty district offers an enriching, free summer learning program. But the end of ESSER means tough choices.
5 min read
Alaysia Kimble, 9, laughs with fellow students while trying on a firefighter’s hat and jacket at Estabrook Elementary during the Grizzle Learning Camp on June, 26, 2024 in Ypsilanti, Mich.
Alaysia Kimble, 9, laughs with fellow students while trying on a firefighter’s hat and jacket at Estabrook Elementary during the Grizzly Learning Camp on June, 26, 2024 in Ypsilanti, Mich. The district, with 70 percent of its students coming from low-income backgrounds, is struggling with how to continue funding the popular summer program after ESSER funds dry up.
Sylvia Jarrus for Education Week
Education Funding Jim Crow-Era School Funding Hurt Black Families for Generations, Research Shows
Mississippi dramatically underfunded Black schools in the Jim Crow era, with long-lasting effects on Black families.
5 min read
Abacus with rolls of dollar banknotes
iStock/Getty
Education Funding What New School Spending Data Show About a Coming Fiscal Cliff
New data show just what COVID-relief funds did to overall school spending—and the size of the hole they might leave in school budgets.
4 min read
Photo illustration of school building and piggy bank.
F. Sheehan for Education Week + iStock / Getty Images Plus
Education Funding When There's More Money for Schools, Is There an 'Objective' Way to Hand It Out?
A fight over the school funding formula in Mississippi is kicking up old debates over how to best target aid.
7 min read
Illustration of many roads and road signs going in different directions with falling money all around.
iStock/Getty