Opinion
School & District Management Opinion

Don’t Buy the “Emergency Powers” Argument for the District of Columbia Public Schools

By Marc Dean Millot — October 13, 2007 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

What powers!

What emergency?

There’s no “state of emergency,” no need for dictatorial authority, and no relationship between the real predicament and the requested powers. Imagine if President George W. Bush and Robert Gates were to argue for making every civil servant in the Office of the Secretary Defense an “at will” employee responsible to the Secretary, who would determine which employees would stay or go based on their performance over the next ninety days.

Their justification? First, a state of emergency brought on by wars in Iraq, Afghanistan and against Islamic terrorism. Second, the failure of the Department of Defense bureaucracy to identify weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, supply our troops with up-armored vehicles, prevent the abuse of prisoners at Abu Graib and Guantanamo, and take adequate care of wounded troops here at home, just to name a few shortcomings.

You decide the details of the response from Congress or among the public, but it’s pretty clear it would not be positive. First, the Second World War didn’t require turning the civil service over to the personal control of an appointed cabinet official. Surely the Republic is under no more serious threat today. Second, the failures cited were not fundamentally ones of the bureaucracy’s inability to execute policy, but of the political leadership’s decisions about policy.

Third, there are very good reasons civil servants are not at will employees. We don’t want them beholden to politics. We don’t want them to so fear for their job security as to put loyalty to the boss above loyalty to the people. We don’t want department heads to think they have such power. And we don’t confine this idea to the national security apparatus, domestic law enforcement, or the tax collectors. We extend it to the entire government, right down to the local level.

So why is it even debatable whether the District of Columbia City Council should give Mayor Adrian Fenty and Public Schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee precisely this power over the school system’s central office?

Stop, think.

What they are saying is:

1) The public schools are in a “state of emergency,” a stretch of that term’s general meaning that seems worthy of Vice President Cheney. They want the City Council to state that public education in the District - by which I presume they mean overall student performance - is in such dire straights that these elected officials must eliminate civil service protections so that the Chancellor can decide who in the central office will have a job.

2) The central office is the problem. It’s why paychecks haven’t reflected what many teachers are owed, the district pays too much for external special education, schools aren’t ready for kids in September, etc., etc.

3) There is a direct and immediate relationship between 2) and 1). That is, unless the central office staff can be made personally responsible to the Chancellor immediately - and subject to her assessment of performance, there’s just no way the Mayor and Chancellor can improve student performance.

I don’t buy any of it, and I don’t see why the City Council should either.

1) We can’t possibly be in a state of emergency so dire that the Chancellor needs to be given absolute power over the school system’s civil service. Even if she and the Mayor are as pure as angels, what about the next Chancellor, the next Mayor? The Roman Senate gave dictatorial powers to Caesars when barbarians were at the gate, and found it hard to see those powers returned. I don’t see the barbarians; do you?

2) The bureaucratic failures cited are of policy making, not policy execution. O.K., unlike Bush, Fenty and Rhee weren’t “the deciders” who got us into this. But just like their predecessors who did by failing to use existing powers, they could use those same powers to get the system out of the mess. For the Mayor and Chancellor to say otherwise is to admit they are no more competent to run the government under the same rules that apply to every jurisdiction in the country than the folks they’ve just replaced. By that logic, the Mayor could just as easily have given the power to former Superintendent Clifford Janey and dispensed with hiring Rhee.

Yes, It’s easier to dictate policy without the restraint of law, but that’s not how we run this republic - and it’s certainly not how a jurisdiction that wants statehood demonstrates its maturity.

3. There’s no relationship between the supposed emergency and the requested powers. If the Chancellor fires every single central office employee tomorrow, reorganizes, and hires people she deems competent by the end of the week, there will be no change in student performance. For her and the Mayor to imply that student performance can’t improve without the central office they’d prefer is ludicrous. There is simply no reason why the Chancellor can’t put in some extra effort/people/funds to use the procedures already in place to do what she and the Mayor deem necessary to improve central office operations and terminate incompetents, while at the same time doing the other things required to improve teaching and learning in the classroom, and accountability and support in the schools.

Related Tags:
Opinion

The opinions expressed in edbizbuzz are strictly those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Assessment Webinar
Reflections on Evidence-Based Grading Practices: What We Learned for Next Year
Get real insights on evidence-based grading from K-12 leaders.
Content provided by Otus
Mathematics Webinar How to Build Students’ Confidence in Math
Learn practical tips to build confident mathematicians in our webinar.
Student Achievement K-12 Essentials Forum How to Build and Scale Effective K-12 State & District Tutoring Programs
Join this free virtual summit to learn from education leaders, policymakers, and industry experts on the topic of high-impact tutoring.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management 1 in 4 Students Are Chronically Absent. 3 Tools to Change That
Chronic absenteeism is a daunting problem. But district leaders aren't alone in facing it, and there are ways they can fight it.
5 min read
Empty desks within a classroom
iStock/Getty Images Plus
School & District Management Opinion Lawmakers Don’t Know What Happens in Schools. Principals Can Help
School leaders must fight to take education funding off the political battlefield.
3 min read
Illustration collage of the U.S. Capitol steps with numerous silhouetted people walking up the steps. There is a yellow halo around them to show the collective power. In the background behind the U.S. Capitol is the back of a young school girl with her hand raised.
Gina Tomko/Education Week via Canva
School & District Management Principals Can't Manage Teacher Morale Alone. Enter the Go-Between
Principals can't check in with every teacher. Can a go-between leader help them out?
6 min read
The concept of joint teamwork, building a team. Working people connecting pieces of puzzles. Metaphor of cooperation and staff partnership.
Anastasiia Boriagina/iStock
School & District Management Quiz Quiz Yourself: How Much Do You Know About Marketing To District and School Leaders at Conferences and Trade Shows?
Think you know what catches a K-12 leader’s eye at conferences? Take this quiz and test your marketing savvy.
120122 mb data conferences 1385168396
Image by Getty