Two high-profile public-opinion polls released this month offer contrasting snapshots on the public’s support for common-core standards and mandatory standardized testing—intertwined issues that are arguably among the most divisive in K-12 public education.
Often released within days of each other, the education survey by Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup—now in its 47th year—and the one conducted since 2007 by Education Next, a journal from the Hoover Institution at Stanford University, deliver new data that fuel debate and reflection on topics ranging from teacher quality to school funding.
This year’s PDK/Gallup poll reveals that a majority of respondents, including 54 percent of public school parents, oppose having teachers use the Common Core State Standards to guide what they teach.
While the Education Next poll also shows public support for the common standards slipping to 49 percent and mounting dissatisfaction among teachers, with 50 percent opposed to the standards, its results show that backers of the initiative continue to outnumber opponents.
A report accompanying the Education Next findings attributes broad opposition to the common core to a “shallow factual foundation,” because 60 percent of its poll respondents didn’t know whether their districts use the common core, and 23 percent of residents in non-common-core states believe their local districts are using the standards.
The polls’ divergent results on some topics should be of little surprise: While both surveys have nationally representative samples, they take distinct approaches to assess the public’s mood.
The results largely depend on how you “ask the questions,” said Paul E. Peterson, one of the authors of the Education Next report and a professor at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government.
Joshua Starr, the CEO of Phi Delta Kappa International, said it’s important to have multiple assessments of the public mood.
“At best, the data help you ask better questions,” said Starr, a former superintendent in the Montgomery County, Md., and Stamford., Conn., districts.
“There’s a messy middle you have to operate in,” he added. “Lawmakers are hearing from people at the extremes. We all need a more nuanced view of the complexity of public education.”
Public Forums Ahead
The PDK/Gallup poll found most Americans, overall, think there is too much emphasis on standardized testing in public schools, but blacks and Hispanics are more likely than whites to think that test results are useful tools to measure school quality and improve schools.
Conducted in May, the poll surveyed 3,500 people via the Internet and 1,000 people by telephone. The first-time Web survey allowed pollsters to capture greater detail on racial and ethnic groups. The Education Next poll, conducted online and via telephone, has been able to capture similar detail since its first edition.
Phi Delta Kappa will host a series of public forums to explore and discuss its results. A report accompanying the PDK/Gallup findings also offers a guide on how to localize the poll results to spark community conversations about school quality.
While roughly half of all PDK/Gallup respondents gave the schools in their own communities a grade of A or B, only 23 percent of blacks and 31 percent of Hispanics would give their neighborhood schools such high marks.
“We can no longer just say ‘parents feel’ or ‘Americans feel,’ ” Starr said. “We need to understand that there are differences ... and bring those perspectives together.”
The racial and ethnic divide in the school assessment results from the Education Next poll was much less stark, with 46 percent of blacks and 51 percent of Hispanics giving their neighborhood schools an A or B.
Overall, 52 percent of the survey respondents would give their community schools high marks.
Among the PDK/Gallup poll’s other findings: A majority of Americans think half, or fewer, of public school students are receiving a high-quality education, and respondents think teacher quality trumps other factors when it comes to improving school quality.
Results Align on Choice
The Education Next poll surveyed 4,083 adults in May and June, and found a declining, but still significant appetite for school choice.
When compared with the 2014 results, the new Education Next survey reveals a slight decline in support for charter schools to 51 percent from 54 percent, tax credits for scholarships for low-income students slipped to 55 percent from 60 percent. Support for tuition vouchers for low-income students dropped to 34 percent from 37 percent.
“One hesitates,” the authors write in their analysis, “to read too much into shifts in opinion that are only modestly larger than what a statistical aberration might account for.”
Support for school choice and a desire for reducing the federal government’s role in turning around struggling schools were issues where the poll results most closely aligned.
The PDK/Gallup poll found that nearly two-thirds of poll respondents support the idea of charter schools and say parents should be able to choose any public school in their community.
In an essay accompanying the PDK/Gallup results, Starr suggests broadening the school choice discussion beyond pro-charter and anti-charter stances and debate over school vouchers to “provide children and parents what they want and need to be successful.”
Only about 1 in 5 respondents to the PDK/Gallup poll think the federal government should determine how to hold poorly performing schools accountable and decide the amount of testing in schools.
The Education Next poll found that “people clearly want the feds in the back seat when it comes to identifying failing schools.”
But when it comes to the hot-button issue of testing, the polls diverged.
The Education Next poll found that only a quarter of the public supports the opt-out movement, the push among parents in some communities to refuse to allow their children to take common-core-aligned or other standardized tests.
Among parents, 52 percent dislike the idea of letting parents decide whether their children are tested, while 57 percent of teachers are opposed.
The Education Next poll also found that 67 percent of the public supports a federal requirement for annual testing, while teachers remain split on that issue. “The backlash against standardized testing appears less potent than opponents claim,” the Education Next authors write.
Conversely, the PDK/Gallup poll found that 64 percent of Americans think there is too much emphasis on standardized testing and less than 20 percent consider test scores a good gauge of school effectiveness and student performance.
Most respondents think parents should have the right to opt their children out of testing, but few said they would exercise that right. Notably, 28 percent of black respondents said test results were a solid measure of school effectiveness, compared to 14 percent of parents overall.
A version of this article appeared in the August 26, 2015 edition of Education Week as Polls Reveal Nuanced K-12 Views