December 10, 2016

Published: October 1, 2005

Letter

Meeting of Minds

Article Tools
  • PrintPrinter-Friendly
  • EmailEmail Article
  • ReprintReprints

You profiled a teacher who laments that once the kids leave him, they lose their way, yet he resorts to punishment and consequences as motivators [“One-Track Minds,” August/ September]. Yes, they score high on standardized tests while in school, but Randall Youngblood admits that once they leave his structure, “he sees the patterns repeat themselves—former students faltering, dropping out, getting into trouble. ... He knows there’s nothing he can do to keep their worlds from crumbling around them.”

Then, in the same issue, you profile [Nelson Beaudoin,] an administrator who tells us, “The lesson here for educators is that seeking to inspire will pay greater dividends than seeking to control” [“Vocal Arrangement”]. What would be most interesting is having these gentlemen meet and hash it out. Who’s right? The desire to force kids to perform well while in our grasp or the desire to allow kids to find their way, despite the mess it may create and leave behind?

Diane Mierzwik
Yucaipa, California

Vol. 17, Issue 02, Page 6

Back to Top Back to Top

Most Popular Stories

Viewed

Emailed

Commented

MORE EDUCATION JOBS >>

Advertisement

Advertisement

MORE EDUCATION JOBS >>

TM Archive