The U.S. Department of Education’s office for civil rights will investigate whether a Georgia school district created a “hostile environment for girls” when it implemented a policy that allows transgender students to use restrooms and locker rooms that correspond with their gender identities.
The investigation comes after a parent claimed their daughter was sexually assaulted in the girls’ restroom at a Decatur City elementary school “by a male student who identified as gender fluid,” according to a Sept. 14 letter from the federal agency to an attorney for Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian organization that has opposed transgender student policies and helped file the Georgia complaint.
The office for civil rights will investigate both the district’s policy and how officials handled the family’s sexual assault complaint.
The district responded in a statement that said it is “committed to supporting all students.”
“We are aware of the unfounded allegations made by the Alliance Defending Freedom,” the statement said. “We fully disagree with their characterization of the situation and are addressing it with the Office of Civil Rights.”
If the complaint is found to be valid, the investigation could trigger a dramatic shift for how transgender students are treated in public schools and set the stage for legal battles between the federal government—which currently takes no position on transgender student rights—and states that identify gender identity as a protected class in their own laws and policies.
A growing number of states have such non-discrimination laws, which require schools to allow transgender students to use the restrooms and locker rooms of their choice. At issue in the complaint: Do such policies violate Title IX, the federal law that prohibits sex discrimination in schools, by creating a hostile and unsafe environment for girls?
One of U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos’ first official actions was to rescind Obama-era guidance, issued in 2016, that said public schools must allow transgender students to use the restrooms and locker rooms that match their gender identity, or risk a federal civil rights investigation. Citing growing court precedent, that guidance argued that Title IX applies to gender identity, rather than sex. In rescinding the guidance, DeVos and U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions took no position on the issue, leaving it to states and districts to interpret federal law.
Advocates for transgender students argue that allowing them access to school facilities that match their gender identity is an issue of basic dignity. In state-level hearings over possible school restrictions, mothers of some transgender students said their children had grown dehydrated when they refused to drink water at school to avoid the need to use restrooms where they felt unsafe.
Several federal judges have sided with transgender students in lawsuits over the issue, citing Title IX and the equal protection clause to the U.S. Constitution.
But opponents of providing such access argue that it violates the privacy rights of other students and creates potential safety risks if, for example, boys use them as an excuse to use girls’ facilities.
“This situation was both deeply tragic and avoidable,” Alliance Defending Freedom Attorney Christiana Holcomb said in a statement. “Schools have a duty to protect the privacy and safety of all students and Decatur Schools clearly failed this young girl. The current approach that many schools are taking of passing these transgender bathroom policies isn’t working; they fail to provide basic privacy or ensure the safety of all students.”
Advocates for transgender students pushed back Thursday. Schools have accomodated transgender students without problems for years, they said. Tweets from Eliza Byard, the executive director of GLSEN:
Something terrible happened to the victim in this case. Our heart goes out to this family, and we hope that the family and child receive all of the support that they need in the wake of this trauma.
-- Eliza Byard (@EByard) October 3, 2018
The National Center for Transgender Equality responded to the investigation with a statement:
Every allegation of sexual assault must be taken seriously, and each deserves a full, thorough investigation that respects the rights and privacy of survivors. We are deeply concerned, however, that the Department of Education will inject politics and ideology into its investigation of the school's handling of this incident. We know that policies affirming the rights of transgender students do not increase the safety risks for any child. Any argument otherwise ignores the support for these policies from hundreds of anti-sexual assault groups, every credible study on the topic, and the lived experiences of schools, students, and families across the country. Our heart breaks for anyone dealing with the trauma of sexual violence, but there is simply no basis to the notion that policies protecting transgender students contribute to that violence."
Photo: Getty Images
A version of this news article first appeared in the Rules for Engagement blog.