Tussle Over English-Language Learners

By Mary Ann Zehr — January 30, 2007 7 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
ESL teacher Kristin Yoder Kauffman explains the word "shuddering" to 4th and 5th graders during their two-hour reading class at Virginia's Waterman Elementary School, in Harrisonburg.

Fifth grader Any Samaria and 4th grader Maliksha Dursunov are both classified as English-language learners, but both can confidently read aloud in English from books at a 1st grade level. And they’re quickly picking up some of Virginia’s required academic skills for reading, such as how to identify a “problem” in a story.

Even so, the three teachers for their reading class of beginning English-learners at Waterman Elementary School in the heart of Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley oppose making the students take the state’s regular reading exam at their official grade levels, as federal officials would require.

After all, Any (pronounced AH-nee) came from Honduras only about a year ago, and Maliksha, a Meskhetian Turk from Russia, arrived less than a year ago. The two still struggle to speak full sentences in English.

Teacher Carissa J. Sweigart works with students on a writing activity at Waterman Elementary School in Harrisonburg, Va. The city's school board is resisting a federal mandate that English-language learners take the regular state reading exam.

“I’ve seen enormous gains since the beginning of the school year,” said Carissa J. Sweigart, a 4th grade teacher for the class, “but we can’t expect them to jump up all those levels of reading” to understand and pass a grade-level standardized test.

So this month, the members of the Harrisonburg City school board unanimously passed a resolution refusing to go along with a federal demand that Virginia schools stop using an English-language-proficiency test instead of the state’s regular reading test to calculate adequate yearly progress, or AYP, for beginning English-learners.

Elsewhere in the state, the Fairfax County school board passed a similar resolution last week and the Prince William County board did earlier this month. The Arlington County and Fairfax City districts are considering doing the same.

Tom Mendez, a Harrisonburg school board member and father of six, believes the federal officials aren’t taking into consideration the different paces at which children acquire English. “Bureaucracy doesn’t make exceptions,” he said. “We see it differently.”

He said it could cripple students’ self-esteem and “set back the learning process” to make beginning English-learners take a test they have no chance of passing.

School board Chairman Michael Walsh added that the testing requirements of the federal education law seem to be based on the idea that children are “square pegs fitting into square holes,” when, in fact, schoolchildren are diverse and not all suited to taking the same test.

Immigrant Influx

In the past decade, Harrisonburg, which has a population of 43,500, has become a magnet for immigrant families drawn to jobs in the poultry and construction industries. More than 1,600 of the school district’s 4,400 students are English-learners. The largest group of newcomers are Latinos, followed by Kurdish and Russian refugees.

District administrators have responded to the influx by standardizing the curriculum for English-language learners, hiring more English-as-a-second-language teachers, employing bilingual parent liaisons and interpreters, and adding classes with intensive instruction for newcomers, such as the reading class with three teachers for 14 students at Waterman Elementary.

The city’s Keister Elementary School was selected by the U.S. Department of Education as a Blue Ribbon School in 2004. That same year, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation chose Harrisonburg High School as one of the nation’s 30 model high schools. Among the city’s six schools, which all have a large number of English-learners, only the middle school failed to make the AYP requirements under the No Child Left Behind Act last school year.

Harrisonburg Superintendent Donald J. Ford sees it as an “intrusion” that the federal government is telling Virginia school districts that they have to change their testing policy for English-language learners, against the advice of local educators.

Mr. Ford and the school board members don’t believe that by resisting a change in policy they’ll lose any of the $980,000 in federal funds that the district receives for disadvantaged students under Title I of the NCLB law.

“I do not believe we are breaking the law,” said Mr. Ford. In his view, the district is “voluntarily” not trying to meet the bar set by the federal law for participation in testing, which is 95 percent participation by all students. Under the law, students are tested in reading and mathematics annually in grades 3-8 and once during high school.

About 250 English-learners would be affected if the district were to go along with the federal mandate. By refusing to have all eligible students take the test, school officials acknowledge that the district will not meet the AYP requirements. But the same would happen if all the English-learners were to take the regular reading test, since many would fail, Mr. Ford said.

Officials of the U.S. Department of Education didn’t respond last week to a request for comment on whether Virginia districts that refuse to change their testing policies for English-learners are, in fact, breaking the law.

Mr. Ford and the school board members would rather have Harrisonburg schools fail to meet AYP for having low testing participation than to see the schools fail because some English-learners didn’t pass the regular reading test. He considers it as unfair and morally wrong to give students a reading test they can’t read and understand.

Complex Debate

The Harrisonburg debate is complicated by the fact that some English-language learners in the first two of four proficiency levels can read English to some degree, though they may not yet have caught up with native English-speaking peers. When regulations were being considered for testing English-learners under the 5-year-old federal law, many educators said the decision should be tied to a child’s English-proficiency level. Others advised that students shouldn’t be expected to take a grade-level test in reading until they had attended U.S. schools for up to five years.

In September, U.S. Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings announced that the federal government had produced final regulations requiring English-learners to be included in regular state reading tests after they had attended U.S. schools for a year. (“Spellings Issues Final Regulations for Testing of English-Learners,” Sept. 20, 2006.)

Harrisonburg educators generally agree with Virginia’s existing policy, which is to give the regular reading test to students only at the upper two levels of English proficiency. They applaud the school board in resisting the federal mandate to change that policy.

Learning to Read

Had the Harrisonburg school board not voted otherwise, many of the children in a special class for English-learners at Waterman Elementary school would be affected this school year by the federal mandate for Virginia schools to change how they test such students. (“States Adopt New Tests for English-Learners,” Jan. 24, 2007.) All of them are still at Level 1 or 2 in English proficiency.

Of Maliksha and Any’s reading group of five on an afternoon last week, three children have been in the United States long enough that they would have to take the regular reading test this school year.

ESL teacher Kristin Yoder Kauffman explains the word "shuddering" to 4th and 5th graders during their two-hour reading class at Virginia's Waterman Elementary School, in Harrisonburg.

During a read-aloud exercise, Any mistook the word “it” for “I” while reading Molly’s Broccoli, written by Deborah Eaton and rated at a 1st grade reading level. She also got stuck on “mole” and “moose,” but could sound out all the other words. On a worksheet, she correctly identified in writing the “problem” in the story: Molly doesn’t want to eat broccoli. Identifying a story’s problem is a concept that might appear on the state’s standardized reading test for her grade.

When Kristin Yoder Kauffman, an ESL teacher, taught the word “smash,” Maliksha asked if it was a “synonym” of the verb “bump.” The concept of synonyms also is something that might be assessed by the regular reading test. But the children obviously had a lot to learn in English. They struggled, for example, to distinguish the “sh” and “ch” sounds in words, and were confused about whether to select “am,” “is,” or “are,” to make a subject and verb agree when crafting a sentence.

Their teachers point out that the No Child Left Behind law does require schools to give all English-language learners—no matter how long they’ve been in U.S. schools—each individual state’s English-language-proficiency test. They believe that requirement is appropriate, and say the results of an English-proficiency test provide useful information about how children are progressing.

Children in the afternoon reading class here aren’t ready, though, to take the regular Virginia standardized paper-and-pencil reading test, said Jenny R. Hartwig, the 5th grade teacher for the class.

“They may understand the concept, but it’s not presented on the test in a way they can pass,” she said.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the January 31, 2007 edition of Education Week as Tussle Over English-Language Learners


Classroom Technology Webinar How Pandemic Tech Is (and Is Not) Transforming K-12 Schools
The COVID-19 pandemic—and the resulting rise in virtual learning and big investments in digital learning tools— helped educators propel their technology skills to the next level. Teachers have become more adept at using learning management
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Data Webinar
Using Integrated Analytics To Uncover Student Needs
Overwhelmed by data? Learn how an integrated approach to data analytics can help.

Content provided by Instructure
School & District Management Live Online Discussion Principal Overload: How to Manage Anxiety, Stress, and Tough Decisions
According to recent surveys, more than 40 percent of principals are considering leaving their jobs. With the pandemic, running a school building has become even more complicated, and principals' workloads continue to grow. f we

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal School Boards, 'Domestic Terrorism,' and Free Speech: Inside the Debate
From critical race theory to COVID policy, the heat on schools has raised issues involving free speech and the safety of public officials.
13 min read
Brenda Stephens, a school board member with Orange County Public Schools in Hillsborough, N.C. has purchased a weapon and taken a concealed carry class over concerns for her personal safety.
Brenda Stephens, a school board member in Hillsborough, N.C., says board members face threats and bullying, an atmosphere far different from what she's encountered in years of board service.
Kate Medley for Education Week
Federal Senate Confirms Catherine Lhamon to Civil Rights Post; Kamala Harris Casts Decisive Vote
Joe Biden's controversial pick to lead the Education Department's office for civil rights held that job in the Obama administration.
2 min read
Catherine Lhamon, nominee to be assistant secretary for civil rights at the Department of Education, testifies during a Senate Health, Education Labor and Pensions Committee confirmation hearing in Dirksen Building on Tuesday, July 13, 2021.
Catherine Lhamon, then-nominee to be assistant secretary for civil rights at the U.S. Department of Education, testifies during a Senate Health, Education Labor and Pensions Committee confirmation hearing in July.
Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call via AP Images
Federal White House Outlines COVID-19 Vaccination Plans for Kids 5-11
The Biden administration will rely on schools, pharmacies, and pediatricians to help deliver the COVID-19 shots to younger children.
3 min read
Ticket number 937 sits on a COVID-19 vaccination at the drive-thru vaccination site in the Coweta County Fairgrounds on Jan. 14, 2021, in Newnan, Ga.
A ticket number sits on a COVID-19 vaccination at the drive-thru vaccination site in the Coweta County Fairgrounds in Newnan, Ga.
Curtis Compton/Atlanta Journal-Constitution via AP
Federal California, Florida, and Other States Waiting on Green Light for Their COVID Relief Plans
The list of states with Ed. Dept. approval for their American Rescue Plan blueprints is growing steadily, but two big states aren't on it.
4 min read
Image shows an illustration of money providing relief against coronavirus.
DigitalVision Vectors/iStock/Getty