School & District Management

System Thwarts Teacher’s Bid To Transfer To Needy School

By Robert C. Johnston — July 11, 2001 6 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

It was a long shot, but James P. Otto figured he had nothing to loose by inviting the 2000 Pennsylvania Teacher of the Year to join his staff.

Typically, veteran teachers want schools that are less demanding than Edwin M. Stanton School, an impoverished but improving South Philadelphia K-8 site where Mr. Otto has been the principal since 1997.

In the spring of last year, though, Faith Kline called him to say the post she held in another Philadelphia school had been cut, and she was ready for a move—to Edwin M. Stanton for the 2000-01 school year.

“Faith Kline was going to be the jewel in our crown,” Mr. Otto said recently of the dynamic, 10-year teaching veteran he met while attending a literacy workshop for teachers that she directed. “She would have put us in another realm.”

But—for reasons that are still unclear to Mr. Otto and to Ms. Kline—the transfer failed. Instead, she was assigned to a school she had not requested, in a less needy community with higher test scores.

“The biggest slap in the face is that a veteran teacher has put in a valid transfer, and I ended up with a stack of teachers with no experience in teaching,” said Mr. Otto, who has been a principal for 18 years. “And someone along the line thinks this is how it ought to be.”

Pairing top teachers with the neediest students is one of most urgent challenges facing schools nationally, as well as in Philadelphia. Ms. Kline’s desire to work in the struggling school runs counter to the more typical pattern of veteran teachers choosing to work in more desirable schools.

“As teachers get more experience, they try to transfer to schools where it’s not as difficult to teach,” noted Patte Barth, a senior associate at the Education Trust, a Washington-based research and advocacy organization that promotes higher academic standards for poor children.

Ms. Kline’s request to transfer to Stanton “signals the kind of cachet there should be around teaching in the most difficult schools,” Ms. Barth said.

Glitch Cited

Personnel officials for the Philadelphia district were unavailable for comment on Ms. Kline’s request. But speaking on their behalf, Milton McGriff, a school district spokesman, said that the system had worked, at least technically, the way it is supposed to.

Jerry J. Jordan, the vice president of the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, agreed, saying that the rules, regulations, and stipulations of the teacher contract then in place were apparently followed to the letter.

Both men also said that if Ms. Kline had just filled out her paperwork a little bit differently, the transfer, in all likelihood, would have gone through.

But the official explanation on the part of the 215,000-student district and the union rings hollow to Ms. Kline, 46.

“It says volumes about huge, bureaucratic districts and their commitment to children,” she said last month. “If it’s my fault that I didn’t get to one of their schools that’s the most needy, then what was their role and what was the purpose of that group [the district personnel office]?”

No Flexibility?

Recent data from a Philadelphia schools study found that, unlike the transfer Ms. Kline sought last year, teachers tended to move to schools with better test scores, lower poverty rates, and lower percentages of minority students. The study also found that one-third of the city’s teaching positions turned over between September 1996 and December 1999. (“Philadelphia Study: Teacher Transfers Add to Educational Inequities,” April 18, 2001.)

Federal data also show that half of all new urban teachers leave teaching within five years.

Given that churning, coupled with chronic teacher shortages in many city districts, some say Ms. Kline’s failed transfer request is symptomatic of greater bureaucratic shortcomings.

“The system has to have the flexibility to respond to what seem to be responsible and important staffing requests,” said Shelly Yanoff, the executive director of Philadelphia Citizens for Children and Youth, a local advocacy group.

Such flexibility seemed to be missing in Ms. Kline’s case.

Mr. McGriff, the school district spokesman, explained that three main criteria govern voluntary-transfer requests: There must be an opening in the requested school; priority goes to senior teachers; and the school must meet certain staffing ratios by race.

Mr. McGriff said there was no opening at Stanton when Ms. Kline’s request was processed, based on his conversation with the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, the local affiliate of the American Federation of Teachers that represents Ms. Kline. He was unable, however, to verify that explanation with the district’s human resources department.

Mr. Otto, Stanton’s principal, said that he had clearly informed the personnel office that he would have several openings, including two maternity leaves, over the summer of 2000.

While a delay by the pregnant teachers in submitting their notices ultimately may have killed Ms. Kline’s request, neither Mr. Otto nor Ms. Kline was told that at the time, despite numerous queries about why she had been assigned to another school.

Two days before the school year began, Mr. Otto was sent seven first-year teachers, three of whom lacked full-time teaching credentials. Ms. Kline was the only teacher in the district who had requested a transfer to his school.

“I dare say that the list of requests to transfer here amounted to one,” Mr. Otto said. “I had no reason to believe she wouldn’t be here. I mean, we’re not beating away applicants with a stick.”

Meanwhile, Ms. Kline was sent to Finletter Academic Plus School, a site she had not requested. After Stanton, her transfer request listed four other clusters, or sub-regions, as broad options for placement.

She said a union representative had told her to do it that way. Believing the Stanton move was certain, she was told that it was better to list regions she preferred to teach in rather than risk being reassigned to the school she wanted to leave.

Mr. Jordan of the teachers’ union now says that may have been poor advice. If Ms. Kline had listed Stanton and left her other options blank, he said, her request to go to a new school would have been put on hold until an opening arose at Stanton."The district honored the request obligation and doesn’t have to reassign, or we’d be doing transfers all year,” he said.

Besides, Mr. Jordan added, “Finletter kids got the Teacher of the Year, and we love the students of Finletter as much as the kids at Stanton.”

Skills Untapped

Ms. Kline said that she, too, loves her Finletter students, as well as the two apprentice teachers she mentored there. But, she added, not all things are equal.

For example, while 29 percent of Finletter students scored “below basic” on district reading exams in 1999-2000, more than half, or 52 percent of Stanton students, performed below basic.

“Yes, Finletter needs a good teacher. Every child deserves a good teacher,” Ms. Kline said. “But what children need in one school is not what children need in another school.”

In addition, she said, she was not called on to be part of the leadership or staff-training team at Finletter—which went through three principals last year. Mr. Otto, in contrast, said that she would have been called on to help train and support his new teachers at Stanton, as she had in her previous school.

“If the district wasn’t going to take advantage of her experience and do something with it,” he said, “I’m certainly willing to turn it into something special here.”

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the July 11, 2001 edition of Education Week as System Thwarts Teacher’s Bid To Transfer To Needy School

Events

School & District Management K-12 Essentials Forum Get a Strong Start to the New School Year
Get insights and actions from Education Week journalists and expert guests on how to start the new school year on strong footing.
Reading & Literacy Webinar A Roadmap to Multisensory Early Literacy Instruction: Accelerate Growth for All Students 
How can you develop key literacy skills with a diverse range of learners? Explore best practices and tips to meet the needs of all students. 
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Webinar
Supporting 21st Century Skills with a Whole-Child Focus
What skills do students need to succeed in the 21st century? Explore the latest strategies to best prepare students for college, career, and life.
Content provided by Panorama Education

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management Top Tips for New Assistant Principals From Those Who've Been There
Nurture relationships, learn on the job, take care of yourself—and other key advice.
5 min read
Image of leaders as a central figures to a variety of activities in motion.
Laura Baker/Education Week and gobyg/DigitalVision Vectors
School & District Management L.A. Cracks Down on Homeless Encampments Near Schools, Over the Jeers of Protesters
Under the new restrictions, homeless people would be prohibited from setting up tents within 500 feet of every public and private school.
David Zahniser and Benjamin Oreskes, Los Angeles Times
5 min read
A homeless camp in downtown Los Angeles pictured on Sept. 17, 2019. A proposal to greatly restrict where homeless people may camp in Los Angeles drew protest at a City Council meeting from demonstrators who fear the rules would criminalize homelessness.
A homeless camp in downtown Los Angeles. A proposal to greatly restrict where homeless people may camp in Los Angeles drew protest at a City Council meeting from demonstrators who fear the rules would criminalize homelessness.
Damian Dovarganes/AP
School & District Management Statistics Update: New Trends in Enrollment, Virtual Schooling, and Special Education
New data in EdWeek's statistics pages point to changes in where students are attending school and the services they're getting.
Conceptual image of allocation.
Lea Toews/iStock/Getty
School & District Management Opinion 10 Ways to Include Teachers in Important Policy Decisions
Teachers are the lifeblood of schools, and they should be treated that way.
5 min read
18Goldstein 1126473545
iStock/Getty