School & District Management

Collective Bargaining Case Gets High Court Spotlight

By Mark Walsh — January 28, 2014 4 min read

The U.S. Supreme Court has now heard arguments in a case with the potential to shake up the collective-bargaining landscape for teachers’ unions and other public-employee labor organizations.

Harris v. Quinn (Case No. 11-681), argued Jan. 21, is a relative sleeper involving eight Illinois home health-care workers (out of 28,000 in the state) who declined to join the union and object to paying agency, or “fair-share,” fees for being represented by one.

Anti-union advocates asked the justices to overrule a key 1977 precedent that authorizes public-worker unions to collect service fees from nonmembers for costs related to collective bargaining.

William L. Messinger, representing the objecting workers on behalf of the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation of Springfield, Va., told the justices that the 1977 decision, Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, should be discarded because compulsory fees infringe upon the First Amendment free-speech and -association rights of the objectors.

President Barack Obama’s administration joined the state of Illinois and public-employee unions in arguing against disturbing the labor-law landmark.

“There is very substantial … contractual reliance throughout the country on the constitutionality of Abood,” U.S. Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli Jr. told the court.

Signals From the Right

In Abood, the high court upheld a Michigan law that designated a single union as the exclusive bargaining agent for Detroit teachers. Adopting some of its precedents on private-sector “union shop” agreements, the court said teachers in public school districts could be required to pay union fees related to collective bargaining—but not for the union’s political purposes—whether they joined or not.

The Illinois case comes amid a backdrop of growing challenges for public-employee unions, from declining membership numbers to efforts in several states to roll back collective-bargaining rights.

“This potentially could be a very big deal,” Joseph E. Slater, a professor at the University of Toledo and a scholar of U.S. labor history, said in an interview.

Two years ago, in Knox v. Service Employees International Union, the court ruled 5-4 that public-employee unions had to get nonmembers to opt in to special dues assessments in certain circumstances. Writing for the majority in Knox, Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. invited further challenges to the status quo in public-employee unionism when he wrote that “our cases have substantially impinged upon the First Amendment rights of nonmembers.”

The national “right to work” movement picked up on the signal, and is advancing several cases designed to test the viability of precedents such as Abood. A group of nonunion teachers in California is challenging that state’s collective-bargaining law for teachers.

The Abood precedent, unsurprisingly, gets support from teachers’ unions. The National Education Association and its affiliate, the California Teachers Association, filed a friend-of-the-court brief in the Supreme Court saying Abood was rightly decided and remains viable. (The American Federation of Teachers didn’t file its own brief in the case, though the AFL-CIO, of which it is a member, did.)

The Illinois home-health workers serve under a Medicaid program designed to encourage the states to de-institutionalize some people with disabilities. The workers were getting paid about $7 per hour, with high rates of turnover and low morale, when Illinois decided to make them state employees for collective-bargaining purposes and to certify a union (the Service Employees International Union) as their bargaining representative.

Worker Turnover

In rejecting the challenge to the service fees by the objecting health workers, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit, in Chicago, held that the state largely controlled the employment of the program’s home-health workers and thus Abood applied to their collective-bargaining arrangements.

The National Right to Work foundation appealed, and significantly broadened the potential impact of the decision by asking the court to overrule Abood.

During the Jan. 21 oral arguments, there was as much discussion about teachers and their unions as there was about the home-health workers.

Justice Alito suggested that a nonunion teacher opposed to the union’s goals of keeping the tenure system and rejecting merit pay would nonetheless see some of his service fee go to support such goals.

Justice Anthony M. Kennedy questioned charging nonmembers for teachers’ union advocacy for smaller class sizes and shorter hours, matters that ultimately affect the size of the government workforce.

“Is not the size of government a question on which there are fundamental political beliefs, fundamental convictions that are being sacrificed if a nonunion member objects to this line of policy?” he said.

Justices Elena Kagan and Stephen G. Breyer, who voted for the union’s side in the 2012 Knox case, both expressed support for Abood as a matter of stare decisis, or adhering to precedent.

Justice Kagan told Mr. Messinger he was making “a radical argument” for ending compulsory fees that would essentially compel a right-to-work environment in all states, Kagan said.

Even if the court were to go as far as overruling Abood, Mr. Slater of the Toledo Law School said “there will still be public-sector unions around.”

A decision in the case is expected by late June.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the January 29, 2014 edition of Education Week as Collective-Bargaining Case Takes Spotlight at High Court


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Addressing Learning Loss: What Schools Need to Accelerate Reading Instruction in K-3
When K-3 students return to classrooms this fall, there will be huge gaps in foundational reading skills. Does your school or district need a plan to address learning loss and accelerate student growth? In this
Content provided by PDX Reading
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Equity & Diversity Webinar
Culturally Relevant Pedagogy to Advance Educational Equity
Schools are welcoming students back into buildings for full-time in-person instruction in a few short weeks and now is the perfect time to take a hard look at both our practices and systems to build
Content provided by PowerMyLearning
Classroom Technology Webinar Making Big Technology Decisions: Advice for District Leaders, Principals, and Teachers
Educators at all levels make decisions that can have a huge impact on students. That’s especially true when it comes to the use of technology, which was activated like never before to help students learn

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management Opinion A Crisis Sows Confusion. How District Leaders Can Be Clear in Their Messaging
Choosing a go-to source of information is a good starting point, but it doesn’t end there.
Daniel R. Moirao
2 min read
A man with his head in a cloud.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week and Getty Images
School & District Management Opinion COVID-19 Ripped Through Our Emotional Safety Net. Here’s How My District Responded
Three years after overhauling its approach to student mental health, one California district found itself facing a new crisis.
Jonathan Cooper
2 min read
A young man stands under a street light on a lonely road.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week and Getty Images
School & District Management Opinion Students Need Better Connections. To Wi-Fi, Yes, But Also to Teachers
We have to fix our digital divide, but let’s not lose sight of the relationship divide, writes one superintendent.
Susan Enfield
2 min read
A teacher checks in on a remote student.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week and Getty Images
School & District Management Opinion Superintendents Have Weathered a Lot of Vitriol This Year. What Have We Learned?
The pandemic turned district leaders into pioneers, writes one superintendent. We had to band together to make it through.
Matthew Montgomery
2 min read
A person walks from a vast empty space towards a team of people.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week and Getty Images