Narrow Definition of Sex Could Affect Transgender Students

By Evie Blad — October 30, 2018 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

A report that the Trump administration is considering a move to define sex under Title IX in a way that could essentially deny the existence of transgender people, including students in the nation’s schools, sparked outrage among advocates for transgender students last week.

“Sex means a person’s status as male or female based on immutable biological traits identifiable by or before birth,” the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services said in a memo, according to a New York Times report.

“The sex listed on a person’s birth certificate, as originally issued, shall constitute definitive proof of a person’s sex unless rebutted by reliable genetic evidence.”

The agency is working to align interpretations of Title IX and other civil rights laws related to gender among federal agencies, the Times reported. Such a move would restrict civil rights enforcement by the agencies related to transgender issues.

But education law experts and civil rights groups—pointing to federal court decisions siding with transgender students in disputes over access to school restrooms and locker rooms—said such an interpretation of Title IX would be at odds with growing court precedent.

The administration’s interpretation of federal laws informs its approach to civil rights enforcement and regulations, but is not legally binding, said Suzanne Eckes, a professor of educational leadership and policy studies at Indiana University.

That means, regardless of the administration’s position, transgender students could still sue over school policies, and they’d have a likelihood of winning in many courts, she said.

“These guidances don’t have the force of law, they’re not binding, and the law is still the law,” Eckes said.

Sex vs. Gender

According to the New York Times report, the HHS proposal would “define sex as either male or female, unchangeable, and determined by the genitals that a person is born with, according to a draft reviewed by The Times. Any dispute about one’s sex would have to be clarified using genetic testing.”

Advocates for transgender students have argued that the concept of sex in Title IX, the federal law that prohibits sex discrimination in schools, was intended to refer more broadly to the concept of gender. In some cases, they’ve even cited law dictionaries from the 1970s, when the law was enacted, to show their definitions did not refer strictly to biological sex assigned at birth.

Several federal judges have agreed, ruling that the law protects the rights of transgender students to use restrooms and locker rooms that align with their gender identity.

In one of her first moves as U.S. Secretary of Education, Betsy DeVos teamed with Attorney General Jeff

Sessions to withdraw an Obama administration civil rights directive on Title IX that called on schools to recognize transgender students by using appropriate pronouns, protecting them from harassment, and allowing them to use the facilities that align with their gender identity.

The Trump officials declined to take a position on Title IX and transgender students, saying it was up to schools to interpret the law. But the agencies’ civil rights officials have declined to take up claims of discrimination in the time since.

If the Trump administration adopted the narrow definition of sex that HHS has proposed, it would move the Education Department from a hands-off approach to one that’s at odds with inclusive policies in many districts and some state-level civil rights laws that list gender identity as a protected class. That may further inflame tensions over the agency’s approach to civil rights enforcement.

The department’s involvement in the cross-agency discussions over gender identity remains unclear. A spokesperson for the agency did not respond to request for comment by press time.

Some conservative groups who’ve opposed allowing transgender students access to restrooms and locker rooms that match their gender identity say it creates privacy and safety concerns for other students.

After such groups made that argument in a lawsuit, a federal judge in Texas issued a preliminary injunction on the Obama-era guidance, freezing its application nationwide while he considered the case. That lawsuit was later ended after the Trump administration rescinded the guidance.

Alliance Defends Freedom, a conservative Christian organization, last month filed a complaint on behalf of Georgia parents who said their daughter was assaulted in an elementary school restroom, connecting the attack to the district’s transgender-student policies.

Many school districts that have accommodated transgender students for years say they have faced few or no problems.

And several judges have quickly shot down privacy arguments made by students challenging their school’s transgender student policies, Eckes said.

Parents of transgender students have testified in state and local hearings that their children face great fear at school about issues as simple as going to the bathroom.

Some students even refuse to drink water at school, dehydrating themselves to avoid the stigma they feel, their parents said.

Transgender advocacy groups vowed to fight any changes to federal policy related to gender.

A version of this article appeared in the October 31, 2018 edition of Education Week as Narrow Definition of Sex Could Affect Transgender Students


Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
English-Language Learners Webinar English Learners and the Science of Reading: What Works in the Classroom
ELs & emergent bilinguals deserve the best reading instruction! The Reading League & NCEL join forces on best practices. Learn more in our webinar with both organizations.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Teaching Webinar
Challenging the Stigma: Emotions and STEM
STEM isn't just equations and logic. Join this webinar and discover how emotions fuel innovation, creativity, & problem-solving in STEM!
Content provided by Project Lead The Way

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal Low-Performing Schools Are Left to Languish by Districts and States, Watchdog Finds
Fewer than half of district plans for improving struggling schools meet bare minimum requirements.
11 min read
A group of silhouettes looks across a grid with a public school on the other side.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week via Canva
Federal Biden Admin. Says New K-12 Agenda Tackles Absenteeism, Tutoring, Extended Learning
The White House unveiled a set of K-12 priorities at the start of an election year.
4 min read
U.S. Education Secretary Miguel Cardona participates in a roundtable discussion with students from Dartmouth College on Jan. 10, 2024, on the school's campus, in Hanover, N.H.
U.S. Education Secretary Miguel Cardona participates in a roundtable discussion with students from Dartmouth College on Jan. 10, 2024, on the school's campus, in Hanover, N.H.
Steven Senne/AP
Federal Lawmakers Want to Reauthorize a Major Education Research Law. What Stands in the Way?
Lawmakers have tried and failed to reauthorize the Education Sciences Reform Act over the past nearly two decades.
7 min read
Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., left, joins Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee Chairman Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., left, as Starbucks founder Howard Schultz answers questions about the company's actions during an ongoing employee unionizing campaign, at the Capitol in Washington, on March 29, 2023.
Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., left, joins Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee Chairman Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., left, at the Capitol in Washington, on March 29, 2023. The two lawmakers sponsored a bill to reauthorize the Education Sciences Reform Act.
J. Scott Applewhite/AP
Federal Will the Government Actually Shut Down This Time? What Educators Should Know
The federal government is once again on the verge of shutting down. Here's why educators should care, but shouldn't necessarily worry.
1 min read
Photo illustration of Capitol building and closed sign.