Special Education

Disability-Rights Groups Spar Over Special Ed. Restraints

By Christina A. Samuels — November 09, 2010 5 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

A Senate bill that would prohibit restraint and seclusion from being used to control students with disabilities is causing a split among some disability-rights advocates.

The bill, sponsored by U.S. Sens. Christopher J. Dodd, D-Conn., and Richard M. Burr, R-N.C., would place an absolute ban on certain restraining techniques, such as holds that impede breathing or mechanical and chemical restraints. Other types of restraints and seclusion could be used only if a student was a serious danger to himself or others and less-restrictive interventions would be ineffective.

But the measure does allow restraints or seclusion to be included as a planned intervention in a student’s individualized education program if the student has a history of dangerous behavior.

Exception Stirs Concern

That IEP exception has thrown some groups that were once united in favor of a federal ban on restraint and seclusion into conflict. Some advocates say that school personnel will default to those techniques if they are an option.

The exception gives the techniques “a false sense of legitimacy,” said Denise Marshall, the executive director of the Council of Parent Attorneys and Advocates in Towson, Md. The Council For Exceptional Children, a professional organization of teachers, administrators, and parents in Arlington, Va., also opposes the bill.

But an organization that played a key role in bringing attention to injuries and deaths caused by restraint and seclusion has come out in favor of the bill, saying that it is imperfect but better than no national prohibition at all.

If this bill dies, I doubt we're going to see any movement on this for years to come."

“We made a political calculation after surveying our states,” said Curtis L. Decker, the executive director of the National Disability Rights Network in Washington. The organization’s report last year on abusive restraints and seclusion was the genesis of the most recent federal efforts to address the practice.

“If this bill dies, I doubt we’re going to see any movement on this for years to come,” Mr. Decker said.

The strongly held differences in opinion, plus the change in the political make-up of Congress following this month’s elections, makes the future uncertain for a federal ban.

Even if the measure were to pass in the Senate unchanged, it would still have to be reconciled with a more-restrictive House bill on restraints and seclusion that passed in March. The House bill bans restraints and seclusion from being considered as an intervention in a student’s IEP.

An earlier version of the Senate bill also had such a ban. But that bill was withdrawn and a new bill submitted in September, when Mr. Burr was added as a co-sponsor.

Advocacy groups have been fighting for years against schools’ use of restraints and seclusion. The issue came to the forefront in January 2009 after the National Disability Rights Network, which represents advocacy agencies around the country, released an investigative report called “School Is Not Supposed to Hurt.”

The report documented chilling examples of restraint and seclusion misuse, including cases of students suffocating to death while being held in prone restraints, or locked for hours in “time-out” rooms. Seclusions or restraints were being used as punishment rather than as a way to prevent harm to the student or staff members, the report said.

Laws ‘Widely Divergent’

U.S. Rep. George Miller, D-Calif., asked the U.S. Government Accountability Office to follow up with its own report. Released in May, that report noted that there were “widely divergent” laws governing restraints and seclusion at the state level.

In Texas, one of the few states that collects data from schools on the use of restraints and seclusion, 4,202 students were restrained 18,741 times in the 2007-08 school year, the report noted.

In July 2009, U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan sent a letter to state education leaders, telling them to develop policies on restraint and seclusion or revise them if necessary.

The U.S. Department of Education does not have a position on the IEP exception, said Alexa E. Posny, the assistant secretary for the office of special education and rehabilitative services, during the question-and-answer portion of an autism policy meeting held in October at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

“We understand the issue on both sides,” she said. “I know once it’s [the use of restraints and seclusion] put into an IEP, it looks like we have given carte blanche approval to have that done. And on the other side, if you don’t have it in an IEP and [school personnel] have to use it under some emergency circumstances, have we set up a lawsuit?”

We're told, 'We have to keep our relationships with the politicians.' This isn't about your relationship with the politicians. This is about the kids."

Mr. Decker said he agrees that IEPs should be “a treatment document, and not a vehicle for discipline.” But he says that opponents of the Senate bill are “starry-eyed people who don’t take into consideration the political realities.” The bill includes some important monitoring provisions, and a requirement that parents be notified if restraint or seclusion is used with their child, he said, and future work with Congress could add even more protections.

Other organizations that have made the same assessment include Children and Adults with Attention Deficit/HyperactivityDisorder, an advocacy group in Landover, Md. “CHADD would prefer the legislation did not include this [IEP] provision, but feels the benefits of the bill outweigh these concerns,” the organization said in a statement.

Parent Voices Ignored?

Leslie Seid Margolis, a managing lawyer at the Baltimore-based Maryland Disability Law Center, and board member of the Epilepsy Foundation of America, said she’s dealt with many cases where school staff members escalate conflicts with students into physical confrontations. Parents who may want to go to due process to have such an intervention taken out of an IEP are at a disadvantage to districts, she said.

And Tricia and Calvin Luker, the parents of a child with a disability and two of the organizers of a group called Our Children Left Behind, reject the notion that the Senate bill is the best that advocates can get in this political climate. They say parent concerns are being pushed aside.

“We’re told, ‘we have to keep our relationships with the politicians.’ This isn’t about your relationship with the politicians. This is about the kids,” said Ms. Luker, who lives in Royal Oak, Mich.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the November 10, 2010 edition of Education Week as Disability-Rights Groups Spar Over Special Ed. Restraints


Student Well-Being Webinar After-School Learning Top Priority: Academics or Fun?
Join our expert panel to discuss how after-school programs and schools can work together to help students recover from pandemic-related learning loss.
Budget & Finance Webinar Leverage New Funding Sources with Data-Informed Practices
Address the whole child using data-informed practices, gain valuable insights, and learn strategies that can benefit your district.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Classroom Technology Webinar
ChatGPT & Education: 8 Ways AI Improves Student Outcomes
Revolutionize student success! Don't miss our expert-led webinar demonstrating practical ways AI tools will elevate learning experiences.
Content provided by Inzata

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Special Education Quiz How Does Special Education Funding Work? Test Your Knowledge
What is IDEA? How much can the federal government contribute to special education funding? Take our quiz.
1 min read
Image of a student working with a teacher.
Special Education How Teachers Can Help Students With Dyslexia: What Our Readers Say
EdWeek's social-media followers weigh in on how to support students with dyslexia, a learning disability that interferes with reading.
5 min read
Young school boy writing in a notebook while sitting in a library with an educator.
Special Education Explainer How Special Education Funding Actually Works
Special education is among the most complicated and misunderstood facets of America’s sprawling K-12 school landscape.
6 min read
Illustration of a desk with a calculator and budget sheet.
Special Education Spotlight Spotlight on Special Education Compliance
This Spotlight will help you examine implementation of universal screening for dyslexia and more.