School & District Management

Urban Schools Chiefs Complain of Demands In ‘Impossible’ Roles

By Jeff Archer — August 06, 2003 4 min read

Imagine inviting a group of urban superintendents to a bar, buying them a round of drinks, and asking what they really think about school boards, unions, parent groups, and their own chances of success. Call it an “unhappy hour.”

The report, “An Impossible Job? The View From the Urban Superintendent’s Chair,” is available from the Center on Reinventing Education.

Researchers at the University of Washington in Seattle have captured that kind of candid talk in a new report on the superintendency. Based on interviews and surveys with superintendents in 100 of the country’s largest districts, the authors conclude that the politics of the job, along with the limits on those executives’ authority, make it almost impossible for district leaders to significantly improve their school systems.

“My sense is that in that environment, the expectations on superintendents to deliver on the promises of ‘No Child Left Behind’ are unrealistic,” said James Harvey, a senior fellow at the University of Washington’s Center on Reinventing Public Education, referring to the federal law that has placed new demands on precollegiate education.

The center carried out the study with financial support from the New York City-based Wallace Foundation, which held a national conference in Eugene, Ore., last week for grantees in its educational leadership initiatives. Together, the superintendents polled for the research project oversee some 9,000 schools serving 6.5 million students in both urban and large suburban systems. The survey had a 70 percent response rate.

Leveraging Change

The report, “An Impossible Job? The View from the Urban Superintendent’s Chair,” shows strong support among superintendents for limiting the role of school boards, for evaluating principals based on school performance, and for allowing district chiefs to close failing schools.

See Also...

See the accompanying chart, “A Host of Challenges.”

District leaders in the study cited a litany of challenges that they say conspire against them. Nearly half those polled agreed that responding to public demands was difficult because those demands keep changing. More than 60 percent said micromanagement by school boards was a problem. And in interviews, many superintendents said that in making important decisions, the concerns of district employees often trump the need to raise student performance.

“We are constantly choosing between initiatives that might work, but would get you fired, and initiatives that are too weak to do much, but might survive long enough to make a little bit of difference,” said one of many administrators quoted anonymously in the report.

Overall, the survey found little difference in the level of frustration between district leaders who came up through the ranks in education and those who came from the military, legal, and corporate worlds. However, those with nontraditional backgrounds were more likely to see “constituency conflicts” as a problem, while career educators were somewhat less satisfied with the quality of their academic training for the job.

Also, although superintendents’ survey responses generally expressed confidence that they could close the achievement gap between needy students and their more advantaged peers, in interviews they were far less sanguine.

“When superintendents focus on the achievement gap, they quickly encounter opposition from the parents of children who are less at risk,” the authors write.

Helpful Pressure

On the flip side, the research does hint at how savvy district leaders can use the challenges they face to their advantage. Many of the superintendents agreed that pressure created by government mandates, the perception of a crisis, and community groups could help advance their own agendas. One schools chief interviewed, for instance, said enlisting the support of local business and religious leaders made for a winning combination.

Although he hadn’t seen the results of the report, former Sacramento, Calif., schools chief Jim Sweeney agreed that a good district leader knows how to exploit external pressure. Mr. Sweeney resigned his post in June after leading the 52,000-student system through five years of student improvement—and significant controversy.

His last year was dominated by debate over his support for converting a regular public high school into a charter school, a battle that continues.

“Since I took this job, I’ve leveraged everything with the fact that we had to get better because too many kids were failing,” Mr. Sweeney said.

“The more you’re really stirring things up,” he added, “the tougher, and meaner, and more difficult it gets.”

But such political skills aren’t enough, say the study’s authors. Based on the survey results, they argue that what district leaders need most is greater freedom to run their school systems.

All but 3 percent of the respondents said they wanted the power to close underperforming schools and reopen them with new staff members and management. And the vast majority agreed that school boards should stay out of personnel matters—except for hiring the schools chief—and focus instead on setting performance goals and budget priorities.

“We’ve got to change the nature of the job,” said Howard L. Fuller, an education professor at Marquette University and a former superintendent of the Milwaukee schools, who also worked on the study. “We’ve got to give these people the kind of power that goes with the responsibility that we give them.”

Related Tags:

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Future of Work Webinar
Digital Literacy Strategies to Promote Equity
Our new world has only increased our students’ dependence on technology. This makes digital literacy no longer a “nice to have” but a “need to have.” How do we ensure that every student can navigate
Content provided by Learning.com
Mathematics Online Summit Teaching Math in a Pandemic
Attend this online summit to ask questions about how COVID-19 has affected achievement, instruction, assessment, and engagement in math.
School & District Management Webinar Examining the Evidence: Catching Kids Up at a Distance
As districts, schools, and families navigate a new normal following the abrupt end of in-person schooling this spring, students’ learning opportunities vary enormously across the nation. Access to devices and broadband internet and a secure

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Special Education Teachers
Lancaster, PA, US
Lancaster Lebanon IU 13
Speech Therapists
Lancaster, PA, US
Lancaster Lebanon IU 13
Elementary Teacher
Madison, Wisconsin
One City Schools
Elementary Teacher - Scholars Academy
Madison, Wisconsin
One City Schools

Read Next

School & District Management Opinion A Road Map for Education Research in a Crisis
Here are five basic principles for a responsible and timely research agenda during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Robin J. Lake
4 min read
Two opposing sides reaching out to work together
J.R. Bee for Education Week
School & District Management 1,000 Students, No Social Distancing, and a Fight to Keep the Virus Out
A principal describes the "nightmare" job of keeping more than 1,000 people safe in the fast-moving pandemic.
4 min read
Dixie Rae Garrison, principal of West Jordan Middle School, in West Jordan, Utah.
Dixie Rae Garrison, principal of West Jordan Middle School in West Jordan, Utah, would have preferred a hybrid schedule and other social distancing measures.
Courtesy of Dixie Rae Garrison
School & District Management A School Leader Who Calls Her Own Shots on Battling the Coronavirus
A charter school founder uses her autonomy to move swiftly on everything from classroom shutdowns to remote schooling.
3 min read
Nigena Livingston, founder and head of School at the URBAN ACT Academy in Indianapolis, Ind.
Nigena Livingston, founder and head of school at the URBAN ACT Academy in Indianapolis, makes swift decisions in responding to the threat of COVID-19 in her school community.
Courtesy of Nigena Livingston
School & District Management A COVID-19 Lull Gives Way to ‘Borderline Insanity’
When the number of cases started to rise steeply, a school community hammered out a routine. Then a basketball player tested positive.
3 min read
Andy McGill, K-12 assistant principal at West Liberty-Salem Local School District in West Liberty, Ohio.
Andy McGill, K-12 assistant principal at West Liberty-Salem Local School District in Ohio, includes coronavirus response among his administrative duties.
Courtesy of Andy McGill