Curriculum

Can Critical Thinking Be Too Critical?

By Ellen Wexler — May 30, 2014 2 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

According to Wesleyan University President Michael Roth, the first thing inquisitive students do when they read a new text is point out exactly what’s wrong with it.

The reason for this, Roth argues in a New York Times commentary, is that in a classroom setting, intelligence is becoming equated with debunking, unmasking, and exposing. If you’re a good student, you can argue why the authors you read are wrong—but that isn’t necessarily the best way to learn.

Roth says that when students feel the need to find flaws in every text they study, they lose the ability to use those texts to create meaning and find inspiration. Students are rewarded for their cynicism in classrooms, but that cynicism will harm their ability to engage with compelling ideas throughout their lives.

“As debunkers,” Roth writes, “they contribute to a cultural climate that has little tolerance for finding or making meaning—a culture whose intellectuals and cultural commentators get ‘liked’ by showing that somebody else just can’t be believed.”

Throughout the piece, Roth labels this focus on poking holes in arguments as “critical thinking"—a term that is being increasingly emphasized in K-12 education. If teachers place too much emphasis on critical thinking, Roth argues, students will become immune to texts that might otherwise challenge their beliefs about the world:

Hard-nosed critical thinking is a useful tool, but it also may become a defense against the risky insight that absorption can offer. As students and as teachers we sometimes crave that protection; without it we risk changing who we are. We risk seeing a different way of living not as something alien, but as a possibility we might be able to explore, and even embrace.

About a week after Roth’s piece ran in The New York Times, Noah Berlatsky, a correspondent for The Atlantic, published a response critiquing Roth’s position on criticism.

“So here I am doing that thing that Roth doesn’t want me to do,” Berlatsky writes. “I am not taking his writing as an opportunity for inspiration. Instead I am finding in it material to object to. Mea culpa.”

According to Berlatsky, it’s impossible to decide which texts are beyond critique. For instance, it makes little sense to examine political writings without examining their flaws, too: “Should we open ourselves and be absorbed and inspired by Birth of a Nation? By Mein Kampf?” he asks. What about the speeches of George W. Bush or Bill Clinton?

Berlatsky argues that there is no difference between ordinary thinking and what Roth defines as critical thinking. When you form an opinion about a piece of art, how can that opinion be unrelated to your critical evaluation of that art?

“If I love Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet,” Berlatsky writes, “how is that love separable from my evaluation of his use of language, his subtlety of characterization, or his criticism of the protagonists’ families?”

According to Roth, overly-critical students will devalue the arguments of the authors that they study. Berlatsky counters students study those authors for a reason—their arguments are the best of the best. They can withstand student criticism.

“The truth is, Emerson doesn’t need help,” Berlatsky writes. “James Baldwin doesn’t need protection from students. Away with this trembling art. Give me art that gets stronger when you fight it, not weaker. Give me the art that’s left after the hammer comes down.”

What’s your view as a K-12 educator? Is criticism an essential component of critical thinking? Can it go too far—or become too much of a impulse—and detract from deeper learning? Both Roth and Berlatsky were primarily talking about college students—and even in the comments sections on both of these pieces, we found very few posts from K-12 teachers. We’d like to hear what you’re seeing in your classrooms.

Related Tags:

A version of this news article first appeared in the Teaching Now blog.


Commenting has been disabled on edweek.org effective Sept. 8. Please visit our FAQ section for more details. To get in touch with us visit our contact page, follow us on social media, or submit a Letter to the Editor.


Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Teaching Webinar
What’s Next for Teaching and Learning? Key Trends for the New School Year
The past 18 months changed the face of education forever, leaving teachers, students, and families to adapt to unprecedented challenges in teaching and learning. As we enter the third school year affected by the pandemic—and
Content provided by Instructure
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Curriculum Webinar
How Data and Digital Curriculum Can Drive Personalized Instruction
As we return from an abnormal year, it’s an educator’s top priority to make sure the lessons learned under adversity positively impact students during the new school year. Digital curriculum has emerged from the pandemic
Content provided by Kiddom
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Equity & Diversity Webinar
Leadership for Racial Equity in Schools and Beyond
While the COVID-19 pandemic continues to reveal systemic racial disparities in educational opportunity, there are revelations to which we can and must respond. Through conscientious efforts, using an intentional focus on race, school leaders can
Content provided by Corwin

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Curriculum What's the Best Way to Address Unfinished Learning? It's Not Remediation, Study Says
A new study suggests acceleration may be a promising strategy for addressing unfinished learning in math after a pandemic year.
5 min read
Female high school student running on the stairs leads to an opportunity to success
CreativaImages/iStock/Getty Images Plus
Curriculum School Halts Use of Fictional Book in Which Officer Kills a Black Child
Fifth graders in at least one Broward County school were assigned to read a book that critics say casts police officers as racist liars.
Rafael Olmeda, South Florida Sun-Sentinel
5 min read
Broward County School Board member Lori Alhadeff listens during a meeting of the Broward County School Board, Tuesday, March 5, 2019, in Fort Lauderdale, Fla.
Broward County School Board member Lori Alhadeff listens during a meeting of the Broward County School Board in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. Alhadeff told the South Florida Sun-Sentinel that she does not feel like the book "Ghost Boys" is appropriate for 5th graders.
Lynne Sladky/AP
Curriculum Opinion Introducing Primary Sources to Students
Five educators share strategies for introducing primary sources to students, including English-language learners.
12 min read
Images shows colorful speech bubbles that say "Q," "&," and "A."
iStock/Getty
Curriculum Opinion Eight Ways to Teach With Primary Sources
Four educators share ways they use primary sources with students, including a strategy called "Zoom."
13 min read
Images shows colorful speech bubbles that say "Q," "&," and "A."
iStock/Getty