Choice, SES Would Flip Under Plan

May 23, 2006 5 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The U.S. Department of Education is planning to expand a pilot initiative that would flip the order of key consequences for schools’ low academic performance under the No Child Left Behind Act.

Building on an initiative piloted this school year in Virginia, participating districts could offer students a choice of supplemental educational services, or SES, a year before having to provide the option of transferring to a higher-performing school. Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings announced the plan last week.

While some state education officials are welcoming the new flexibility, which some of them had long sought, the effort is also facing sharp criticism.

Lawyers at two advocacy groups that want tougher enforcement of the law’s choice provisions argue that the secretary’s move oversteps legal bounds. One of the lawyers, Clint Bolick from the Phoenix-based Alliance for School Choice, said last week that his group was researching the possibility of a legal challenge.

In a May 15 letter to chief state school officers, Ms. Spellings said states that meet three eligibility criteria could apply on behalf of up to seven districts each to take part.

“If we get kids help first before the public school choice thing, as a possibility, [that] makes sense to me,” Ms. Spellings said in a May 17 session with reporters. “Let’s do stuff that works better.”

Under a “flexibility agreement” reached last August, the department is running a smaller pilot project in four districts in Virginia. The pilot marked the first time the agency had granted a waiver of the actual provisions of the No Child Left Behind Act itself. (“NCLB Waiver Lets Virginia Offer Tutoring Before Choice,” Sept. 7, 2005.)

The normal order calls for districts to offer school choice first, after a school receiving federal Title I aid has not made adequate yearly progress, or AYP, for two consecutive years. If the school fails for a third year, the district must also give students free access to supplemental services such as tutoring.

Even many supporters of the 4-year-old No Child Left Behind law have called that order illogical.

Ms. Spellings wrote in her letter that the “positive results” in the Virginia pilot showed that offering the flexibility on a broader scale was warranted. At the same time, the letter warns that the department is prepared to take “significant enforcement action” against states and districts that fail to meet the choice and SES requirements, including possible withholding of federal funds.

Eligibility Limited

With the June 19 deadline for applications nearing, Valerie A. Woodruff, Delaware’s education secretary, predicted that her state will likely pursue the new flexibility.

“It makes more sense to give schools the opportunity to meet the needs of kids … before you just go wildly into choice,” she said.

Jack Jennings, the president of the Center on Education Policy, a Washington research and advocacy group that has monitored the law’s implementation, says he sees the department’s move as significant.

“In our surveying over the last four years, this has been a common recommendation from school districts and states,” said Mr. Jennings, a former longtime aide to Democrats on the House education committee.

But he estimated that more than half of states might not be eligible.

“There’s a whole slew of conditions on it,” he said. “Those conditions will limit this considerably.”

To participate in the pilot, states must have determined whether schools had made AYP before the start of the academic year for this school year and last; have an evaluation of SES providers under way; and have their assessment system fully or conditionally approved by the Education Department or have such approval “expected,” according to information accompanying Ms. Spellings’ letter.

For a district to participate, it must have issued “timely” notification letters to parents on both choice and SES over the past two years.

Jeff Simering, the legislative director for the Washington-based Council of the Great City Schools, which represents the nation’s largest urban school districts, suggested that while the new flexibility was “reasonable,” he does not believe it will mean much.

He said Education Department officials have long suggested that districts should make supplemental services available when choice is not a realistic option.

“We’ve heard that for the last three or four years, so I don’t think this is a major change,” he said.

He also said the issue is a moot point for a large number of Title I schools that under the law already have to meet both the choice and supplemental-services options.

Legality Questioned

Dianne M. Piché, the executive director of the Citizens’ Commission on Civil Rights, a Washington-based watchdog group, sharply criticized the department’s plans.

“We’ve been monitoring implementation, and with very few exceptions, school districts are doing a terrible job in finding spaces and offering parents the opportunity to transfer to a better school, as they’re required to do,” she said. “And so it baffles me that we wouldn’t be trying to find more ways to provide more choices for parents instead of restricting parents’ options under the law.”

Ms. Piché, a lawyer, also questioned the move’s legality. “There’s no statutory authority to do this,” she contended.

Mr. Bolick of the school choice alliance agreed. “It seems completely outside the secretary’s authority,” he said. “The law is very explicit about the rights children have.”

His group filed a formal complaint with the department in March charging that two Southern California districts had failed to offer choice under the law. (“Complaint Targets NCLB Transfers in Calif.,” March 29, 2006.)

But Valerie L. Smith, an Education Department spokeswoman, argued that the federal agency has clear authority to take such steps, citing Section 9401 of the law. This section, she wrote in an e-mail, states that, with limited exceptions, “the secretary may waive any statutory or regulatory requirements of this act” for a state, district, or school.

On the enforcement front, Ms. Spellings cited concerns about weak compliance by some states and districts with the school choice and tutoring options under the law.

“In most cases, when [districts] are out of compliance with public school choice and [the SES provisions], I will place conditions on state grants and consider withholding federal funds or entering into a compliance agreement,” she wrote.

Mr. Bolick said he was pleased by those comments, but suggested the secretary’s letter sent mixed messages.

“Waivers and enforcement actions simply don’t mix,” he said.

Staff Writer Michelle R. Davis contributed to this report.
A version of this article appeared in the May 24, 2006 edition of Education Week as Choice, SES Would Flip Under Plan


School & District Management K-12 Essentials Forum Get a Strong Start to the New School Year
Get insights and actions from Education Week journalists and expert guests on how to start the new school year on strong footing.
Reading & Literacy Webinar A Roadmap to Multisensory Early Literacy Instruction: Accelerate Growth for All Students 
How can you develop key literacy skills with a diverse range of learners? Explore best practices and tips to meet the needs of all students. 
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Supporting 21st Century Skills with a Whole-Child Focus
What skills do students need to succeed in the 21st century? Explore the latest strategies to best prepare students for college, career, and life.
Content provided by Panorama Education

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal Voters Want Republicans and Democrats to Talk About Learning Recovery, Not Culture Wars
A recent Democrats for Education Reform poll shows a disconnect between political candidates and voters on education issues.
4 min read
Image of voting and party lines.
Federal Use Your 'Teacher Voice,' Jill Biden Urges in a Push for Political Activism
Voting in the midterms is a critical step educators can take to bolster democracy, the first lady and other labor leaders told teachers.
5 min read
First Lady Jill Biden speaks during the American Federation of Teachers convention, Friday, July 15, 2022, in Boston.
First lady Jill Biden speaks during the American Federation of Teachers convention in Boston.
Michael Dwyer/AP
Federal Federal Initiative Leverages COVID Aid to Expand After-School, Summer Learning
The Education Department's Engage Every Student effort includes partnerships with civic organizations and professional groups.
3 min read
Education Secretary Miguel Cardona speaks at an event on June 2, 2022, at the Department of Education in Washington.
U.S. Secretary of Education Secretary Miguel Cardona speaks at an event at the Department of Education in Washington in June. The department has announced a push for expanded access to after-school and summer learning programs.
Jacquelyn Martin/AP
Federal Restraint and Seclusion, and Disability Rights: Ed. Department Has Work to Do, Audit Finds
The Government Accountability Office releases a checklist of how the U.S. Department of Education is performing on a list of priorities.
4 min read
Flags decorate a space outside the office of the Education Secretary at the Education Department in Washington on Aug. 9, 2017.
Flags decorate a space outside the office of the Education Secretary at the U.S. Department of Education. The Government Accountability Office has released recommended priorities for the Education Department that target special education rights.
Jacquelyn Martin/AP