School Climate & Safety

Justices Decline Case on Student’s Violent Writing

By Andrew Trotter — January 30, 2007 4 min read

The U.S. Supreme Court declined last week to review a free-speech case involving a middle school student who was suspended for reading to classmates his fictional story about a school killing spree that depicted him and several other students in sexual and violent situations.

The family of the boy, who was 10 at the time, argued that the punishment imposed by the 6,800-student Syosset Central School District, in Syosset, N.Y., violated his First Amendment right to freedom of speech.

Without comment, the justices refused on Jan. 22 to hear the appeal in D.F. v. Board of Education of Syosset Central School District (Case No. 06-542).

The court’s action was somewhat surprising because the justices agreed in December to review another student-speech case. That case involves a high school student at a parade in Juneau, Alaska, who raised a banner with a slogan that school officials contend promoted illegal drugs. The justices often defer action on appeals raising similar legal questions if they might be affected by a decision in the first case. Arguments in the so-called “Bong Hits 4 Jesus” case—Morse v. Frederick (No. 06-278)—are scheduled for March 19.

A Lurid Read

The New York state case originated at the Syosset district’s Thompson Middle School in the fall of 2003. The student, identified only as D.F. in court proceedings, wrote a lengthy story in his class journal that he allegedly modeled after the horror movie “Halloween,” according to the record cited in 2005 by the federal district court in Central Islip, N.Y.

The story tells of a boy with the same first name as D.F.’s who goes on a murderous rampage at school, brutally assaulting other students who have the same names as students at Thompson Middle School.

The story also describes a female student—with the same name as a student in D.F.’s class—in sexual situations and being attacked by the protagonist; at one point, she kisses him, despite her bloodied mouth, to save herself. Two other students are depicted having sex and then being attacked.

On Oct. 3, 2003, D.F. read the story to other students in class while the teacher, who arrived late, was distracted by checking attendance, according to the opinion by U.S. District Judge Thomas C. Platt Jr.

Later, the boy asked the supervising teacher at a voluntary lunchtime program for permission to read the story aloud, but that teacher reviewed the story and reported the boy to the principal.

The principal suspended D.F. for five days, and later, after a full hearing, the district’s superintendent imposed an additional 30-day suspension.

In their suit against the school district in the federal district court in Central Islip, the boy, now 12, and his father, Andrew Finkle, contended that the story was not a “true threat” and did not pose a substantial risk of disruption of school, which are requirements under case law for removing First Amendment protection from student speech.

In September 2005, Judge Platt granted the district’s motion to dismiss the case, noting that D.F. had repeatedly read excerpts of the story to other students.

“The story, with its graphic depictions of the murder of specifically named students and sex between named students, may materially interfere with the work of the school by disturbing the students and teachers,” the judge wrote. He added that the story “constitutes a true threat of violence, as it describes a student killing other real-life students.”

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit, in New York City, upheld the district court’s decision unanimously.

The court’s refusal to accept the appeal means the lower court’s decision stands.

Michigan Affirmative Action

In a separate order, issued Jan. 19, the Supreme Court turned down an emergency motion seeking to reinstate an injunction suspending a Michigan law that bars the state’s universities from using affirmative action in admissions.

Several Michigan groups had filed the request after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit, in Cincinnati, overturned on Dec. 29 a federal district court’s injunction suspending Proposition 2, which was passed by Michigan voters in November. A three-judge panel of the 6th Circuit court said the ballot initiative was likely to be upheld.

In December, the University of Michigan, Michigan State University, and Wayne State University dropped consideration of race and gender from their admissions policies.

But after the opponents asked Justice John Paul Stevens, as circuit justice for the 6th Circuit, to reinstate the injunction, the three universities and Michigan Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm, a Democrat, joined in support of that request.

In papers filed with Justice Stevens on Jan. 17, the universities contended that the abandonment of their former admissions policies was unfair to students who had applied for admission for the fall 2007 academic term.

But Michigan Attorney General Michael A. Cox submitted papers arguing that the stay by the appeals court should remain in place.

Justice Stevens referred the motion in Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action v. Granholm (No. 06A678) to the full Supreme Court, which denied the motion without elaboration.

Consideration of the merits of the challenge to the law is still pending in the lower courts.

A version of this article appeared in the January 31, 2007 edition of Education Week as Justices Decline Case on Student’s Violent Writing


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Student Well-Being Webinar
How Principals Can Support Student Well-Being During COVID
Join this webinar for tips on how to support and prioritize student health and wellbeing during COVID.
Content provided by Unruly Studios
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Professional Development Webinar
Building Leadership Excellence Through Instructional Coaching
Join this webinar for a discussion on instructional coaching and ways you can link your implement or build on your program.
Content provided by Whetstone Education/SchoolMint
Teaching Webinar Tips for Better Hybrid Learning: Ask the Experts What Works
Register and ask your questions about hybrid learning to our expert panel.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

CCLC Program Site Director
Thornton, CO, US
Adams 12 Five Star Schools
CCLC Program Site Director
Thornton, CO, US
Adams 12 Five Star Schools
Marketing Coordinator
Portland, OR, US
Northwest Evaluation Association
Sr Project Manager, Marketing (Temporary)
Portland, OR, US
Northwest Evaluation Association

Read Next

School Climate & Safety Boy, 15, Injured in Arkansas School Shooting; Classmate Held
A 15-year-old boy shot and seriously injured a fellow student Monday morning at an Arkansas junior high school, authorities said.
1 min read
Traffic is lined up March 1, 2021 outside Watson Chapel Junior High School in Pine Bluff, Ark. as parents pick up students after a shooting at the school.
Traffic is lined up March 1, 2021 outside Watson Chapel Junior High School in Pine Bluff, Ark. as parents pick up students after a shooting at the school.
Staton Breidenthal/The Arkansas Democrat-Gazette via AP
School Climate & Safety Interactive School Shootings This Year: How Many and Where
Education Week is tracking shootings in K-12 schools in 2021. See the number of incidents and where they occurred in our map and data table.
3 min read
Sign indicating school zone.
School Climate & Safety When Toxic Positivity Seeps Into Schools, Here's What Educators Can Do
Papering over legitimate, negative feelings with phrases like "look on the bright side" can be harmful for teachers and students.
6 min read
Image shows the Mr. Yuck emoji with his tongue out in response to bubbles of positive sayings all around him.
Gina Tomko/Education Week + Ingram Publishing/Getty
School Climate & Safety Opinion Teaching's 'New Normal'? There's Nothing Normal About the Constant Threat of Death
As the bizarre becomes ordinary, don't forget what's at stake for America's teachers during the COVID-19 pandemic, writes Justin Minkel.
4 min read
14Minkel IMG