Equity & Diversity

Researcher Insists N.Y.C. Vouchers Benefit Black Students

By Debra Viadero — June 18, 2003 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Yet another analysis of results from a privately financed experiment with school vouchers in New York City suggests that the program produced significant test-score gains for African-American students.

The findings, unveiled last week by Harvard University researchers Paul E. Peterson and William G. Howell, are the latest in a series of analyses that have yielded different conclusions from the same data.

The program in question, which began in 1997, provides scholarships of $1,400 a year to 1,200 New York public school students so they can attend private schools.

While school choice is a perennial hot topic, the New York effort particularly interested researchers and policymakers because it offered a rare chance to empirically test the effects of vouchers. Since the vouchers were distributed by lottery, researchers could compare the experiences of the winning students with those of students who sought, but did not receive, vouchers.

The full text of Peterson-Howell’s study, “Efficiency, Bias, and Classification Schemes: Estimating Private-School Impacts on Test Scores in the New York City Voucher Experiment,” is available from the John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University. (Requires Adobe’s Acrobat Reader.)

The first analysis of the results, which the Harvard researchers conducted with Mathematica Policy Research Inc., showed that while students overall derived no academic benefit from the program, African-American students did make sizable gains. (“Voucher Plans’ Test Data Yield Puzzling Trends,” Feb. 27, 2002.)

That finding was disputed earlier this year by Alan B. Krueger and Pei Zhu, two Princeton University researchers who re-examined the data. Their analysis concluded that the gains found for black students were too small to be significant. (“Study: No Academic Gains from Vouchers for Black Students,” April 9, 2003.)

In the new study, Mr. Peterson and Mr. Howell try to dispel the Princeton researchers’ criticisms of their work by configuring the data dozens of different ways.

Not Persuaded

“The basic story here is whether you do it one way or another, you get significant, positive impacts for African- Americans,” said Mr. Peterson, a professor of government at Harvard.

By Mr. Peterson and Mr. Howell’s optimal calculations, black students who attended private schools for three years under the program outscored their public school counterparts who weren’t chosen in the lottery by 8.4 percentile points. That gain—equal to about a grade level—is slightly lower than the 9.2 percentile points that the Harvard researchers first reported.

Mr. Peterson said the change reflects some revisions the authors made in their calculations.

Interviewed last week, however, Mr. Krueger said the points the Harvard researchers made in their new study were still “off the mark.” The new findings also failed to sway a group of prominent researchers assembled by the Washington-based Economic Policy Institute via teleconference to answer reporters’ questions about the new study.

Looking at both re-analyses, Cecilia E. Rouse, a Princeton economics and public-policy professor, concludes: “Really, what you take away from this is that the results are basically not as robust as previously characterized.”

A major point of contention between the Princeton analysis and the Harvard study was whether to include students for whom the researchers had no baseline test scores. Adding those students to the mix increases the sample size by 44 percent and reduces some of the original test-score gains.

“The simplest thing to do is to compare those who got vouchers with those who didn’t,” Mr. Krueger said. “The beauty of an experiment is that you should be able to control for anything, and it should not change your results.”

Mr. Peterson and Mr. Howell argue in their new paper, however, for including only students with baseline test-score data—or at least factoring the scores into the calculations. “You’ve got a lot better-quality information if you know kids started out from the same place at the very beginning,” Mr. Peterson said.

The Harvard researchers also took issue with the Princeton scholars’ methods for classifying students’ race and ethnicity. When students were African-American and Hispanic, for example, Mr. Krueger and his co-author classified them as both. The Harvard researchers took the categories to be mutually exclusive.

Mr. Peterson and Mr. Howell also recalculated the race-related numbers several ways, looking at whether a student’s mother, both parents, either parent, or caretaker was black. Results were positive each time, they said.


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Budget & Finance Webinar
Innovative Funding Models: A Deep Dive into Public-Private Partnerships
Discover how innovative funding models drive educational projects forward. Join us for insights into effective PPP implementation.
Content provided by Follett Learning
Budget & Finance Webinar Staffing Schools After ESSER: What School and District Leaders Need to Know
Join our newsroom for insights on investing in critical student support positions as pandemic funds expire.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Student Achievement Webinar
How can districts build sustainable tutoring models before the money runs out?
District leaders, low on funds, must decide: broad support for all or deep interventions for few? Let's discuss maximizing tutoring resources.
Content provided by Varsity Tutors for Schools

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Equity & Diversity States Have Restricted Teaching on Social Justice. Is Teacher Preparation Next?
A new Florida law will restrict what teacher-preparation programs can teach about racism and sexism.
5 min read
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis answers questions from the media, March 7, 2023, at the state Capitol in Tallahassee, Fla.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis answers questions from the media, March 7, 2023, at the state Capitol in Tallahassee, Fla. DeSantis signed legislation earlier this month that would restrict teacher training and educator preparation institutes from teaching on social justice.
Phil Sears/AP
Equity & Diversity Opinion 70 Years After 'Brown,' Schools Are Still Separate and Unequal
The legal strategy to prioritize school integration has had some unforeseen consequences in the decades since.
4 min read
A hand holds a scale weighing integration against resource allocation in observation of the 70th anniversary of the Brown v. Board of Education case.
Noelle Rx for Education Week
Equity & Diversity How a DEI Rebrand Is Playing Out in K-12 Schools
School districts continue to advance DEI initiatives, though the focus is more on general inclusion and belonging for all.
9 min read
Ahenewa El-Amin speaks with students during her AP African American Studies class at Henry Clay High School in Lexington, Ky., on March 19, 2024.
Ahenewa El-Amin speaks with students during her AP African American Studies class at Henry Clay High School in Lexington, Ky., on March 19, 2024. State leaders in Kentucky are pushing the message of making sure all students feel they belong in school including by offering ethnic studies courses.
Jaclyn Borowski/Education Week
Equity & Diversity Opinion 70 Years of Abandonment: The Failed Promise of 'Brown v. Board'
If the nation is going to refuse integration, Black people must demand we revisit the separate but equal doctrine, writes Bettina L. Love.
4 min read
A Black student is isolated from their classmates by an aisle in the classroom.
Xia Gordon for Education Week