Opinion
School & District Management Opinion

Put an End to In-School Fundraising

By Elly Schull Meeks — May 14, 2009 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan recently told the nation that education “is the civil rights issue of our generation, and it is the one sure path to a more equal, fair, and just society.” This struck a chord with me and raised a question: How does Duncan, a former professional basketball player and CEO of the Chicago public schools, a man who is known for his dedication to fair play on the court and in the classroom, feel about a routine practice in today’s schools that is both unfair and unjust? I’m talking about the insidious, hidden-in-plain-sight practice of fundraising during the school day, with the students recruited as salespeople.

My wake-up call on the problem came late, after several years of volunteering at the annual Scholastic Book Fair at my son’s school. Each year, I’d help the kindergartners who were trotted in from their classes fill out their “wish lists,” forms giving the titles and prices of books they wanted bought for them. Take the lists home tonight, I’d dutifully remind the children.

What better way to help the school generate a little extra cash than promoting reading? Plus, I enjoyed it—until one day I didn’t. And then I realized that what I was doing was coercive, exploitative, and economically discriminating, to the children and their families. Not to mention the fact that it was blatantly commercial.

It’s not just these sponsored book fairs that snare the well-meaning parent, either. Consider the annual magazine drives with their kickoff assemblies. These money-making activities, whether supplied by industry leader QSP Inc. or one of the abundant smaller purveyors contracted by schools around the country, typically involve herding the entire student body into the auditorium to be whipped into a selling frenzy. “Sell the most subscriptions and you can win the iPod, Xbox, or a limo ride to the neighborhood pizza parlor!” Many schools around the country go further, holding pet-show parties or cash-grab carnivals for the winners—during school hours.

Good-bye, bake sales and car washes—hands-on, largely student-run after-school ventures to pay for a special field trip or new team uniforms. Hello, backpacks stuffed with promotional fliers hawking cookie dough, wrapping paper, or (my favorite) gourmet-scented pencils—Smencils!—and incentivized sales rallies in lieu of social studies.

The rationale for these activities? They supposedly teach kids teamwork, business, and people skills. But the only lesson kids are guaranteed to learn is how to become cogs in the $4 billion-a-year commercial school-fundraising industry—and make next year’s crop of ever-more-irresistible gewgaws possible.

These days, teachers complain of having barely enough time to cover the material required by state standards and federal testing mandates. But more than just precious instructional hours are lost to fundraising as it turns classrooms into polarizing arenas in which kids learn whose parents can buy them the most books or get enough relatives or co-workers to pony up in chocolate bars to win them the Wii.

Economic inequalities between school districts are exacerbated, too. In a sad commentary on the gap between parents’ desires to help their children’s schools and their abilities to do so, while both well-heeled and less affluent communities hold book fairs, the latter often yield less profit than bounced checks.

Whittled-down school budgets have intensified real and perceived needs for spending on everything from jeopardized arts programs to smartboards. And in our financial panic, perhaps, we’ve persuaded ourselves that the only way we can enrich our schools is by fundraising that is not just perpetual, but often unfettered by firewalls that could shield kids from the competitive pressures and other grown-up concerns they foist on them.

Yet commercial firewalls in schools are precisely what parents fight to maintain by banning advertising and sugary snacks. And that’s what the National PTA claims to honor. PTA online and print literature repeatedly warn, “Children should never be exploited or used as fundraisers” and “Children should not take part in fundraising activities.” A few paragraphs or pages later, however, these materials offer helpful links to fundraising outfits utilizing students in just these ways.

Interestingly, a majority of principals surveyed in 2007 by the National Association of Elementary School Principals said they’d rather not have fundraisers. Yet they valued the programs and technologies these activities were able to bring their schools, add-ons that promised to raise test scores and the schools’ reputations. Other, anonymous reports suggest that principals are likely to allow fundraisers because doing otherwise means saying no to today’s prevalent school booster types who wield their own agendas and have a can-do way of going over the principal’s head for what they want.

Plenty of teachers detest fundraisers, too. At the same time, though, they rely on them to pick up the costs of supplies and materials their schools can’t afford and that they often end up paying for out of their own pockets. Without the support of their unions, generally silent on this issue so far, teachers are understandably reluctant to speak out.

Parochial interests seem unwilling or unable to confront the problem. Which is why Secretary Duncan’s addressing education in civil rights terms make me somewhat hopeful. He might just be the player to take a shot at the issue, and at least make the case publicly that ensuring our children’s right to an education of quality and equality means protecting them from in-school fundraising. Maybe he can even make it a slam-dunk.

A version of this article appeared in the May 20, 2009 edition of Education Week as Put an End to In-School Fundraising

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
The Future of the Science of Reading
Join us for a discussion on the future of the Science of Reading and how to support every student’s path to literacy.
Content provided by HMH
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
College & Workforce Readiness Webinar
From Classrooms to Careers: How Schools and Districts Can Prepare Students for a Changing Workforce
Real careers start in school. Learn how Alton High built student-centered, job-aligned pathways.
Content provided by TNTP
Mathematics K-12 Essentials Forum Helping Students Succeed in Math

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management Q&A ‘A Nice and Gentle Disrupter’: Meet the New Principals of the Year
The award went to middle school principal Damon Lewis and high school principal Tony Cattani.
11 min read
Damon Lewis, the principal of Ponus Ridge STEAM Academy, and Tony Cattani, the principal of Lenape High School, receive their awards at the annual National Association of Secondary School Principals Illuminate Principal of the Year Celebration in Seattle.
From left, Damon Lewis, the principal of Ponus Ridge STEAM Academy, and Tony Cattani, the principal of Lenape High School, receive their awards at the National Association of Secondary School Principals conference in Seattle. They were both named the 2025-26 National Principal of the Year.
Courtesy of Allyssa Hynes/National Association of Secondary School Principals
School & District Management Opinion Kindergartners Are Struggling With Self-Regulation. How Principals Can Respond
This school leader recommends three actionable steps.
Ian Knox
4 min read
Addressing difficulties and equipping students, staff, and faculty with the tools they need to thrive.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week via Canva
School & District Management Opinion The Stunning Resignation of UVA President Jim Ryan—and Why It Matters
The university president’s departure is more than just a headline. It’s a lesson in leadership.
2 min read
Opinion Licensed Not for Reuse Wait What FCG
Canva
School & District Management In Their Own Words This Custodian Got Students to Stop Vandalizing and Take Pride in Their School
Andy Markus, the 2025 Education Support Professional of the Year, helped boost behavior and engagement in his Utah district.
5 min read
Andy Markus, the head custodian at Draper Park Middle School, in Draper, Utah, sits for a portrait during the National Education Association's 2025 Representative Assembly in Portland, Ore., on July 3, 2025. Markus was named the 2025 NEA Education Support Professional (ESP) of the Year.
Andy Markus, the head custodian at Draper Park Middle School, in Draper, Utah, sits for a portrait during the National Education Association's 2025 representative assembly in Portland, Ore., on July 3, 2025. Markus was named the 2025 NEA Education Support Professional of the Year for his mentorship of students.
Kaylee Domzalski/Education Week