English-Language Learners

Bilingual Education Works, Study Finds

By James Crawford — March 25, 1987 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Bilingual education last week won its second endorsement in 10 days from an independent panel of experts.

“Dual-language instruction improves both academic achievement and English proficiency,’' concluded a seven-member committee on bilingual education convened by the Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. The A.S.C.D. announced the study’s findings during its annual conference in New Orleans.

In a separate study released this month, a majority of experts polled by the General Accounting Office disagreed with statements by the U.S. Education Department that research findings are inconclusive about the value of native-language instruction. (See Education Week, March 18, 1987.)

The A.S.C.D.'s report, “Building an Indivisible Nation: Bilingual Education in Context,’' concludes that there is considerable evidence for the effectiveness of bilingual education.

It argues, however, that the question, “Does bilingual education work?’' is overly simplistic, and that it fails to recognize the complexity of the subject.

“Rather than emphasize research that might give insights to teachers on effective classroom practices and how they might help limited-English-proficient students,’' the report says, public debate has “expended ... much energy on research of questionable quality and validity that asks, ‘Has it worked?’''

The criticism apparently refers to reviews of program-evaluation research, which the Education Department cites in arguing that the case for native-language instruction is too weak to justify mandating that approach in programs supported by federal bilingual-education grants.

Because much of that research “has been plagued by methodological problems,’' the A.S.C.D.'s panel said, “findings are equivocal’’ about the comparative effectiveness of differing instructional methods for LEP students.

Research Findings

But the report, which reflects a consensus of the panelists’ views, features research findings about the success of various bilingual methods in the classroom. For example, it states:

  • When bilingual instruction lays “a strong foundation in the native language, [it] makes learning a second language both easier and faster.’' Students in such programs often, it says, learn more English than those in English-only programs.
  • Literacy skills and academic knowledge “transfer readily from one language to another, so that students do not have to relearn in a second language what they have already learned in a first.’'
  • There are cumulative benefits of bilingual instruction: “The longer students remain in a bilingual program, the higher their academic achievement, as measured in English, is likely to be. Studies of native speakers of Spanish and Navajo show that students who remain in a bilingual program for five or six years may reach or exceed national norms in achievement.’'

Structured Immersion

The A.S.C.D. report contains virtually no discussion of “structured immersion,’' an English-only approach that has been promoted as an alternative to bilingual education.

Research on immersion programs for language-minority students has been limited. The Education Department’s contention that this method “shows great promise’’ was disputed by the G.A.O.'s study.

“School authorities should be aware of the larger social issues in which the [bilingual-education] controversy is enmeshed,’' the A.S.C.D.'s panel said, noting that the assimilation of new immigrants and the preservation of minority languages and cultures are highly charged political issues.

Educators should “refuse to let emotional arguments dictate instruction,’' the panel said, while bringing to language-minority students “the same concern for individuality and unique potential that they bring to other youngsters.’'

In addition, they wrote, “programs for LEP students should be an integral part of the school in terms of curriculum, instructional design, staff development, and supervision.’'

The A.S.C.D.'s panel was headed by Jack Levy, professor of education at George Mason University. It also included: Diane G. Berreth, director of field services for the A.S.C.D.; Esther Eisenhower, bilingual coordinator for the Fairfax County, Va., public schools; Edward Fuentes, director of research and evaluation for the Education Department’s office of bilingual education and minority languages affairs; Gonzalo Garza, associate superintendent of the Austin, Tex., public schools; Kenji Hakuta, associate professor of psychology at Yale University; and Muriel Saville Troike, professor of educational psychology at the University of Illinois.

A version of this article appeared in the March 25, 1987 edition of Education Week as Bilingual Education Works, Study Finds

Events

Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
Ed-Tech Policy Webinar Artificial Intelligence in Practice: Building a Roadmap for AI Use in Schools
AI in education: game-changer or classroom chaos? Join our webinar & learn how to navigate this evolving tech responsibly.
Education Webinar Developing and Executing Impactful Research Campaigns to Fuel Your Ed Marketing Strategy 
Develop impactful research campaigns to fuel your marketing. Join the EdWeek Research Center for a webinar with actionable take-aways for companies who sell to K-12 districts.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

English-Language Learners Nuanced Accountability Would Help English Learners. New Research Shows How
A new report offers suggestions on how states can approach federal accountability measures with more nuance for English learners.
5 min read
The child is studying the alphabet.
Germanovich/iStock/Getty
English-Language Learners Opinion How to Connect With English-Language Newcomers. Teachers Share Their Favorite Lessons
Stock classrooms with books that reflect students’ lives, languages, and cultures and invite them into as yet unfamiliar worlds.
10 min read
Images shows colorful speech bubbles that say "Q," "&," and "A."
iStock/Getty
English-Language Learners Do Immigrant Students Help the Academic Outcomes of U.S.-Born Peers? One Study Says Yes
Schools and districts across the country have recently been reporting larger numbers of immigrant student enrollment, researchers say.
5 min read
Eric Parker teaches a class NW Classen High that has immigrant students and he has a flag representing each, which is a way to make them feel welcome, Tuesday, September 10, 2019.
Eric Parker teaches a class NW Classen High that has immigrant students and he has a flag representing each, which is a way to make them feel welcome, Tuesday, September 10, 2019. In a study published in the Review of Economic Studies last year, researchers analyzed population-level school records and birth records from Florida to measure the impact of immigrant students on U.S.-born peers’ academic outcomes.
Doug Hoke/The Oklahoman via AP
English-Language Learners Federal Funding for English Learners Has a New Home. What Do Educators Hope This Means?
$890 million in Title III grants moved to the federal office of English language acquisition in December.
4 min read
Billy Lopez and Indica Beckham read together during kindergarten class at Fairview Elementary in Carthage, Mo., on Nov. 26, 2018. The Carthage School District, along with three other Missouri districts, is participating in a $2.6 million five-year grant project that seeks to bolster its English Language Learners program. The grant will provide ELL training to teachers in the Carthage, Kansas City Public, Bayless and Columbia school districts.
Billy Lopez and Indica Beckham read together during kindergarten class at Fairview Elementary in Carthage, Mo., on Nov. 26, 2018. The Carthage School District, along with three other Missouri districts, is participating in a $2.6 million five-year grant project that seeks to bolster its English Language Learners program.
Roger Nomer/The Joplin Globe via AP