School Choice & Charters

Reporter’s Notebook

May 31, 2000 3 min read

Conflicting Views on the Effects of School Choice on Integration

As policymakers continue to push for programs that allow parents to pick their children’s schools, researchers gathered here last week warned that free-form educational choice could lead to greater racial isolation of students.

“It’s not clear to me what are the conditions that would bring about greater racial integration; it is clear to me what will not,” Rosalyn Mickelson, a sociology professor at University of North Carolina in Charlotte, said during a May 22 conference on choice and racial diversity hosted by the National Center for the Study of Privatization at Teachers College, Columbia University.

“A sloppy or half-baked choice plan” will lead to racial segregation in schools and school systems, Ms. Mickelson argued. “Racial integration is not always possible, but when it is possible I think we need to defend it and cherish it.”

With the era of court-ordered desegregation and mandatory busing giving way to the rise of alternatives like magnet schools, charter schools, and privately funded tuition-voucher programs, there is a growing debate about whether these new arrangements are leading to racial isolation.

With few exceptions, most of the attendees at last week’s conference voiced doubts that racial equality in the nation’s schools could be maintained under choice plans that don’t include measures specifically aimed at that goal.

One study examined whether charter schools were the result of “an emerging market for a new model of equity.” In it, researchers Carol Ascher and Nathalis Wamba of the Institute for Education and Social Policy at New York University contend that even if charter schools offer an alternative to the one-size-fits-all approach of regular public schools, they don’t necessarily offer an “education that carefully helps individual children blossom and thrive.”

Furthermore, Ms. Ascher said, “there is beginning evidence nationally that charter schools may be furthering economic and racial isolation.”

Others, however, questioned whether racial balance should take priority over the belief of some parents that charter schools and other alternatives can provide a better education than the traditional public school system.

“The demographics of charter schools need to be monitored and the outright or even subtle forms of inequity need to be addressed,” said Pearl Kane, an associate professor of education at Teachers College. “However, ... as far as parents of color are concerned, there may be more interest in educational quality than desegregation.”

Jay P. Greene, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, argued that vouchers are a way of combating the racial inequities of the regular public school system because they offer poor minority families the choices long enjoyed by affluent whites. “If we’re looking at ways to improve racial integration and schools, we ought to be looking at ways to expand educational opportunities to families,” he said.

In another study of racial segregation and private and public school choice, a University of California, Santa Cruz, economics professor found possible evidence that private-school vouchers or other school-choice programs may lead to increased segregation.

For his study, Robert W. Fairlie used data from the National Educational Longitudinal Study and the National Center for Education Statistics.

Lower levels of income among African-American and Hispanic families contribute substantially to the fact that far fewer of these students attend private schools than whites, Mr. Fairlie said. And the private schools that whites attend tend to be less integrated than public schools, while blacks and Hispanics attend private schools that are slightly more integrated than public schools.

“These findings can be interpreted as providing both evidence that vouchers will lead to increased segregation and evidence suggesting that vouchers will lead to decreased segregation,” he said, prompting laughter from his audience.

Furthermore, Mr. Fairlie made the case that “a definitive answer to whether vouchers will increase racial segregation is not possible until several large-scale experimental programs have been implemented and evaluated.”

Only three states have publicly funded voucher programs—Florida, Ohio, and Wisconsin—and the longest-running of these, in Milwaukee, is barely 10 years old. Other researchers argued, however, that there is enough evidence available to warn federal and state policymakers who are pursuing expanded school choice programs.

“It’s too easy for us as academics to say we need more research,” said Jay Heubert, an associate professor of education at Teachers College. “In many states and districts, the train is leaving the station.”

—Darcia Harris Bowman

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the May 31, 2000 edition of Education Week as Reporter’s Notebook


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Recruitment & Retention Webinar
Recruiting and Retaining a More Diverse Teaching Workforce
We discuss the importance of workforce diversity and learn strategies to recruit and retain teachers from diverse backgrounds.
Content provided by EdWeek Top School Jobs
Student Well-Being Webinar Boosting Teacher and Student Motivation During the Pandemic: What It Takes
Join Alyson Klein and her expert guests for practical tips and discussion on how to keep students and teachers motivated as the pandemic drags on.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Student Well-Being Webinar
A Holistic Approach to Social-Emotional Learning
Register to learn about the components and benefits of holistically implemented SEL.
Content provided by Committee for Children

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Meredith, New Hampshire
Inter-Lakes School District
Elementary Principal
Washington State
Wenatchee School District
Meredith, New Hampshire
Inter-Lakes School District
Elementary Principal
Washington State
Wenatchee School District

Read Next

School Choice & Charters Letter to the Editor Are NOLA Charters a Mixed Bag?
To the Editor:
The opinion essay by Douglas N. Harris about how New Orleans’ education reforms post-Katrina are relevant to the COVID-19 era (“As Schools Recover After COVID-19, Look to New Orleans,” Sept. 30, 2020) highlights some basic improvements in the NOLA system but downplays the most significant aspects of those changes: the impact on people of color.
1 min read
School Choice & Charters Home Schooling Is Way Up With COVID-19. Will It Last?
The shift could have lasting effects on both public schools and the home-schooling movement.
10Homeschool IMG
School Choice & Charters Opinion Challenging 3 Common Critiques of School Choice
A new volume from Corey DeAngelis and Neal McCluskey challenges some of the familiar but suspect assertions that pepper public debates about school choice.
3 min read
School Choice & Charters Briefly Stated Briefly Stated: Stories You May Have Missed
A collection of stories from the previous week that you may have missed.
8 min read